Prospective Double-Cohort Study: Comparing Efficacy of Budesonide Via MAD or INSI in Post-operative Treatment
Prospective Double-Cohort Study: Comparing Efficacy of Budesonide Via MAD or INSI in Post-operative Treatment
Chronic Rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a common disorder in North America, affecting more than 31 million people annually. Common therapy for CRS includes intranasal corticosteroids (INCS) such as budesonide. At our centre , the current practice is to administer budesonide two ways: the mucosal atomization device (MAD), which is a nasal spray or impregnated budesonide in nasal saline irrigation (INSI), which is a nasal rinse. Our study aims to see which method of administering budesonide has the best treatment outcomes after sinus surgery. This study will follow patients over a six-month period of time.
Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) with nasal polyps (CRSwNP) and without nasal polyps (CRSsNP) is a common condition affecting millions of North Americans. CRS is a multifactorial disease that causes inflammation within the sinonasal passages. Symptoms include; dysosmia, nasal blockage, sinus pain, and discolored mucous. Olfactory dysfunction is commonly seen in the CRS patient population. It is estimated that up to 78% of CRS patients have a decreased sense of smell. Therefore, validated smell tests such as Sniffin'Sticks have been used to determine the severity and presence of dysosmia. In addition, patients are frequently colonized with various bacteria or fungi which may further aggravate patient's symptoms. Together, these manifestations lead to a decreased quality of life in CRS patients.
The basis of therapy is to increase mucociliary clearance, improve drainage and relieve obstruction, and eliminate signs of inflammation. Common therapy for the inflamed nasal mucosal lining includes intranasal corticosteroids (INCS) or systemic corticosteroids. Budesonide (Pulmicort) is a corticosteroid which is the mainstay treatment for CRS patients. They have been proven to be very effective in reducing SNOT-22 scores, endoscopic scores, and reducing recurrence in varying severity and subtype of CRS disease.
The current practice at our institution is to administer budesonide via two modalities: the mucosal atomization device (MAD, Wolfe-Tory Medical, Salt Lake City, UT) or impregnated budesonide in nasal saline irrigation (INSI) using a NeilMed squeeze bottle (NeilMed Pharmaceuticals, Santa Rosa, California). The MAD atomizes the medication into particles from 30-100 um in size thus increasing the surface area for drug absorption. At our centre, INSI is frequently employed for CRS patients in the acute postoperative period. Postoperative use of INSI has shown to demonstrate significant improvement in quality of life and endoscopy findings in CRS patients. However, patients can potentially experience headaches and discomfort, which can affect their adherence to this treatment regimen. Therefore, for recalcitrant and non-responsive CRS patients, an alternative treatment method is to utilize budesonide via a MAD in its concentrated form.
Although there is literature that exemplifies the benefit of adding budesonide to postoperative management of CRS patients, there is yet to be a study that assesses the most effective modality of administering the corticosteroid. Therefore, this study aims to prospectively assess the efficacy of INSI and MAD in delivering high-dose nasal corticosteroids in CRS patients. By determining which administration technique is more effective, it will lead to better postoperative outcomes for patients suffering from CRS. Overall, the investigators hope the results from this study will be a step forward in the understanding which administration modality of intranasal corticosteroids is most effective in ameliorating patient disease and quality of life.
Primary Objective:
To compare the postoperative efficacy of budesonide in CRS patients delivered via mucosal atomization device (MAD) or impregnated budesonide in nasal saline irrigation (INSI).
Hypothesis:
The investigators hypothesize that budesonide delivered via MAD will be more effective postoperatively at decreasing objective evidence and subjective symptoms of CRS compared to INSI.
Baseline and Follow-up Visits Evaluation:
The following information will be obtained from each participant
Baseline Demographic data: Age Gender Smoking status
Clinical Data:
Conduct of Study:
This is a prospective randomized double cohort study at the St. Paul's Sinus Centre. Patients who have an upcoming sinus surgery will be recruited to this study. After the patients have signed the informed consent form and have undergone sinus surgery, they will have their baseline visit. Patients will be divided into the MAD or INSI arm randomly. Patients will be required to take budesonide at least 5 days a week to assure changes seen are directly correlated to taking budesonide. Baseline will be the 1-week postoperative visit following the patient's sinus surgery. Further data will be collected at month 3 and lastly at the patients 6 month follow up visit.
Management of Patient Care
Patients have the right to withdraw from the study at any time. Patients who experience signs and symptoms of hypersensitivity to iodine, burning, itching, pain redness, tiredness, nausea or vomiting will be asked to stop the rinses immediately. The reaction will be noted and the code will be broken so that a discussion can occur between the physician and the patient regarding the use of iodine with the nasal rinses. Patients who meet any of the exclusion criteria that were not noted at the beginning of the study will be removed from this study and the physician will discuss the future management options with the patient.
Sample size:
The investigators expect 60 patients (30 patients per study arm) for the number of participants in this prospective double cohort.
Analysis:
Descriptive statistics will be used to analyze the baseline characteristic data and the data from the administered surveys and objective findings of eosinophil and IgE blood work, cultures, Sniffin' Sticks smell test and MLK scores. In addition, rigorous statistical analysis will be conducted on the Likert scale-based SNOT-22 and EQ-5D-5L surveys. These analyses will include cross-tabulations (Pearson's chi square test) and confidence interval calculations.
Safety Monitoring
Patients who experience signs and symptoms of budesonide reaction will be noted and the code will be broken so that a discussion can occur between the research supervisor and the patient regarding the use of the topical iodine.
Patients can contact the office anytime if they notice any of the signs or symptoms of iodine reaction and will be seen by the research supervisor (or designate) within 24 hours.
Adverse Events (AE's)
All expected and unexpected adverse events will be recorded and graded by the research supervisor. Stable chronic conditions, which are present prior to the clinical trial entry and do not worsen, are not considered adverse events and will be accounted for in the patient's medical history.
Recording/Documentation of Adverse Events
During each patient visit, the research supervisor will ask appropriate questions and perform a physical exam to elicit any adverse events. The research supervisor will also review blood work obtained from the patient. All reportable adverse events will be recorded on appropriate case report form. The research supervisor will also write the stop date, the severity of the AE and his judgment of the AE's relationship to the study.
Serious Adverse Events (SAE's)
An SAE is defined as an AE meeting one of the following:
Death occurring between Day 0 and 182 days (6 months) of the study. Life Threatening Event (defined as a participant at immediate risk of death at the time of the event) In-patient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization between Day 0 and 42 of the study.
Results in a persistent or significant disability/incapacity In the event of SAE, the research supervisor will discuss with the patient (or next of kin) whether there is a relationship between the study and the SAE. If there is a relationship, the PI will be responsible for coordinating care for the patient until the SAE has been addressed.
Pregnancy During the Trial Patients will be responsible for determining if they are pregnant or become pregnant during the study. If patients notify the PI they are pregnant, they will be removed from the study and the medical management options will be discussed.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
apascual@providencehealth.bc.ca(604) 806-9926
lsamson2@providencehealth.bc.ca(604) 806-9926