The Effectiveness of Smartphone Delivered Interval Walking Training on Physical Activity and Glycemic Control in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes: a Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial - Part of The InterWalk Study
The Effectiveness of Smartphone Delivered Interval Walking Training on Physical Activity and Glycemic Control in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes: a Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial - Part of The InterWalk Study
Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) is one of the most common chronic diseases world vide. Patients with T2D experiences reduced quality of life and have a lower physical activity level. Physical activity is well documented treatment to the patient group. The effect of physical activity is shown to reduce co-morbidity, and better functional level and quality of life.
Interval Walking Training (IWT) is a new and effective exercise type. IWT is done by walking in a slow and a fast tempo. InterWalk is an application to a smartphone. By using InterWalk the patient can to IWT independently and when used, the app has, as an exercise tool, the potential to better the individual functional level and to measure the physical activity level with the integrated personalised walking test.
Motivation for change of habits and lifestyle is subjectively determined by the individual, his or hers individual resources and environment. It is important to get insight in these individual challenges in order to be better structure possible help.
The combination of an exercise log, a measure of physical activity fromInterWalk and insight in motivational aspects on an individual level, is essential for successful individualised training.
The primary objective of the study is to investigate if the InterWalk app is more effective in increasing the physical activity level compared to a standard care offer in a sample of newly T2D diabetes patients across 52 weeks.
Secondarily, we will investigate if the IW app can reduce sitting time, induce weight loss, improve glycaemic control, increase quality of life, improve cardio-respiratory fitness and reduce the use of diabetes medication.
The study is designed to test the hypothesis that replacing a standard exercise program in the normal municipal standard care with the Interval Walking Training delivered by the IW app with and without a motivational support program, can increase the long-term physical activity level in patients with T2D for a period of 52 weeks.
From January 2015 to June 2016 all patient's with T2D, who are referred to the promotion centres in the municipality, will be offered to participate in the study. In total 513 patients with T2D from different municipalities in Denmark will be included and randomly allocated into three groups. One group will receive standard care and the two other groups will do IWT with the InterWalk app. All three groups are followed by the promotion centre for 8-14 weeks (according to the rehabilitation in the municipality) and hereafter only one of the IWT groups will receive motivational support up to 52 weeks.
All patients, no mater group allocation, will be tested and fulfill questionnaires, three times during the intervention period - at baseline, after 8-14 weeks and after 52 weeks. The interventions take place at the promotion centres in the municipalities two times a week and the patient will be encouraged train by them selves one time a week.
Background Type 2 diabetes (T2D) is one of the most common long-term medical conditions worldwide. The patients have a two-fold increased mortality rate compared to the general population T2D is a major problem in Denmark and the incidence is estimated to rise from 280.000 today to approximately 500.000 people by 2020 (5).
The T2D rehabilitation program in the Danish municipalities has the overall purpose of introducing and helping patients to a healthier lifestyle (6). The program is conducted in a period of 8-14 week with some or no exercise intervention, with no long-term follow-up. Not much is known on the amount and integration of PA in the patient's everyday life following the intervention (7). This major variation across municipalities poses a problem in the rehabilitation of TD2, as the quality of rehabilitation depends on the geographical location of the T2D patient.
Several studies have shown that supervised PA is advantageous; in patients with T2D on key metabolic factors (6-9) and that it improves quality of life and reduces the risk of all-cause mortality (1,2,6,10,11,12). Due to the many beneficial effects of PA on T2D patients, PA is an important factor in the prevention and treatment of T2D (13). Long-term PA interventions have employed supervised exercise regimes (14,15) that are effective, but also demanding and expensive. Attempts to increase the daily physical activity level on a large scale, in a free-living "real life", have very little effect (14-16) despite well-established patient education programs. In general, the exercise adherence is low and dropout rates are high in this group of patients. A large number of patients with T2D experience diminished quality of life, decreased physical functioning, diminished exercise tolerance (17), numerous patients are unmotivated or incapable to change behaviour and the prevalence of depressive and anxiety symptoms are highly prevalent in T2D patients (17,18,19). Collectively this could pose important barriers to engagement in exercise and reaching the recommended level of PA (20).
Karstoft et al (2013) examined the feasibility of implementing a free-living interval walking (IWT) and continuous walking training program in a smaller sample of patients with T2D. IWT was initiated and monitored by a Japanese training device, the JD-mate (10). The study found remarkable effects on physical fitness level, body composition and glycaemic control and with a compliance rate of more than 85% and a very low dropout level (9). Based on the experiences by Karstoft et al and several pilot testing's in the Danish Diabetes Association (DF), we believe that IWT can be an approach to handle lack of PA in patients with T2D. However the JD-mate, is expensive (3500 kr.), Japanese instructions, lacks automatic transmission of data and is thus not user-friendly on a larger scale. It is evident that novel low cost, more sustainable exercise solutions and suitable vehicle are needed and through this, improve quality of life and increase life expectancy in these patients.
The use of Tele-Health interventions (THI) have the potential to educate and engage patients with T2D in self-management in the long-term and the evidence suggests that THI could be effective and feasible in improving clinical outcomes in diabetes care (14,15,22,23). The widespread and increasing use of smartphone applications is opening new ways to improve health and health care delivery. It might be ideal to use THI to increase physical activity and hereby target a large part of the population by simple and inexpensive means. The smartphone has been used as a tool among others to register exercise, diet, weight and plasma glucose levels, but the evidence of using a smartphone as an exercise device is lacking (24).
In 2010 the Danish Centre for Strategic Research in Type 2 Diabetes (DD2) and TrygFondens Centre for Aktiv Sundhed (CFAS), Rigshospitalet, Denmark, developed the InterWalk Application (IW app) to the smartphone to promote IWT on a larger scale. IWT has the potential to increase physical activity in a large group of T2D patients and hopefully improve lifestyle in patients with T2D. However, motivation for lifestyle changes is subjectively driven and individually determined (25-27). The personal resources and the close environment are key determinants of how challenges are handled in everyday life (28,29). Motivational factors are important for changing physical activity behaviour in patients with T2D, but knowledge on how motivation is maintained for a sustainable active lifestyle is limited. Studies of the effectiveness of employing smartphones as a vehicle to improve physical activity behaviour in everyday life in the long-term in patients with T2D is therefore needed.
Aim/purpose - (Hypothesis) The primary objective of the study is to investigate if the InterWalk app is more effective in increasing the moderate-and-vigorous physical activity level compared to a standard care offer in a sample of T2D patients across 52 weeks.
Secondarily, we will investigate to what extend the IW app can reduce sitting time, induce weight loss, improve glycaemic control, increase quality of life, improve cardio-respiratory fitness and reduce the use of diabetes medication.
The primary hypothesis is to test the hypothesis, that replacing a standard exercise program in the normal municipal standard care with the Interval Walking Training delivered by the IW app, the patient will become more physical active. The secondary and explorative hypothesis is that motivational support will increase the individual long-term physical activity level in everyday in patients with T2D.
Methods Study design The study is a 52-weeks single-blinded pragmatic randomized controlled trial, where the participants are allocated into three arms. Two of the arms will receive IWT with or without additional support. The control arm will receive the standard care. The interventions are delivered by the Danish municipalities. A detailed description of the three arms is found below. The study is carried out in a subgroup of the DD2 cohort.
Participants, Recruitment and eligibility All patients referred to the promotion centre in the municipalities from January 2015 will be screened for eligibility. The patients will be informed about the study and will be given formalized oral and written material, a consent form and a free post envelope. Upon reception of the consent form by the health professional at the municipality, the patient will be contacted by one of the health professionals assigned to the study and a date for the first visit is arranged.
Enrolment is anticipated to take approximately 18 month and begins in January 2015, and is expected to be completed in July 2017. The intervention will take place at the promotion centres in municipalities in Denmark.
Sample size considerations The minimum difference of interest (MDI) is 10 minutes per day. After applying Bonferroni adjustment due to multiple comparisons in the three group trial and shared end-points, a total of 393 participants are needed using an sample SD of 25 minutes per day (30) with an α of 0.017 (two-tailed) to obtain a statistical power (1-β) of 80%. Allowing for an attrition rate of 30%, 513 patients (171 in each group) are allocated in the three arms.
Allocation, randomization and concealment Patients are randomized using random permuted blocks (2x2x2) and stratified by gender to ensure an equal number of participants in all groups across the allocation period. The allocation sequence is generated through a standardized computer program by an independent researcher not affiliated to the study and is concealed until the study arms are assigned. Randomization of each patient to one of the three groups in the study is done after the baseline tests have been conducted by the health professionals at the promotion centres. The scientific staff is blinded to the allocation. The health professionals at the promotion centre are not blinded to allocation according to control group (1/3) or intervention groups (1/3: IWT and 1/3: IWTsupport). After the intervention period at the promotion centre, the allocation to either control, IWT or IWTsupport is unsealed to the patients and the health professionals at the promotion centres. The scientific staff is still blinded.
Interventions Group 1 (control group): Patients in this group will receive the standard rehabilitation program with the overall purpose of lifestyle changing in T2D patients in a multimodal setting in the municipality including physical activity. In addition to exercise, the rehabilitation consists of education, smoking cessation and dietary change with the purpose of weight loss, motivation groups and self-care. The duration of the rehabilitation differs between municipalities with duration from 8 to 14 weeks. There will be no follow-up from the municipality, which is the normal procedure in the municipality.
Group 2 (IWT with without motivational support after 8-14 weeks): Patients in this group will be engaged to IWT with the IW app (see: The InterWalk Application). The intervention period will follow the period in which the rehabilitation program is carried out in the municipality (duration from 8-14 weeks). The patients are encouraged to perform IWT three times per week, 60 minutes per session. The municipality offers to walk with the patient´s two times per week for 60 minutes per session in group sessions with additional 30 minutes of group discussion afterwards. The last and third time the patients have to walk by themselves for 60 minutes per session. The participating patients will receive a thorough introduction to the IW app and follow-up during the intervention (8-14 weeks) from the health professionals. At the end of the intervention period, the health professionals, conducts a transition program, preparing the patients to continue IWT with IW app on their own. There will be no follow-up from the municipality, which is the normal procedure in the municipality.
Group 3 (IWTsuppport) IWT with motivational support after 8-14 weeks: Patients in this group will like patient´s in intervention group 2 be engaged to IWT with the IW app. The intervention period will be 52 weeks. The first 8-14 weeks will be conducted together with group 2 with a thorough introduction to the IW app and IWT three times per week for 60 minutes. In addition to the IWT from week 0 to 52, the patients in this group will receive motivational support from week 8-14 to week 52 by the health professionals at the promotion centre (see below for information regarding the IW app and the motivational support part).
The InterWalk Application The IW App is a personal trainer as well as a monitor unit, which allows continuous and automatic transmission of physical activity data to a central data base in DD2. The IW app guides the user in IWT with repeated cycles of 3 minutes fast and slow walking. During IWT the app provides the patients with continuous feedback on the walking intensity (10). The feedback is personalized through a standardized eight-minute walking test, performed before engaging in IWT. The patients are able to track exercise history and receive historic feedback on the quality of the IWT sessions. The feedback system employs the on-board accelerometer and GPS system to assess intensity and geographical location.
The patients are obligated to enter their social security (CPR) number before using the app. Uniquely, this will allow the scientific teams to integrate the app into the health care system, link the data with the Danish disease and demographic registers and thus, will enable the study of long term nation-wide effects of IWT in T2D rehabilitation.
The application has been through extensive piloting in different groups of patients with T2D. Information on training intensity, total number of steps per day and IWT-data and data from the standardized walking test is stored on the smartphone or IPod and automatically transmitted to a central database when connected to Wi-Fi or mobile data network.
Individual motivation (IWTsupport) Motivational support will in addition to the IWT be offered in intervention group 2 after the intervention at the promotion centre. The support is initiated and conducted by the health professionals at the promotion centres.
Individual goal setting: To measure the patients motivation for physical activity using the IW app in group 2 and 3, we ask the patients to set individual goals every 4th week, related to their everyday life, during the intervention period (group 2 (4-18 weeks) and group 3 (0-52 weeks) (40) - The goal setting is based on the S.M.A.R.T.-principle where S stands for Specific, M for Measurable, A for achievable , R for relevant and T for timely (41).
- IWTsupport group sessions: Patients in group 3 have the opportunity to participate in IWT with other patient and a InterWalk ambassador at the municipality once a week after the intervention at the promotion centre.
Motivational interviews: Four motivational interviews will be scheduled for patients in group 2, in the period where the patient no longer is part of the formalised IWT in the municipality (week 12-52). The aim of these interviews is to help he patients to maintain motivation and focus tin prioritizing IWT in their everyday life. The interview will take place at the promotion centre.
Measurements
Electronic log of data from IWT to the central database Adherence to the intervention is determined by an evaluation of the electronic log of data from IW app to a central database. All the uploaded data can be quantified into adherence.
The NEO-FFI consists of 60 questions in a 0-4 Likert format constructed by selecting 2 items from each of the six facets characterizing each of the five personality traits (Neuroticism, Extraversion, Openness, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness) assessed by NEO-PI-R (36).
The Sensation Seeking Scale is a 40 items self-administered questionnaire and consists of 40 questions designed to test the tendency towards varied, novel and intense sensations (37). The SES-questionnaire is in its design impertinent as it consists of only two possible response options for each question. The patient will be encouraged to answer the questions, but is not required an answer.
We do not know much about what characterizes the individual to either participate or to decline an intervention e.g. diet, smoking cessation or physical activity. The two personality questionnaires are part of the project because it is essential to get more knowledge on personality traits, risk behavior and adherence to an intervention in this case physical activity. By this knowledge it will be possible to better individualize the intervention and by this hopefully get a higher adherence in the long term.
Risk, side effects, and discomfort General considerations The exercise intervention (Interval Walking Training) is expected as a minimum to be as effective as the standard care programme currently offered to patients with T2D at the municipality. Interval walking Training with the use of a Tele-Health solution is providing patients with T2D with a feasible option on how to implement and maintain a physical active lifestyle in a gentle and flexible way. The intervention is expected to result in remarkably health benefits on a long-term basis in terms of improved increased VO2max, blood glucose regulation, and quality of life and motivation for a more active everyday life.
The study is important and will contribute to great knowledge about how to implement and thus increase public health in a large and growing cohort of patient´s with T2D.
Measurements Smartphone administered walking test: The patients are expected to reach 80-85% of VO2max during the IW walking test. This will cause some degree of breathlessness.
AX3 Axivity accelerometers: Due to the patched by which the accelerometers are hold on the thigh and lower bag, itching and redness may occur in allergic subjects. In those cases the subjects are encouraged to remove the patches immediately and if necessary consult a general practitioner. The patients will be informed on procedures in writing containing pictures of the application of accelerometers and possible discomfort.
Interval walking training: The IWT will cause some degree of breathlessness in the fast walking interval periods.
Anthropometric measurements, sit-to-stand test, temperature, questionnaires and motivational initiatives: These methods are not associated with any known risk or other unpleasant.
Statistical analysis All analyses will be conducted according to the Intention-to-treat principle. Mixed model analyses will be employed to determine the group X treatment effects of the intervention across twelve months. The secondary outcomes will be analyzed using the same approach. Assuming that the data on potential drop-outs are missing at random multiple imputation procedures will employed to handle missing data. Patterns of missing data will be investigated. Per protocol analyses will be performed to support the primary analysis.
Ethical considerations The study is expected to result in limited risks, adverse effects and discomfort to the patients. No invasive methods will be used besides blood samples taken by the GP at regular visits. The patients will benefit from the study in terms of enhanced physical capacity and by introduction to effective training methods.
The randomization of the participating patients into three groups is necessary to evaluate the effectiveness of the InterWalk app. The intervention groups (group 2 and 3) are alike as long as the standard rehabilitation with physical activity proceeds in the municipality. From hereafter only group 3 will be supervised and will receive motivational support from the health professionals. This differentiation between groups is needed in order to obtain insight regarding motivational factors of importance to the individual, to maintain a physical active everyday life.
The two personality questionnaires in the study will help to get insight on personality, physical activity and motivation for behavioural changes (e.g. more physical active everyday life). With this knowledge, the results from the study can help the health professionals at the promotion centres, to better allocate patients with T2D, into a rehabilitation offer adjusted to the individual and not as a standard offer in the municipality.
Expected outcomes Performing IWT might be a suitable and effective way to exercise for at large group of patients with T2D. The patient can walk everywhere and IWT can hereby be integrated and maintained in the patient's everyday life. Experiences from the study can be used in planning interventions with the IW app and IWT, to patients with other lifestyle diseases e.g. Constructive Obstructive Pulmonary Lung Disease (COPD) and Heart Diseases. The aim is to obtain lifelong physical activity for the individual in their everyday life.
Patient insurance The intervention takes place at the promotion centres in the Municipality and the patient is, if anything should happen during the intervention period, insured by 'Patient Forsikringen'. The law says '…personer, der deltager i biomedicinske forsøg m.v., der udføres af private firmaer, foreninger m.v. er omfattet af lovens område, hvis forsøget udføres under direkte ansvar af et sygehus, en statslig højere uddannelsesinstitution m.fl.'. The University of Copenhagen is the 'statslige højere uddannelsesinstitution in this study.
Protection of personal information All personal information on the patient's identities are protected by the "Lov om behandling af personlige oplysninger". A unique subject ID number will be subscribed to all patients in order to anonymize data. The identification key (ID to personal information) will be encrypted and stored securely and separately from the unique ID number on a secure database. In this way no information on patient´s can be assigned to the ID number. All data is automatically backed up on a secure server. Questionnaires is completed online and automatically uploaded with the ID number to the secure data base.
Each promotion centre will be assigned with secured logons to the database and only the health professional assigned to the study, will get logons and will only be able to see the patients included in the study at their promotional centre. The scientific members have access to the secure database and data from all the included patients. All data will be secured in the database and a bag up of all the data is stored in an extern hard disk which is also secured. It is possible to track all logons to the database as well as all tasks done in the database.
To enter the IW app the patients are obligated to enter their CPR number, which immediately are encrypted to protect against inappropriate use of the number from unauthorised people not connected to the study. The health professionals in the municipalities will be educated in data entry and will only have access to their own promotion centre. Only the research team will have access to data processing.
The IW app is already approved by "Datatilsynet" (2008-58-0035 (paraplygodkendelse i Region Syddanmark)) and the RCT-study will in addition be reported to "Datatilsynet".
Compensation There will be no compensation given to the patient. All participating patients are treated in accordance with the national guidelines regarding rehabilitation in the municipality.
Dissemination The data will be published in international peer-reviewed journals. The results are to be reported according to the CONSORT guidelines (38). All results will be disseminated (negative, positive and inconclusive findings). All result will be published (positive, negative and inconclusive).
For references - see the section 'References'
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: