Development of a Methodology for Diagnosis and Promoting Adherence to Treatment of Patients With Chronic Diseases and Evaluation of Their Impact on Cardiovascular Risk Factors
Development of a Methodology for Diagnosis and Promoting Adherence to Treatment of Patients With Chronic Diseases and Evaluation of Their Impact on Cardiovascular Risk Factors
The metabolic syndrome is a group of cardiometabolic risk factors that reflect a sedentary lifestyle and the excessive intake of food among the risk factors that comprise it are located the obesity, hyperglycemia, dyslipidemia and hypertension.
It has been observed that the interventions of lifestyle changes that promote weight loss through the practice of physical activity and intake of a hypocaloric diet, reduce the prevalence of chronic diseases such as Metabolic syndrome.
Adherence is defined as the extent to which a person's behaviour - taking medication, following a diet, and/or executing lifestyle changes, corresponds with agreed recommendations from a health care provider. The World Health Organization has estimated that in developing countries, as in Mexico, less than 27% of people with chronic diseases will continue treatment as directed.
Adherence to treatment of chronic disease is a multifactorial problem that includes not only patient-related barriers, but also providers of health services and social security systems themselves. Furthermore, as WHO has pointed out, as increasing prevalence of chronic non-adherence to treatment will become a global problem even more serious.
The purpose of this study is develop and implement a methodology to overcome barriers affecting adherence to treatment of women over 20 years with non-communicable diseases such as metabolic syndrome (diabetes , hypertension and dyslipidemia) evaluating its impact through various quantitative indicators such as weight loss or metabolic syndrome prevalence.
This study will include two phases:
The World Health Organization estimates that worldwide one billion adults are overweight. In Mexico, the prevalence of overweight and obesity using data from 2006 was nearly 70% in men and women over 20 years.
Being overweight is associated with other co-morbidities such as diabetes mellitus (79.4%), hypertension (78.0%) and dyslipidemia (82.8%). WHO has estimated that over 50% of these patients have a poor grip and do not follow their treatment as indicated, generating costs for managing these diseases of until $ 100 billion each year. Improve the effectiveness of interventions on adherence to treatment, will significantly improve the health of these patients and help reduce costs involving health systems.
The obesity and comorbidities affect 41% of the adults in Mexico and increases up to five times the risk of developing cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes and up to three times the risk of developing coronary artery disease and myocardial infarction. Therefore, these diseases are currently one of the main problems of public health in Mexico.
Adherence to short and long term is the result of a complex process that develops through different stages: the acceptance of diagnosis, the perceived need for treatment successfully, motivation, and skills training available, the ability to overcome the barriers or difficulties arise, and maintenance of achievements over time.
The lack of adherence to chronic disease is a multifactorial problem that includes not only patient-related barriers, but also with service providers and health systems. Poor adherence to long-term therapies severely compromises the effectiveness of treatment and negatively impacts the quality of life of patients.
It has been observed that the interventions of lifestyle changes that promote weight loss through the practice of physical activity and intake of a hypocaloric diet, reduce the prevalence of Metabolic diseases and achieve a better control.
The changes in lifestyle are the foundation of any strategy for the treatment of chronical diseases . The patients require counseling to effect change in their behavior and improve their risk of mortality and morbidities. So far, interventions to improve treatment of patients with chronic diseases, not including diet and exercise recommendations, has not reported any significant positive change. Moreover, in Mexico there is still no method or reference tool to assess adherence. It has been reported that healthy lifestyles achieve positive changes on cardiovascular risk factors, however, no known methodology to help patients overcome the barriers that prevent them from adopting and adhering to the recommendations that are prescribed providers of health services. Therefore, the objective of this study is to assess if a multidisciplinary treatment that stimulates the constant practice of physical activity and intake of a hypocaloric diet, reduces the prevalence of metabolic chronic diseases such as obesity, diabetes, hypertension and dyslipidemia, and improves the control, in comparison with a traditional medical treatment in Mexican women. Also, to develop a methodology validated in Mexican population to identify barriers that affect adherence to treatment assessing their impact through a variety of quantitative indicators of health.
This project was conducted in 2 phases.
PHASE 1 Development of the tool for identifying barriers. In a private hospital care to chronic noncommunicable diseases, were called patients with co-morbidities associated with overweight and obesity (diabetes mellitus, dyslipidemia, hypertension) to identify common barriers they face to adequately follow through treatment the application of a validated questionnaire. The results will be used as reference for the discussion of traditional treatment algorithms based on the Mexican standards for the management of obesity, hypertension, diabetes and dyslipidemia.
PHASE 2. Design and implementation of the intervention
Phase 2 began with the recruitment of study subjects. The recruitment was done by a local advertising campaign that included posters and leaflets in the city the Cuernavaca, Morelos. México.
Were recruited a group of 180 patients with overweight and two of the following co-morbidities: diabetes mellitus, dyslipidemia or hypertension. All study subjects will be randomized to a control group and intervention. The intervention will last 24 weeks. The control group will receive traditional clinical care and the intervention group will receive a behavioral intervention to improve adherence.
The design of the intervention is based in the the stages-of-change model (also referred to as the transtheoretical model) identifies five stages through which individuals progress as they change behaviours, and stage-matched strategies that predict progress to each subsequent stage of change.
The stages of change are:
Precontemplation at this stage the subject does not plan to make an effort to adhere to treatment or to change your behavior. (Not considering changing behavior in the next 6 months),
The second is called "contemplation", the person admits that there is a risk behavior or beneficial and begin thinking about trying to change or adopt. (Considering changing behavior in the next 6 months),
The third is "preparation" in this stage the person intends to initiate behavior change, strategies and plans to acquire solutions. (Planning to change behavior during the next 30 days),
The fourth is "action" has become the person intended in the expected action (in this study the action is to improve adherence to treatment). (Currently changing behavior)
The fifth is "maintenance", here the change has been established as usual. (Successful behavior change for at least 6 months).
There is a sixth stage called "relapse", where the person returns to the behaviors that had been changed, abandoned the effort and go to the pre-action stages.
Stages of change describe an individual's motivational readiness to change.
The specific tools that contain the intervention program are:
Preparation
At this stage various strategies will be developed:
Action At this stage the individual begins proper actions to get a better adherence It will provide enough printed material that allows it to achieve its goals in diet, physical activity and taking medications.
There will be a computerized database (software) with which you can update the progress and barriers presented by the individual and be able to access either the nutritionist doctor or psychologist
Description of the tools:
In the query are used as reference treatment guidelines of the ADA and the Third Adult Treatment Panel (ATP III).
Data collection will be done with different tools according to the phase of the project
Phase 1:
a) Identification of barriers to treatment through the application of validated questionnaires.
Phase 2:
Variables
Dependent. The dependent variable or outcome will be reduction in the prevalence of obesity and comorbidities (such as hypertension, diabetes, dyslipidemia), and control measured through weight loss, and decrease in blood pressure, fasting glucose, and cholesterol.
Independent. The independent variable is the lifestyle and behavioral program.
Data Analysis. Will present descriptive statistics for the dependent variables weight, fasting glucose, HbA1c, triglycerides, HDL-C, LDL-C, blood pressure and intima-media thickness.
Each group will analyze the mean difference in measurement time (initial, intermediate and final) for mean difference test
The differences between the control and intervention group were analyzed using three strategies: 1) by intention to treat (including patients who dropped out), 2) full support to the intervention (patients who completed the program), and 3) for proper administration of the intervention, ie an analysis will be specific to those subjects who received the intervention effectively by the physician and nutritionist (patients intervened correctly).
Inclusion Criteria:
Women from 19 to 65 years old
Body mass index ≥ 25.0 - ≤39.9 or abdominal obesity
With previous medical diagnosis:
Exclusion Criteria: