Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation and Action Observation for Healthy Aging: a Home-based Approach to Promote Sensorimotor Adaptation
Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation and Action Observation for Healthy Aging: a Home-based Approach to Promote Sensorimotor Adaptation
Aging is associated with a decline in muscle strength and the functionality of the perceptual structures involved in proprioception. This decline results in a gradual loss of autonomy in daily activities. Neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) has been shown to be an effective technique in limiting the decline in strength. Action observation (AO) is a cognitive technique, which has been shown to improve motor performance, especially when combined with peripheral stimulation.
The purpose of this study is to evaluate whether a self-administered, home-based intervention combining NMES and AO improves upper limb muscle strength and proprioceptive abilities in healthy elderly individuals.
Participants within the age range of 65-85 years will be recruited for this study. The intervention is scheduled to span a duration of four weeks, encompassing three treatment sessions per week. Participants will be randomly divided into three groups: NMES, AO, and AO-NMES. Assessments will be performed before and immediately after the intervention. They will include muscle strength evaluation (handgrip strength, maximal isometric force of the biceps, bench press power), and perceptual evaluation (weight discrimination during an AO task, weight judgment tasks).
This study may suggest an original approach, cost-effective approach to mitigate the effects of physiological aging on muscle and sensorimotor function, with potential applications for frail populations, unable or unmotivated to perform conventional physical activity.
Aim The purpose of study will be testing the effects of a self-administered, home-based intervention combining NMES and AO for the upper limbs in healthy elderly people on muscle strength and proprioceptive abilities. This will be done by comparing action observation-neuromuscular electrical stimulation (AO-NMES) with action observation (AO) and neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) delivered alone, with the hypothesis that AO-NMES leads to higher improvement than the others. This approach could be a safe, accessible and cost-effective way to maintain or improve neuromuscular function and sensorimotor control in ageing populations. Furthermore, by preserving upper limb function, the intervention could help older adults to retain functional autonomy, reduce their risk of disability and improve their overall quality of life and well-being.
Methods
Participants Voluntarily participants will be recruited from the students enrolled in the 'UniGeSenior' program at the University of Genoa. The inclusion criteria are voluntarily participation, age ranges from 65 to 85 years, both male and female, sedentary. Exclusion criteria include neurological or psychiatric disorders, fractures within the past six months, orthopedic or musculoskeletal impairments, uncontrolled hypertension, and regular resistance training (at least once per week), participation in competitive sports.
Study design This will be a randomized, double-blind, controlled experimental trial. The study will be registered on ClinicalTrials.gov. The intervention will last four weeks, three sessions per weeks will be performed at home. The intervention will vary according to the assigned group, with all interventions delivered in parallel across the following groups: AO group, NMES group and AO-NMES group. The assignment will be done using the RAND() function in Excel, which generated random numbers that were then used to sort and allocate subjects evenly. During each session, the treatment will last 30 minutes and will include a 10-minutes warm-up phase during which the visual task will be administered, and 20 minutes of exercise phase.
Before (PRE) and after (POST) the intervention period participant will perform different kinds of assessments (see Evaluation section).
Intervention 3.1. Visual stimuli
The stimuli shown to the participants will change according to the group. In the AO group participants will watch a video showing different instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs), which require considerable force production, executed with the upper limbs by a woman or a man. The IADLs will involve the individual performing the following tasks:
3.2. NMES parameters During the first day of intervention, participant will receive the NMES medical device (I-TECH PHYSIO, IACER srl, Scorzè, Venice, Italy) and will be instructed on how to use it by a researcher expert in sport science.
During the warm-up phase, the NMES will be set with a frequency of 50 Hz and a pulse duration at 400 μs and the intensity at motor threshold. During the exercise phase, participants in the AO group will receive a NMES sham treatment (f=5Hz, t=100 μs) delivered at sensory threshold, and known to be ineffective in increasing muscle strength. In the NMES and AO-NMES groups, the exercise phase will be administered at functional threshold (the minimum intensity required for a complete arm flexion) or at maximal tolerated intensity (f=100Hz, t=400 μs).
Evaluations Experimental evaluations will include strength assessment, weight judgment task and weight discrimination during an AO task. They will be performed on the same day, with appropriate rest periods between each evaluation. One week before the PRE evaluation, in a familiarization session, participants will perform the strength assessment, the familiarization was recommended with elderly people.
Evaluations will be conducted by two researchers with expertise in sport science, who will be blinded to the type of intervention performed by the participants. Possible harms will be recorded non-systematically based on spontaneous reports from participants during the experimental period.
4.1. Strength assessment The aim of this test is to assess the effectiveness of the three interventions in increasing muscle strength and power.
The handgrip strength (kg) of the participants will be assessed with the KERN MAP handgrip dynamometer (KERN & SOHN GmbH). The participants will execute the test standing, with the shoulder adducted, the elbow extended, the forearm and the wrist neutral. They will be required to grip the dynamometer with their maximum strength. The mean value obtained from three repetitions will be considered to assess the right and left handgrip strength. The mean values between left and right handgrip strength will be considered as the outcome parameter of handgrip strength.
During the familiarization session, participants will familiarize with the isometric curl and the bench press test. Regarding the first test, participants perform 10 submaximal repetitions and 3 maximal repetitions. Regarding the second test, they perform two sets of eight to ten repetitions at a submaximal load of bench press, followed by two sets of two repetitions at maximal speed with an empty bar.
During the evaluation, the assessment of biceps maximal isometric force (MIF, N) will be performed using the Chronojump force sensor (Chronojump, Barcelona, Spain) asking participant to perform an elbow flexion. Participants will be assessed from sitting position, holding a bar with both supinated and elbow angle approximately at 90°. The bar will be connected to the force sensor by a static rope. The movement will be executed three times, with 1-minute pause between each repetition. Participants will be instructed to pull as hard as possible to maintain the contraction for at least 2 s with verbal encouragement. The trial with the highest MIF value will be considered as valid. Before the evaluation, a warm-up phase consisting in a set of five repetitions at the loads of 40-60% of the perceived maximum force will be performed.
Bench press test will be executed to assess the force-velocity relationship, and to estimate the maximal power. The test will be preceded by a warm-up consisting of two sets of 10 repetitions at the Smith Machine. During the execution of traditional bench press, participants will stop the bar to the chest for 2 seconds and then will push the bar as fast as possible until the full extension of the elbow. The initial load will be set at 16kg for male and 12kg for female. The load will constantly increase to perform 3-4 sets, number of sets required to obtain an adequate estimate of maximum power, with an execution speed in the last set lower than 0.3 m⋅s- 1. Between each set, 3 minutes of rest will be applied. During this test a linear position transducer will be used (Chronojump, Barcelona, Spain). One end will be attached on the left side of the bar, and the other end will be fixed to the floor. Maximal Power (MP) will be extracted with Chronojump software.
4.2. Weight judgment task The aim of this evaluation is to test the perceived heaviness of an object in a daily life context with the hypothesis that AO-NMES treatment will have positive effect on proprioceptive ability. A point weight judgement task will be performed. The participants will be instructed to judge the weight of a box in kilograms. A one-kilo box will be used for familiarization of the task. Participants will lift the box, positioned in front of them on a table with the handles aligned at hip level, using arm flexion until approximately 45° of flexion is reached. The box used during the weight judgment task will be filled with cast-iron disk, secured to prevent movement, to reach a weight of 4 kg, 7 kg and 10 kg. Participants will not be given information about weights or the number of different weights. Each box will be lifted 5 times. The mean values weight reported by the participant and coefficient of variations will be considered as outcome parameters together with the estimation error computed as the absolute difference between the real and the perceived weight.
4.3. Weight discrimination during an AO task The aim of this test is to evaluate participants' ability to discriminate the weight of an object moved by others during an action observation task. The hypothesis is that by improving both strength and the perception of heaviness, this enhanced ability will transfer to the motor resonance mechanism, thereby assisting participants in accurately evaluating the weight of an object moved by another individual. The weight-discrimination video task is described in a previous paper of our group. Briefly, participants will have to discriminate the weight of two boxes moved in two consecutive actions displayed in a video indicating which is the heaviest box. One of the videos is used as a reference. The weight inside the box in this video is 7 kg. In the other video, the weight inside the box varied from 0 to 15 kg. The number of trials is 112 (16 repetitions for 7 box weight). Just Noticeable Differences (JND), obtained by the psychometric function, will be the outcome parameter.
4.4. Monitoring adherence to the protocol To monitor participants' adherence to the protocol, a researcher will call each participant at the end of every intervention week to ask whether all planned sessions for that week were completed. The reported number of completed sessions will be recorded to support data interpretation.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: