A Pilot Randomised Controlled Feasibility Trial for the Use of a Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Device to Assist Management of Type 2 Diabetes
A Pilot Randomised Controlled Feasibility Trial for the Use of a Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Device to Assist Management of Type 2 Diabetes
The majority of people with diabetes worldwide consist of type 2 diabetes mellitus. Typically, patients with type 2 diabetes are encouraged to manage their condition with weight loss; healthy eating; regular exercise; blood glucose monitoring; and in some cases, diabetes medication or insulin therapy. However, many struggle with their condition.
Pulsed Electromagnetic Frequency (PEMF) devices, which follow similar principles as a TENS machine, emit electromagnetic fields and are proposed to provide a non-invasive, safe, and easy-to-use method for treatment and management of diabetes related symptoms such as pain, alongside existing treatments and interventions. There is a belief that such devices may promote health and wellbeing and as a result could improve outcomes of type 2 diabetes. The use of the PEMF device would not replace existing treatments, interventions, or any primary care that the participants are currently receiving.
The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of a PEMF device of this kind for reported symptoms such as pain, fatigue, and overall wellbeing in people with type 2 diabetes. The study also seeks to explore patients' experiences of using the PEMF device.
Type 2 diabetes is highly prevalent and many sufferers struggle with their condition. One symptom of type 2 diabetes is diabetic neuropathy, which is characterised by progressive pain and loss of sensation.
Pulsed Electromagnetic Frequency (PEMF) devices, which follow similar principles as a TENS machine, emit electromagnetic fields and are proposed to provide a non-invasive, safe, and easy-to-use method for treatment and management of pain alongside existing treatments and interventions. A recent systematic review reported that pulsed electromagnetic fields had high efficacy in reducing musculoskeletal pain and that methods were well tolerated and had no negative side effects. Research established that pulsed electromagnetic field therapy had beneficial effects on pain, stiffness, and physical function in patients with osteoarthritis. It has, however, been recommended that further research is conducted to examine the use and effectiveness of pulsed electromagnetic field methods.
Given the findings reported regarding the effectiveness of pulsed electromagnetic field methods in reducing pain, it is possible that such devices could prove effective in managing diabetes related symptoms such as pain. It would also be useful to provide insight on the claim that they could potentially improve outcomes of type 2 diabetes and benefit users overall wellbeing.
The study is a pragmatic study as it is considered a better reflection of the perceived clinical benefits in a real world setting as opposed to being more efficacious in a trial setting. Pragmatic studies answer questions such as whether there is perceived additional clinical benefit where a treatment is utilised alongside usual care. This can then determine whether there is reason to explore this matter further and conduct a placebo-controlled trial to further inform health professionals and clinical guidelines.
The purpose of this study, therefore, is to evaluate the effectiveness of a pulsed electromagnetic field (PEMF) device for managing pain, health and wellbeing issues associated with type 2 diabetes via a pragmatic study. The study also seeks to explore patients' experiences of using the device.
Objectives:
This is a mixed methods study containing quantitative questionnaires and some qualitative interviews. All methods are non-evasive. The target population will be a heterogeneous and demographically diverse group of patients with type 2 diabetes meeting the inclusion criteria. Patients will be aged 18 years and over with a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes. Patients must be willing to participate, be able to read and write in English, and be able to give full, informed, written consent.
Patients will be recruited from patient support groups for adults with type 2 diabetes. In addition, the screening process will exclude those ineligible for inclusion. Responses to an on-line link will highlight the particulars of those interested in participating. Research staff will email an invitation letter to selected respondents (as per the study inclusion criteria ) with type 2 diabetes, together with a screening questionnaire, a patient information sheet and a consent form. Those who indicate they are interested in participating will be further contacted by the research team.
Consenting participants will be randomised into either the PEMF device group or the waiting list control group. There will be 30 participants in the PEMF group and 30 in the waiting list control group. The trial period of device use will last 3 months. Participants will be asked to use the PEMF device for 30 minutes per day.
The study outcome measures will assess diabetes symptoms and quality of life, and will be completed at baseline and at the end of the study intervention. All questionnaire tools have been previously validated. The Interview schedule will be piloted prior to use. Outcome measures consist of the following validated instruments: the Appraisal of Diabetes Scale (ADS), Measure Yourself Medical Outcome Profile (MYMOP)2, and the EQ-5D-5L tool to determine health related quality of life.The outcome measures will be collected at baseline, 6-weeks, 3 months plus a 6 month follow up.
Participants will be asked to complete a patient diary throughout the duration of the trial. The diary will ask participants to indicate use of study interventions, use of prescribed and non-prescribed treatments, and use of NHS services during the course of the trial. The diary will additionally record details of any changes to participants' food consumption during the trial period, device usage, and any routine blood glucose monitoring.
Sociodemographic and treatment characteristics will be obtained from a participants demographics questionnaire. These will include gender, age, educational level, marital status, and diabetes treatment received and dosage.
Participants will be invited to send the study team any clinical result sheets from participants' routine care. Such results routinely include glycated haemoglobin level (HbA1c) systolic/diastolic blood pressure, total cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL), high density lipoproteins (HDL), and triglycerides. Any such information will be analysed and where appropriate help to address the research questions.
No restrictions will be placed on the care provided by healthcare professionals treating participants but use of prescribed and non-prescribed treatments will be recorded.
Members of the PEMF device group will be invited to qualitative on-line focus groups or interviews. Participants will also be asked to participate in focus groups to explore their experiences of using the PEMF device, including participants' perceptions on how the device could be improved, any perceived impact on their diabetes and quality of life, and any adverse effects. Focus groups were chosen as the data-gathering method of choice, as the interaction helps participants to explore and refine their own experiences and perspectives. Two members of the research team will jointly conduct each focus group. The focus groups will be directed by a topic guide. Topic guides will be updated throughout the study to incorporate emerging themes. Focus groups will take place 3 months after the initiation of the PEMF intervention. Up to 5 focus groups will take place with patients using the PEMF device. Focus groups will be audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim.
The PEMF devices will be delivered to the homes of participants and all measures involve self-reporting to be conducted at participants' own homes.
Project milestones:
Milestone 1: Pre-study preparation (2 months)
Milestone 2: Recruitment/ data collection (6 months)
Milestone 3: Data analysis (2 months)
Milestone 4: Dissemination
Data analysis-
Quantitative data- Appropriate descriptive statistics will be estimated for all baseline sociodemographic and clinical variables by arm, and for outcome variables (scores on). The association between baseline sociodemographic or clinical variables and outcome variables will be assessed using appropriate between-group tests or correlations depending on skewness. Primary outcome variables will be compared between the arms using t-tests, one-way analysis of variance, Mann-Whitney tests and Kruskal-Wallis tests, bearing in mind any skewness in the data. Data will also evaluate the impact of medication on outcome, comparing treatment outcomes from those on diabetic medication compared to those not currently receiving medication for their diabetes. An intention-to-treat analysis model will be followed.
Qualitative data- Data will be analysed inductively, using thematic analysis. One of the researchers will immerse themselves in the data, repeatedly reading the transcripts to understand participants' experiences. Key issues, concepts and themes arising from the data will be identified to create a coding framework. Transcripts will then be coded and analysed thematically.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
anne.majumdar@stmarys.ac.uk020 8240 2312
charlotte.foster-brown@stmarys.ac.uk+447899973829