Effectiveness of Community-based Approach in Reducing the Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) Exposure and Outcome: a Randomized Control Trial of IPV Victimization and Perpetration in Rwanda
Effectiveness of Community-based Approach in Reducing the Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) Exposure and Outcome: a Randomized Control Trial of IPV Victimization and Perpetration in Rwanda
Abstract
Background:
There is a little known about the effectiveness of Community-Based Approach (CBA) on reduction of intimate partner violence (IPV) exposure, anxiety, depression and PTSD symptoms as outcomes in collectivist and post-genocide societies like Rwanda. This study, therefore, aimed at assessing the effectiveness of Community-Based Approach (CBA) for IPV victimization and perpetration as well as it's associated mental health outcomes in Rwanda.
Methods:
This is a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) study which will be conducted using a sample of 31 couples (MA =36.9, SD=9.9), with 16 couples assigned in treatment group and 15 assigned in control group. Data has to be collected using the Hurt, Insult, Threaten and Screaming (HITS-7) to assess IPV exposure; the Hopkins Symptom Checklist for anxiety and depression (HSCL-25); and the PTSD checklist for DSM-5 (PCL-5). Data will be analyzed using Pearson correlation and mixed ANOVAs to evaluate the effect of CBA over IPV occurrence and mental health outcomes.
Key words:
IPV, community support, emotions management, anxiety, depression, PTSD, Rwanda
Introduction Globally, intimate partner violence (IPV) against woman is considered as an important social and public health issue. IPV refers to physical, sexual or emotional harm by a current or former intimate partner. It has been estimated that almost 30% of all women in the world have experienced IPV. South- East Asia, the Mediterranean region and Africa were found to have the highest lifetime prevalence of physical and/or sexual IPV. According to the analysis of data from 77 studies conducted by World Health Organization (WHO), 33% of women have ever experienced physical or sexual violence in Africa region, which was similar to South-East Asia and Mediterranean region (31%). Within the region, the national surveys demonstrated that the prevalence of lifetime physical and/or sexual violence among women from age 15 to 49 years ranges from 47% in Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) to 16 % in Cameroon . Similarly, the national survey in Rwanda also found that 38% of Rwandan women experience physical and /or sexual violence in their life time which keeps placing Rwanda among the countries with the highest prevalence of intimate partner violence in the world. Recently data from the 2019/2020 Rwanda Demographic and Health Survey(RDHS) has showed that the percentage of women who report IPV experience increased from 40.1% in 2015 to 46% in 2020 but declined from 21% to 17% for men in the same period Exposure to IPV, like any other experiences of violence (gender-based violence, sexual violence), is reported to have deleterious and long-lasting negative effects on the victims. Research findings and clinic records have shown that women who are victims of IPV are likely to report a wide range of negative health consequences (physical and mental) such as depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), suicide ideations and attempts, alcohol and drug use disorders, physical injuries, and even death.The negative effect of the IPV exposure is reported to affect offspring, meaning that children from families where there is violence may also suffer from a range of behavioral and emotional problems. On the other hand, there is well documented associations between psychopathology and IPV victimization and perpetration. Such comorbidity implies that the association between IPV and mental disorders is bi-directional, meaning that IPV may cause mental sufferance and vice-versa; as such mentally ill individuals are likely to experience or inflict frequent IPV than non-mentally affected individuals.
The genocide committed against Tutsi in Rwanda has left the surviving victims with deep wounds and scars, both physical and mental, which are seen particularly during commemoration events . As from the growing research interests assessing the long-lasting effects of the genocide on both the general population and survivors, results yield quite high prevalence of mental disorders in both samples, with highest scores in the sub-sample of survivors. Equally, scholars estimate the post-traumatic burden to affect not only the direct victims of the genocide but possibly their offspring as well through different mechanisms of transmission. In the same vein, chronic mental disorders, particularly PTSD and depression, are considered to be predictors of the worsening of family harmony and sometimes leading to disputes and related IPV related psychopathologies. In an effort to address IPV and its associated mental health problems being a public health concern in post-genocide Rwanda, some NGOs have developed and implemented programs aimed at empowering women and changing community norms that support violence and male dominance in sub-Saharan Africa. These programs are reported to have had a positive effect on IPV victimization and perpetration with additional intervention benefits like improvement in depression symptoms, conflict management, communication, trust, self-efficacy, household earnings, food security and actions to prevent IPV. Such programs have focused on raising awareness on domestic violence and intimate partner violence, with a working hypothesis that the increase of knowledge on the IPV phenomenon will reduce its perpetration and victimization. Moreover, these studies were limited in their design as few interventions worked on past-mental burden which is likely to negatively affect couples' communication and intimacy. Equally, little attention was directed to the anxiety and PTSD disorders which were estimated to be ubiquitous to IPV exposure and perpetration.
However, amongst the local organizations intervening in the area of domestic violence in Rwanda, the Life Wounds Healing Association (LIWOHA) has almost twenty years' experience of intensive work in communities managing IPV from a Community Based Approach (CBA) by integrating psychoeducation, psychosocial support and emotions management models. The working paradigm of the organisation is that violent behaviours in couples are induced by life wounds rooted in the past. Therefore, unless perpetrators and victims discover the real cause of their violent behaviours and work on them, it assumed that awareness raising and law enforcement themselves will not discourage IPV perpetrators.
In a longitudinal study design examining the impact of the LIWOHA group-based intervention, revealed that the approach was effective in bringing together members of opposing groups (survivors and perpetrators of the genocide) by facilitating mutual healing and restored trust; establishing new social identities, and regained a strong sense of belonging. While this approach is being utilized in managing IPV cases, none of the existing studies have assessed it's effectiveness in lowering IPV perpetration and victimization occurrence as well as it's improvement in outcomes like anxiety, depression, and PTSD symptoms.
Therefore, the aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the community-based approach in managing IPV, anxiety, depression and PTSD among individuals reporting IPV.
Methods Participants
Participants are to be recruited from Ntungamo and Kankuba cells in Mageragere Sector, City of Kigali. From a list submitted by the Sector Executive Secretary of 113 couples considered by the local authorities as conflicting couples, 58 couples from both cells were eligible for this study. Eligibility criteria included the consent, experience of IPV and availing time to attend all the workshop sessions. Couples accepting to participate in the research were randomly distributed in treatment and control groups. Given number of eligible participants (58 couples), and the need to reduce the number of couples to 15 for both groups, the "first come, first served" principle was used. As such, 32 couples, 17 from Nkankuba Cell (Treatment group) and 15 couples from Ntungamo Cell (control group) granted their consent to participate in the research either as experimental or control.
Procedure
Experimental group will receive the LIWOHA workshops package delivered by a clinical psychologist working with the organization. It will be important that the sessions are facilitated by the same trained staff from the organization to ensure accuracy and fidelity. The workshops structure will take13 days, with time interval of 3 to 4 weeks between sessions. The interval time will mean for participants to practice what they will learn from the preceding session. Structured interviews were conducted in each workshop for the experimental group. On the side of the control group, which did not receive the LIWOHA package, participants were also assessed at the same time as the experimental group. The control group will only be followed and supported by the cells personnel by educating participants on the existing laws and policies for mitigating and punishing all IPV behaviours.
Treatment manualisation
The community-based approach on IPV and sexual violence is conceived as a dynamic process where community members willing to recover from life wounds induced by IPV and sexual violence agree to share their lived experiences in order to work on them accordingly and to support each other in this healing journey. The main steps or sessions of a community healing program can be summarized as follow:
Tools
The HITS (Hurt, Insult, Threaten, and Scream) is a 7 items Likert scale which is used to evaluate intimate partner violence. All items were scored as: 0=never, 1=rarely, 2=sometimes, 3=fairly often, and 4=frequently. The total scores ranged from Score 0 to 24.
The Hopkins Symptom Check List-25 is a 25 items instrument which is used to measure common psychiatric symptoms of depression and anxiety in both clinical and non-clinical samples.The first 10 items assess anxiety symptoms and the remaining 15 items assess depression.
The PTSD Checklist (PCL-5) is a 20 items self-reported instrument that was used to evaluate the symptoms of PTSD. All items were scored on the Likert scale: 0=Not at all, 1=A little bit, 2=moderately, 3=Quite a bit and 4=extremely. The total score ranged from 0 to 20.
Ethical consideration
The study was submitted and approved by the University of Rwanda College of Medicine and Health Sciences' Institutional Review Board (IRB); approval letter No 033/CMHS-IRB/2020 of 18th February 2020. Ethical principles were fully complied for and included free informed consent and privacy principles.
Data analysis
Data will be analysed descriptively to describe the characteristics of participants.The effectiveness of community-based approach to victims/perpetrators of Intimate partner violence and mental health disorders will be evaluated using a mixed ANOVAs with a within-subjects' factors and a between-subjects factor. All analysis has to be performed using Statistical Package for Social sciences (SPSS) version 25.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: