Efficacy of Recombinant FSH/GnRH Antagonist Protocol With and Without LH Adjunct and GnRH Agonist Trigger for Egg Bank Donation
Efficacy of Recombinant FSH/GnRH Antagonist Protocol With and Without LH Adjunct and GnRH Agonist Trigger for Egg Bank Donation
Disprove the null hypothesis as follows:
Among the investigator's egg bank donors undergoing ovulation induction with recombinant FSH medication per treatment protocol outlined below, use of adjunctive LH activity medication Menopur ™ , will result in the same number of mature oocytes recovered and cryopreserved as from egg donors not treated with Menopur™.
Objectives:
Compare efficacy of recombinant FSH (Follistim ™) with and without adjunct LH activity medication Menopur ™ for our volunteer egg bank donors.
Efficacy defined as:
Study type: Randomized prospective clinical trial.
Patient selection: Voluntary egg donors who have satisfied all screening criteria for FDA and the Michigan Egg Bank: Age range 18-to 39 years. BMI 18 to 25. Resting antral follicle count of 16 or greater. Cycle day 3 FSH <10 mIU/ml. AMH >2.0 ng/ml.
Study design:
Two groups- Group A- Recombinant FSH Follistim only; Group B- Recombinant FSH Follistim and adjunct Menopur. Both groups will use GnRH agonist trigger 36 hours prior to egg retrieval.
Random number generator with patients assigned basd on odd or even numbers.
Number of subjects: 25 in each group. Total of 50 subjects. This takes into account possible cycle cancellation for poor ovarian response or patient elective withdrawal to result in at least 20 subjects in each group completing the study.
Primary measure of outcome: number of mature oocytes recovered and cryopreserved.
Secondary measures of outcome:
Background:
The investigator's Center has been studying human oocyte cryopreservation by vitrification since July 1, 2008 (Western Institutional Board Review -WIRB Pro. Nr: 20081080, WIRB Study Nr.: 1100421). The first phase of the investigator's study was to assess efficacy of oocyte cryopreservation among voluntary egg donors with end points for outcomes including rates of oocyte thaw survival, fertilization, embryo development, implantation, clinical pregnancy, live birth and infant health. The rationale for starting with egg donors was that they represent a population of women most likely to have optimal egg quality and a short turnaround time from vitrification to thaw, IVF and embryo transfer into an appropriate egg recipient patient. If the investigator could establish good outcomes when egg quality is optimal, then there would be good hope to provide reliable egg cryopreservation technology to women in need of fertility preservation when facing treatment of cancer; other illnesses for which treatments harm their eggs; women choosing personal egg banking and for women who wish to avoid excess embryo creation on moral or religious grounds.
The investigator's study observations were that outcomes with use of previously cryopreserved donor eggs was equivalent to fresh donor eggs: 90% of mature oocytes survived the thaw, 76% of thawed oocytes fertilized normally with ICSI, 98% of recipient women had a day 5 embryo transfer with one or two embryos transferred, implantation rate of 42%, 60% or recipient women achieved clinical pregnancy, 58% live birth rate and no birth defects have been observed in over 40 babies delivered through this technology at our Center.
In the beginning of 2012, we opened up the second phase of the investigator's study to include women in need of fertility preservation for the indications mentioned above. No outcomes are yet known due to the expected time deferment from oocyte cryopreservation to use. The favorable outcomes from donor egg bank IVF led to the investigator's establishing the Michigan Egg Bank. On October 22, 2012, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine announced a new practice guideline that oocyte cryopreservation technology should be considered mainstream medical therapy and no long be considered experimental medical care. The investigator's closed the WIRB study November, 26, 2012.
Rationale:
Ovarian stimulation for egg donation should be provided offering the safest and simplest process for our egg donors. Avoiding complications of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome while assuring recruitment and harvest of good quality oocytes is a main goal in caring for the investigator's volunteer egg donors. Use of FSH medications with GnRH antagonist and GnRH agonist trigger is the protocol of choice for all of the investigator's egg donors. The investigator's egg donors have experienced no complications and rapid recovery. GnRH antagonists have been shown to suppress endogenous ovarian androgen synthesis. In using GnRH antagonist, adjunctive LH or low dose hCG combined with FSH medication has been a mainstream assumption to assure sufficient endogenous ovarian testosterone is present as a substrate for estrogen synthesis and normal folliculogenesis.
In an effort to improve patient compliance by simplifying the use of medications for the investigator's egg donors, the investigator wishes to examine the efficacy of recombinant FSH without additional separate medication of adjunct LH activity in the form Menopur ™.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: