Comparative Analysis of 2 Bone Graft Materials in Socket Preservation

Comparative Analysis of Healing Outcomes Between Two Bone Graft Materials in Socket Preservation Procedure

Socket preservation procedures after tooth extraction have been designed and implemented to maintain the volume of the bone and gingival tissues, which can decrease following the extraction of the teeth. In this clinical trial we will compare clinically and histologically the effectiveness of two distinct bovine bone graft materials; an allograft and a xenograft, in alveolar ridge preservation procedures following tooth extraction .

Patients who seek socket preservation procedures will be identified and recruited from the out clinic of College of Dentistry. Inclusion criteria will be: systemically healthy, non-smoking patients aged 21-50 years, with no bone metabolism affecting medications, good oral hygiene (full-mouth plaque score <20%), and willingness to participate. Exclusion criteria included stage III/IV periodontitis, active periodontal lesions, acute infection, severely resorbed sockets (buccal bone height <5 mm), smoking >10 cigarettes/day, and pregnancy.

Indications for extraction include caries, failed endodontic treatment, unrestorable teeth, and tooth fracture. All patients underwent full periodontal examination and initial therapy (oral hygiene instructions, scaling, and root planing) at least 4 weeks before surgery. Preoperative CBCT scans will be analyzed for baseline conditions. Reference stents will be fabricated and used to standardize bone dimensional measurements.

Sample size estimation was based on detecting a mean dimensional change in ridge width following 2-3 months of healing. With SD = 10%, α = 0.05, and power = 80%, a minimum of 9 sockets per group (18 total) was deemed adequate.

Surgical Protocol All surgical procedures will be performed under local anesthesia (2% lidocaine with 1:100,000 epinephrine). A sulcular incision will be made with a 15c blade, and atraumatic extraction will be achieved using periotomes, tooth separation, and forceps while preserving the buccal plate. Following thorough socket debridement, the buccolingual ridge width will be measured using a periodontal probe and customized stent.

Patients will be randomly allocated into one of two treatment groups:

Group 1: Allograft group (n=9) Group 2: Xenograft group (n=9) In all cases, graft material will be condensed gently from the apical region. Sockets will be covered with a collagen membrane and closed with 4-0 PTFE sutures.

All patients will receive standard postoperative care including: amoxicillin 500 mg TID for 7 days, ibuprofen 600 mg BID, and 0.12% chlorhexidine rinse BID for 7 days (starting 48h post-op). Sutures will be removed after 14 days. Patients will be recalled at 2-3 months for CBCT scans with an identical machine and settings. Buccolingual ridge width and buccal bone thickness will be assessed by superimposing baseline and follow-up scans.

At 3 months, crestal/intrasulcular incisions will be made and flaps elevated for re-entry. Biopsies will be obtained using a 2.0-mm trephine bur (8 mm length) from all grafted sites. A total of 27 biopsies (9 per group) will be collected, coded, and fixed in 10% neutral buffered formalin. Osteotomies will be completed, and implants will be placed per manufacturer protocol.

Inclusion Criteria:

• • Systemically healthy individuals

  • Non-smokers
  • Age between 21 and 50 years
  • Indicated for tooth extraction and socket preservation
  • Good oral hygiene (full-mouth plaque score <20%)
  • Willingness to participate and provide informed consent

Exclusion Criteria:

• • Stage III or IV periodontitis

  • Active periodontal or periapical infection
  • Severely resorbed sockets (buccal bone height <5 mm)
  • Smoking more than 10 cigarettes per day
  • Pregnancy
  • Systemic conditions or medications affecting bone metabolism