Determinants of Adolescent Social Well-being and Health: a London Based Longitudinal Study of Young People From Different Ethnic Groups
Determinants of Adolescent Social Well-being and Health: a London Based Longitudinal Study of Young People From Different Ethnic Groups
Black and ethnic minority groups living in the UK experience high rates of chronic diseases such as diabetes, hypertension and heart disease, general morbidity and poor mental health. The cause of these excess rates is unknown but obesity, smoking, diet and deprivation are important contributing factors. There is also global evidence of the association of these diseases in adulthood with health and deprivation in early life and childhood. Persisting social deprivation over the lifecourse is disproportionately borne by some ethnic minorities (Harding and Balarajan 2001) but the impact on the health of their children is virtually unknown. Least is known about the health of Black Caribbean young people. It is important to examine risk factor differences by social predictors within the ethnic minority groups as well as between them. The DASH Study started as a school-based cohort study of adolescents from the main ethnic groups (White British, Black Caribbean, Black African, Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi) in 10 London boroughs. Wave 1 took place in 2002/03 (MREC Ref: MREC/2/10/12), when participants were aged 11-13 years (school years 7 and 8). Wave 2 took place in 2005/06 (MREC Ref: 05/MRE10/43) when they were 14-16 years (school years 9 and 10). Wave 3 took place in 2010/2011, when participants were aged 19-21 years and involved a postal follow-up complemented by telephone interview and on-line questionnaires. The current proposal is for a feasibility study, using a small sample of the DASH cohort, to inform the design of the next full face-to-face follow-up. DASH will be the first large scale UK longitudinal cohort of ethnic minority youths with both social and biological measures from childhood to early adulthood. It will allow detailed examination of ethnic differences in the social patterning of biological mechanisms and pre-clinical disease in young adulthood.
Background:
Black and ethnic minority groups living in the UK experience high rates of chronic diseases such as diabetes, hypertension and heart disease, general morbidity and poor mental health. The cause of these excess rates is unknown but obesity, smoking, diet and deprivation are important contributing factors. There is also global evidence of the association of these diseases in adulthood with health and deprivation in early life and childhood. Persisting social deprivation over the lifecourse is disproportionately borne by some ethnic minorities (Harding and Balarajan 2001) but the impact on the health of their children is virtually unknown. Least is known about the health of Black Caribbean young people. It is important to examine risk factor differences by social predictors within the ethnic minority groups as well as between them. The DASH Study started as a school-based cohort study of adolescents from the main ethnic groups (White British, Black Caribbean, Black African, Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi) in 10 London boroughs. Wave 1 took place in 2002/03 (MREC Ref: MREC/2/10/12), when participants were aged 11-13 years (school years 7 and 8). Wave 2 took place in 2005/06 (MREC Ref: 05/MRE10/43) when they were 14-16 years (school years 9 and 10). Wave 3 took place in 2010/2011, when participants were aged 19-21 years and involved a postal follow-up complemented by telephone interview and on-line questionnaires. The current proposal is for a feasibility study, using a small sample of the DASH cohort, to inform the design of the next full face-to-face follow-up. DASH will be the first large scale UK longitudinal cohort of ethnic minority youths with both social and biological measures from childhood to early adulthood. It will allow detailed examination of ethnic differences in the social patterning of biological mechanisms and pre-clinical disease in young adulthood.
Aims:
(i) To conduct a feasibility study to establish the best methods for data collection, including the collection of physical and biological measurements, for subsequent face to face follow-up of the entire cohort.
(ii) To generate a proposal for subsequent follow-up of the entire cohort for submission to MRC, dependent on the findings of the postal and telephone surveys and proposed feasibility study.
Objectives:
I. What are the advantages and disadvantages of conducting the study in the two settings - GP surgeries and homes?
Outcome measures:
These will be examined by setting (home visit, GP surgery) using a mixture of quantitative and qualitative methods and are as follows:
I. Percentage response rates - overall, per item/physical measure; II. Percentage consistency of answers to questionnaire items; III. Percentage physical measures within expected range e.g. spirometric measures; IV. Mean length of time for interview; V. Mean length of time for taking physical/biological measures; VI. Qualitative appraisal of cultural appropriateness of mental health measures and of respondents' satisfaction with survey processes.
Sample At the recent telephone survey, respondents were asked if they would be willing to take part in a small feasibility study to prepare for a later full face to face follow-up. Almost all agreed and of those, a sample of 300 (40-50 in each of the main ethnic groups- White British, Black Caribbean, Black African, Pakistani, Bangladeshi, Indian) will be invited to complete a questionnaire, and have physical and physiological measures taken. Interviews will be conducted in respondents' own homes or GP surgeries dependent on the preference of the respondent. As this is a feasibility study, the sample size has been chosen pragmatically to give a reasonable spread, with equal gender representation across the 10 London boroughs that the whole sample was in at wave 2.
Specially trained nurses will conduct the survey in homes or General Practitioners' surgeries, supervised by a nurse manager in the General Practice Research Framework. Nurses will be attached either to the General Research Practice Framework or the Primary Care Research Network.
Main Questionnaire The content reflects mainly questions that were asked in previous waves (general health; health behaviours; psychological well-being; SEC; social support; and relationship with parents). New items include parenthood; age appropriate mental health measures; own education, economic activity and occupation; job strain; caring; 'romantic' relationships; positive and negative emotions; views on their parents being invited to participate in DASH in order to examine generational influences. The investigators will explore two methods of delivery of the questionnaires - self complete questionnaires done prior to visit and computer assisted interviews. If the questionnaire is not completed by the time of the interview, respondents will be asked if they would like to complete a computer assisted interview. Completion of the questionnaire is expected to take about 40 minutes.
Physical/physiological measures As in waves 1/and 2, height, weight, arm, waist and hip circumference, lung function, blood pressure will be measured.
New measures include:
(i)Hand to foot bio-impedance (ii) Bio-markers - HbA1c, total cholesterol, HDL-cholesterol (iii) Dietary assessment - 24 hour recall interviews Qualitative assessment - focus groups and semi-structured interviews. For the new mental health/cognitive measures, the investigators will conduct focus group vignette assessment, based on explanatory model and illness perception theories. This will be carried out in a small sub-sample (6 participants per ethnic group and allowing for 2 gender-specific groups; n=48). Analysis of these data will focus on narratives about the signs and symptoms of different aspects of mental health in the different ethnic groups. These data will provide valuable insights about the appropriateness of measures, usually validated with European populations, for ethnic minority groups.
A research scientist will conduct semi-structured interviews with respondents to obtain feedback on the process of follow-up - what worked well, how best to improve the process, what was un/acceptable etc. The investigators will also enquire about the usefulness of feedback of results. A similar evaluation will take place with the nurses with the aim of identifying best practice in clinics and homes.
Data analysis Descriptive statistics will be used to look at the general distributions and quality of the data collected. Outcomes measured as rates will be examined by data collection setting (GP surgeries vs. home visits), ethnic group and socio-demographic characteristics using standard comparisons technique such as Chi-square test or logistic regression. Mean length of time and any continuous outcomes will be compared using linear regression. In addition, although the sample size of each ethnic group is small, the total sample will allow analyses of the potential social patterning of biological mechanisms in a diverse sample in young adulthood.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: