Nursing Intervention in Two Risk Factors of the Metabolic Syndrome, Abdominal Obesity and Arterial Hypertension, and Quality of Life in the Climacteric Period
Nursing Intervention in Two Risk Factors of the Metabolic Syndrome, Abdominal Obesity and Arterial Hypertension, and Quality of Life in the Climacteric Period
The estrogenic deficit characteristic of the climacteric stage is accompanied by a high incidence of health problems, such as the presence of Metabolic Syndrome risk factors that contribute to the increase of cardiovascular diseases.
Objective: To determine the effect of a nursing intervention based on self-care aimed at improving the control of two metabolic syndrome risk factors (abdominal obesity and arterial hypertension) and health-related quality of life in climacteric women.
Material and methods: Quasi-experimental study, non-equivalent control group design with women between 40 and 59 years old who present two risk factors of the Metabolic Syndrome (abdominal obesity and arterial hypertension) from two type C Health Centers of District 17D03 of Quito, Ecuador. Among one of the conceptual hypotheses, the researchers have Conceptual hypothesis 1: Climacteric women of the experimental group after the intervention of Nursing based on self-care improve two risk factors of MS with respect to those of the comparison group. A sample of 40 women was selected for experimental group and 40 for comparison group. Instruments and measurements: Abdominal Circumference, Blood Pressure, Menopause Rating Scale, International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ). Women in both groups received the usual care and those in the experimental group received a Nursing Intervention with technological support that included individual face-to-face nursing counseling, group education and physical activity sessions through a virtual platform for 12 weeks. Ethical requirements were considered.
Expected results: It is expected that after the Nursing Intervention based on self-care the women of the experimental group will decrease the parameters of abdominal circumference, blood pressure and improve health-related quality of life.
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Presentation and rationale of the problem During the last decade, health needs have been changing, with a significant increase in the life expectancy of the population in general and with it the increase of non- communicable diseases, which threaten the health and development of people, especially in developing countries, being predicted for the year 2050.
The World Health Organization (WHO) considers noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) to be the leading cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide, killing 41 million people each year, which is equivalent to 71% of deaths worldwide. Specifically, among individuals aged 30-69 years, 15 million die each year from this type of disease and more than 85% of these premature deaths occur in low- and middle-income countries. According to WHO projections, annual deaths from noncommunicable diseases will increase to 55 million by the year 2030, which at an economic level will bring consequently a high cost to the countries of the world, constituting one of the greatest challenges facing health systems.
Because of the context presented and the projected data, the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development recognizes NCDs as a major obstacle to development, WHO has developed the Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of Noncommunicable Diseases 2013-2020 to address them. This is expected to reduce premature deaths by 33% by 2030 through prevention and treatment of these conditions (target 3.4 of the Sustainable Development Goals).
Regarding cardiovascular diseases, it is mentioned that the risk factors that are closely related to them are: causal (hypercholesterolemia, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking and age), predisposing (obesity, sedentary lifestyle, family history, sex and psychosocial factors) and conditional (hypertriglyceridemia, high LDL-oxidized, high prothrombotic factor and microalbuminuria), increasing their suffering.
About predisposing factors, it is necessary to consider that the female population is the most affected by cardiovascular diseases because they have a significantly higher risk of mortality, due to their biological difference as well as the complex interactions of cultural and socioeconomic conditions. In this regard, the researchers must consider that female sex, gender, ethnicity, hormonal changes, onset of menarche, pregnancy, premature birth, presence of pathologies such as gestational hypertension, polycystic ovary and menopause, combined with the epidemiological and demographic transition, which have changed habits and lifestyles, further condition the presence of cardiovascular diseases. In addition, the life expectancy of women worldwide has risen considerably and they spend a third or more of their lives after the climacteric period with some risk factor.
The climacteric stage is a physiologically normal period that should be observed due to the permanent cessation of menstruation, after the disappearance of ovarian activity produced by estrogenic decline, which is found between 45 and 55 years of age, marking the end of reproductive life, experiencing physical and emotional changes, because of a series of endocrinological, biological and clinical processes. The hormonal deficit, typical of this stage, is accompanied by a high incidence of problems in women's health (80% hot flashes, night sweats, sleep disorders, fatigue, and depression), as well as the presence of metabolic risk factors that contribute to the increase of cardiovascular diseases, such as acute myocardial infarction.
In this context, the so-called Metabolic Syndrome or Syndrome X arises, characterized by the presence of abdominal obesity, arterial hypertension (AHT), insulin resistance, glucose metabolism disorders and atherogenic dyslipidemia related to metabolic, vascular, inflammatory, fibrinolytic and coagulation abnormalities.
Studies conducted in several countries worldwide indicate that the prevalence of Metabolic Syndrome is found in 60% of the female population and increases in menopause. Thus, studies have shown a high prevalence of Metabolic Syndrome in pre- and postmenopausal women, according to NCEP/ATPIII criteria, with prevalence's ranging from 26.1 to 50.5%, with Ecuador and South Korea standing out in this last group.
That is why the prevalence of Metabolic Syndrome in the climacteric stage constitutes an entity of high epidemiological impact due to the metabolic changes that modify body composition, verifying an increase in weight, insulin resistance and visceral fat, and changes in lipid metabolism and estrogen deficiency that cause deterioration of endothelial function. In addition to the above, hypertension is another factor present among climacteric women with metabolic syndrome. The increase in blood pressure in patients with MS is mainly due to insulin resistance, which causes three actions in the body: increased bioavailability of endothelial nitric oxide; increased activation of the Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System (RAAS) and the endothelin system; changes in the hormonal milieu and a decrease in the autonomic nervous system. In summary, estrogen deficiency can induce sympathetic hyperactivity and endothelial dysfunction by direct effect on the vessels as well as by age-related deleterious effect on the vascular endothelium.
Clinical and epidemiological studies indicate that middle-aged women have at least one independent risk factor for chronic diseases. With this risk approach, it becomes evident how significant preventive work is, aimed at conrolling, reducing and eliminating the risk factors of the Metabolic Syndrome that can complicate the overall health of women at this stage.
Thus, the approach to abdominal obesity and arterial hypertension is particularly relevant in women in the climacteric stage, since women experience during the climacteric period an increase in weight gain and an increase in abdominal adiposity, being this accumulation of visceral fat the major determinant of MS, which is evidenced in 70% of the female population, primarily due to hypoestrogenemia related to metabolic changes, whose distribution is android type, and due to the decrease in muscle mass secondary to the decrease in physical activity. To this is added the approach to arterial hypertension because its prevalence and incidence exceeds the other risk factors of MS by 55%. As arterial pressure is a modifiable risk factor, interventions have been made to control it to levels below 140 mmHg for the systolic and 90 mmHg for the diastolic, reducing cardiovascular risk by 2 to 3% for each mmHg that the diastolic blood pressure (BP) is reduced (TAD).
In addition, the association between the two components of MS (abdominal obesity and hypertension) and the severity of climacteric symptoms have caused negative consequences for women's health, specifically in the domains of physical and psychological health, leading to a deterioration of HRQOL. It is therefore important to consider in all research, the perception of women about their health status, making them active participants in this process, their assessment and contribution is essential to take preventive and therapeutic measures, adapted to the cultural environment in which they are, in order to provide health services, prevent disability and premature death, increasing the years of healthy life and quality of life during the third of their life. It should be noted that there are few intervention studies that integrate the association between the components of MS and quality of life in climacteric women, demonstrating the need to address these variables.
It is therefore essential to carry out comprehensive interventions, undertaking strategies aimed at the promotion and prevention of pathologies prevalent in the climacteric period, such as the Metabolic Syndrome, to reduce cardiovascular risk. It is here that primary health care plays a transcendent role in the control of risk factors, in this context the prevention activities imply behavioral modifications in which educational intervention, health advice and the use of technologies have been effective resulting in the improvement of the quality of life.
In this scenario, the nursing professional plays a crucial role since studies show the nurse's responsibility in the implementation of strategies to contribute to the control of modifiable risk factors of MS, actively involving women in the participation of their own health status. Among some interventions carried out by nurses, there are motivational and technological programs that included physical activity, adequate nutrition, and individualized counseling in women with MS older than 40 years and postmenopausal, reporting positive results in the increase of health- related quality of life in the woman's life and in the control of MS risk factors. However, the inclusion of health-related quality of life and the use of nursing models and theories to guide interventions has been scarcely visible in this type of studies.
Therefore, the following study question leads to the formulation of the problem: What is the effect of a nursing intervention based on self-care to reduce two components of MS (abdominal obesity, hypertension) and improve health-related quality of life in women in climacteric stage attending primary health care centers in the city of Quito- Ecuador? 1.3 HYPOTHESIS
Conceptual Hypothesis 1:
Climacteric women in the experimental group after the self-care nursing intervention improve two MS risk factors over those in the comparison group.
Working hypothesis:
Conceptual Hypothesis 2: Climacteric women in the experimental group after the self- care-based nursing intervention improve health-related quality of life relative to those in the comparison group.
Working hypothesis:
Conceptual Hypothesis 3: Climacteric women in the experimental group after the self- care-based nursing intervention improve self-care agency by increasing physical activity relative to those in the comparison group.
Working hypothesis:
• Climacteric women in the experimental group improve their level of physical activity after the self-care-based nursing intervention compared to those in the comparison group.
1.4 GENERAL OBJECTIVE To determine the effect of a Nursing Intervention based on self-care aimed at improving the control of two Metabolic Syndrome risk factors (abdominal obesity and arterial hypertension) and health-related quality of life in climacteric women.
Specific Objectives
Regarding women in climacteric stage with two risk factors of Metabolic Syndrome of the experimental group and comparison:
To characterize according to basic conditioning factors, the bio-sociodemographic profile, and the level of physical activity.
To assess the need for therapeutic self-care using the two MS risk factors (abdominal obesity and arterial hypertension) and health-related quality of life in a pre- and post-test measurement.
To evaluate the effect of the self-care-based nursing intervention in the experimental group versus the traditional approach in the comparison group:
Within the requirements of the experimental design are considered:
Making known:
G: Group of people (G1 group 1, G2 group 2). X: Experimental condition (presence of some level or modality of the independent variable), in this research it will be the nursing intervention.
OR: A measurement of the subjects in a group (application of instruments, measurements). If it appears before the experimental condition, it is a pre-test (pre-intervention). If it appears after the experimental condition, it is a post-test (post- intervention).
2.2 Origin The study will be conducted in District 17D03 of the Ministry of Public Health of Ecuador. This district has two Type C Health Centers: San Antonio de Pichincha Health Center and Comite del Pueblo Health Center. These facilities are part of the National Health System and are in the urban sector, north of the city of Quito. They provide services to a population of 25,000 to 50,000 inhabitants and provide coverage to approximately 13,000 women between the ages of 40 and 59. They offer outpatient services: General Medicine, Gynecology, Pediatrics, Obstetrics, Dentistry, Psychology, Laboratory, Ultrasound, Pharmacy, Nursing, Vaccinations, Statistics and Emergency, Primary Care Programs (Immunizations, Prevention and Control of TB, Hypertensive and Diabetic Program, among others) from 8 am - 15 pm.
The purpose of carrying out the study in these Centers is by the characteristics and similar population number and because within the functions of the centers of Health type C at level of Country is the promotion of the health, prevention of diseases and recovery of the health by cycles of life, through the services of general medicine, gynecology, infirmary, maternity of short stay and emergency. It is worth mentioning that the hypertensive programmers of the health centers meet three times a month and carry out activities aimed at health promotion and disease prevention.
st Phase: Intervention Design Construction of the mobile app and content of the intervention It will be designed and developed through the exploration of content necessary for the intervention of the mobile app during the months of April to July 2021, which will serve as support for the nursing counseling modality, included in the intervention. Having a virtual application will allow combining the technological with personalized interventions, whose design approach will focus on the user, ensuring the needs of the participants and their context, making them participants in the process and development of the product.
For the construction of this mobile app has been considered, in the first term, a search in the scientific literature based on the topics addressed, incorporating elements of the Self-Care Deficit Theory of Orem. Subsequently, to collect information from users in the climacteric stage, an exploration stage will be carried out where women from the Cotocollao Health Center, with similar characteristics to those of the experimental and comparison group, will be invited to participate in individual interviews, prior Informed Consent, to identify their needs. The inclusion criteria to participate in the interviews will be the same as those required for the intervention. A guideline for the interviews will be developed that integrates aspects related to expectations and suggestions on how to approach health care and the use of technology based on questions asked by the thesis candidate.
Finally, health care providers (nurses, doctors, nutritionist, physical culture teacher) with a long experience in working with women in climacteric stage and women with presence of risk factors of Metabolic Syndrome will be consulted. The professionals will be invited to participate as consultants regarding the content and time of applicability. Among the professionals, the participation of Dr. Peter Chedraui, an expert in topics related to women in the climacteric stage, has been considered. In addition, support will be provided by eHealth experts and information technology (IT) developers, as well as designers and content specialists who will collaborate with the project team with extensive experience in the development of self-management technology tools.
Once the necessary content adjustments and input from the participants that will be identified in the exploration phase have been obtained, the first version of the low- fidelity software prototype will be developed, which will consist of the paper prototype that will provide a home page, menu page and screens that will present the design of the first intervention module and content.
In the first meeting with the eHealth experts, they will test and give feedback on the prototype to ensure the logical creation to meet the requirements of the participants, then the researcher will meet with health experts to socialize the contents of the module and give feedback on its development.
Subsequently, the high-fidelity prototype will be developed which will have the actual software home page, menu page and modules for the intervention, to ensure usability a second meeting will be held with users, health care providers, subject matter experts and eHealth experts to test it and the feedback data will be used to evaluate, refine, adjust, update the prototype, and verify its usability.
The security, privacy and confidentiality of eHealth data will depend on the operating software, the device, the network and the servers, it is here, that apart from the technology the researchers will address security issues related to the behavior of the user based on her context and the national policy where the Ministerial Agreement 5216 art. 8, 10, 11, 18 of the Ministry of Public Health of Ecuador points out the security and confidentiality of physical and digital data from collection to disposal.
The data obtained during the execution of the intervention will be eliminated in a period of five years, counting from the moment of the collection of the information, as indicated in Art. 18 of the Organic Law of Transparency and Access to Public Information, to guarantee that there is no risk of exposure. The storage of the data will be carried out in the servers of the Information Technology Department of the UdeC where the files and the database will be stored in the user: metamorphosis; server: www2.udec.cl; service: ftp; with the domain: metamorfosis.udec.cl, for which the respective authorizations are available.
Design of the implementation plan This plan constitutes the central part of the intervention, as it allows for the development of an implementation plan. To do this, it will be necessary to identify the facilitating factors and barriers to the adoption and implementation of the intervention, which will allow its evaluation for future implementation.
The technological support will be used by the participants of the experimental group from the beginning of the nursing intervention. The researcher in the first session of individual counseling, will be responsible for downloading and entering the username and password to each participant to access the application, if the user agrees to work with her phone as a means of support, teaching her how to use it.
Users will use the app to complement face-to-face individual counseling (3 sessions), virtual group education (2 sessions) and virtual physical activity (36 sessions) by providing remote nursing care from primary care to the home, not to mention reducing the cost of traveling to health centers.
Designing an evaluation plan the researchers will evaluate the achievement of the implementation of the intervention with technological support based on the self-care of women in the climacteric stage who present two risk factors of MS to improve the quality of life. The objective will be to have a cell app that will be downloaded on the cell phones of the participants during the 3 months of the intervention being useful, attractive, motivating, that fits in the broader context of the daily life of women in the climacteric stage with MS risk factors. The implementation of the technology will aim to reduce costs and intensify the support provided to multiple clients to assist in decision making at the primary care level by providing free access to content developed and refined together with the clients, which will expand equitable access to new resources at the community level and may provide the opportunity to make health care more effective, better coordinated, and closer to home.
According to what has been previously described, a first (virtual) meeting will be held with the physical culture teacher to socialize the physical activity plan and the instrument to be used during the evaluation and subsequent diagnosis of the physical condition of the participants during the month of July. A week after the initial meeting will be requested collaboration of students of physical culture of the 8th semester, these students will not have knowledge of the group to which the participants belong.
The second face-to-face meeting will be held with the nursing interns to whom the researcher will train in the application of the instruments to be used in the pre- and post-test, as well as in the measurement of anthropometric parameters and vital signs (blood pressure, heart rate, weight, height, BMI, abdominal circumference) in the month of August. These students will not know which group each participant belongs to.
The operational, economic and technical feasibility of the project will be carried out through the funding of the researcher and the ethical aspects involved, will be safeguarded from the beginning of the study considering the criteria of Ezekiel Emanuel through the confidentiality of data and informed consent providing autonomy to the participants of the experimental and comparison group to decide for themselves whether or not to participate in the research and withdraw when they deem appropriate, indicating the benefits and risks in an equitable manner among potential participants without seeking to produce harm, since the protection of the person is more important than the search for knowledge.
nd Phase: Execution of the intervention In first instance the participants of the group comparison that go to the Center of Health of the Committee of the People and that are registered in the Program of Hypertensive will receive habitual attention of the Institution on group chats, fairs of health based on general topics of the disease and group sessions 2 times per week. In the collection of the data for the investigation the group will receive a copy of the anthropometric measures and indicators of health pre, and post intervention and they will continue with their habitual activities.
On the other hand, the participants of the experimental group will receive counseling through: Educational counseling with technological support (3 individual sessions), educational sessions (2 group sessions virtually) and physical activity sessions 3 times a week virtually and an individual walking session. The topics of annual clinical controls, Metabolic Syndrome risk factors, health-related quality of life, healthy eating, and adequate level of physical activity in the climacteric stage will be included, which will be focused on self-care to improve the usual lifestyles. These sessions will be taught by the nurse/researcher.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: