The BAROLO Study Bedside Assessment of Right Ventricular Output Lying in Prone Or Supine Position. Hemodynamic Changes Due to Prone Position in Patients After Cardiac Surgery - a Prospective Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluating the Effect of Prone Position on Right Heart Function
The BAROLO Study Bedside Assessment of Right Ventricular Output Lying in Prone Or Supine Position. Hemodynamic Changes Due to Prone Position in Patients After Cardiac Surgery - a Prospective Randomized Controlled Trial Evaluating the Effect of Prone Position on Right Heart Function
Right ventricular failure (RVF) is a common complication to cardiac surgery, which is associated to mortality, kidney failure, stroke, prolonged mechanical ventilation and ICU stay. The right ventricle is particularly vulnerable to an increased afterload. By increasing pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR), atelectasis might mitigate a negative effect on the right ventricle.
Recruitment maneuvers have been shown to resolve atelectasis and improve hemodynamics by increasing cardiac output and lowering PVR. However these maneuvers transiently raise airway pressures, which in turn increases right ventricular afterload, a situation often poorly tolerated by patients with RVF.
Prone position is used in patients with respiratory failure and has been shown to decrease mortality in patients with ARDS. Prone position decreases atelectasis and moves ventilation dorsally. In ARDS it also seems to mediate beneficial hemodynamic effects such as an increase in cardiac output and a decrease in PVR.
The investigators hypothesis is that prone position early after cardiac surgery will increase cardiac output by recruitment of atelectasis and thereby decrease PVR.
Recruitment and consent:
Patients will be screened for participation no later than the day before surgery. Potential participants will be given written and verbal information regarding the study and time to ask questions and consider their participation.
Randomization:
After end of surgery, at baseline in the ICU, patients will be randomly allocated (1:1 ratio) to supine position and prone position. Block randomization with variable block sizes will be performed with sequentially numbered, opaque, sealed envelopes. All performed by Statistiska konsultgruppen. Patient stratification according to cardiac index at end-surgery will be performed to ensure similar allocation of patients with cardiac index <2.2 L/min/m2 in each group. The investigator who enrolls study participants will not have access to the random allocation sequence.
Sample Size:
Based on previous studies regarding cardiac surgery or prone position a power calculation was performed using a two-sample comparison of means, with equally sized independent groups. With an intention to detect a 20% difference in cardiac index in the intervention group and with 80% power, 0.05 α, estimated mean CI 2.6(0.8 SD) in control group, and CI 3.2 in the prone group, calcuation rendered n=70 divided in 2 equally large groups. As patients intermittently require recurring surgery due to i.e. bleeding, some patients will be excluded after inclusion. Based on this and the power analysis 80 patients will be included and randomized to supine position (n=40) and prone position (n=40).
Description of method:
In included patients, anesthesia will be performed with Propofol, Fentanyl and Sevoflurane. As per clinical routine patients will have a central venous catheter, 1-2 arterial catheters, TEE probe and endotracheal tube inserted. Study participants will also get a pulmonary artery catheter (PAC) inserted prior to surgery to facilitate measurement of cardiac output using thermodilution and PVR. Body surface area is calculated using the Mosteller formula.
During surgery, after CPB is weaned, the attending anaesthesiologist is instructed to refrain from additional recruitment maneuvers and a PEEP >8 cmH2O. Unless FiO2 is >80% to maintain adequate oxygenation of the patient or the anaesthesiologist deems it necessary.
When surgery is finished, the patient will be moved to the Thoracic ICU. Ventilation performed with a Maquet Servo-U (Getinge, SE) is set to volume control, tidal volumes of 6 ml/kg IBW with a respiratory rate of 12-18 and PEEP 8 cmH2O. Data collection occurs in all patients in supine position (0). Hereafter the study group is turned to prone while the control group remains in supine position.
60 minutes after proning data is again collected (t1), whereafter a recruitment maneuver is performed by gradually increasing PEEP during 2,5 minutes in 6 steps to 20 cmH2O during. After 30 seconds PEEP is decreased in 6 steps during 2,5 minutes to reach PEEP 8 cmH2O. Data is collected after the recruitment maneuver (t2) and one hour after (t3), adding up to a total of 2 hours and 15 minutes in supine or prone position. The patients in prone position are turned to supine position and the last data collection occurs (t4). In total 5 time points for data collection. Postoperative care will now continue as per routine care. Patients will be extubated as soon as possible according to clinical routine and eventually discharged from the ICU.
Since a recruitment maneuver transiently increases right ventricular afterload there is a possibility not all patients will tolerate the recruitment maneuver as described above. As per clinical practice the level of airway pressures during recruitment will be adjusted when needed to avoid adverse effects.
Discontinuation of the intervention:
In order to minimize harm the following set criteria will be used to discontinue prone position:
Blinding:
After allocation to supine or prone position neither the investigator, nor ordinary ICU personnel, will be blinded due to safety and impracticalities. Patients are blinded due to being under general anaesthesia during randomization until weaning from mechanical ventilation (after the study protocol is completed).
Data collection:
A site investigator will record data using a software developed by Getinge from the respirator to a designated research computer. All other data and variables, mentioned above, will be collected from the participants digital chart and real time monitoring (Philips IntelliVue & BD Hemosphere).
Data management:
Collected data is pseudonymized and stored on a password protected designated research computer. Only authorized study personnel have access to the computer.
Original records, including signed written consent, are kept with strict confidence. These records will be kept in a secure, locked and limited access location at Sahlgrenska Univeristy Hospital during the study and after completion for an additional 10 years. At inclusion each patient is pseudonymized by receiving a participant ID, which is used in all data files.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
viktor.erbring@vgregion.se+46706456664
per.persson@vgregion.se+46736467042