Human Papillomavirus Vaccine Integrated Service Implementation Research in Cameroon
Human Papillomavirus Vaccine Integrated Service Implementation Research in Cameroon
The goal of this implementation research study is to understand whether a package of community-based interventions can increase access to and uptake of the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine among very young adolescent girls and boys in the North and Far North Regions of Cameroon. The main questions this study aims to answer are:
To evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention, researchers will compare HPV vaccination within regions where the new intervention model is being implemented (intervention areas) to regions where the new routine HPV vaccination delivery model is not being implemented (comparison areas) for approximately 1 year before the new intervention model is implemented and for approximately 9 months after the start of implementation to compare changes over time and between intervention and comparison areas.
The study will evaluate the effect of the intervention on HPV vaccination delivery using routine health facility data.
To understand acceptability, feasibility, implementation, and potential for scale, the study will enroll participants including health officials and providers, adolescents girls receiving HPV vaccination and other services in intervention areas, and their parents/caregivers. The study will be conducted in two phases, with the first phase focused on gathering formative data through interviews with key informants. This data will be used to inform the design of the intervention, which will be implemented and evaluated in phase 2. Only phase 1 of this study protocol has been currently approved.
In phase 1, key informant interview participants will be asked to participate in a an interview to discuss HPV vaccination services and their perspectives on how to integrate HPV vaccination within existing community-based and health facility structures and programs. Key informants will include government officials, health program implementers, representatives from non-government organizations working on HPV vaccine delivery, and healthcare providers, as well as community leaders including school and religious leaders.
Introduction Cervical cancer is a leading cause of cancer among women in Cameroon. Vaccinating very young adolescent girls and boys is the most effective long-term strategy to reduce its risk. Despite the introduction of the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine in Cameroon in 2020, the vaccination program has faced substantial challenges, including widespread vaccine hesitancy and low awareness of the vaccine. As a result, an initial approach focusing on school-based vaccination was shifted to routine, health facility-based distribution. Integrating HPV vaccinations into existing health platforms that reach very young adolescents and their caregivers presents an opportunity to improve the effectiveness, acceptability, and feasibility of routine, community-based HPV vaccination in Cameroon. Implementation research is needed to evaluate the effectiveness of such integrated service delivery approaches, contributing to more effective HPV vaccine programs in Cameroon and other, similar settings.
Objectives The aim of this research project is to evaluate the effectiveness, feasibility, acceptability, and potential for scalability of integrating HPV vaccination into an existing supply- and demand-side sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) intervention to increase HPV vaccine coverage among girls and boys aged 9-13 years in the North and far North regions of Cameroon. The intervention will aim to deliver HPV vaccination through integration with demand- and supply-side program interventions in addition to an existing program implemented by Population Services International-Cameroon (PSI-C) and Association Camerounaise pour le Marketing Social (ACMS): Programme d'Accès aux Services de Santé de la Reproduction (PASSR).
Specific objectives
Methods The study will be conducted in 4 intervention PASSR health districts (HDs) and 4 'standard of care' comparison HDs in the North and Far North regions of Cameroon. It will use a hybrid model of effectiveness and implementation research, with research conducted from approval until December 2025 (with the potential for ongoing data analysis, manuscript preparation, and dissemination through conferences and publications after this end date). Phase 1, the rapid formative and design phase, research activities will include interviews with key informants and secondary analysis of service statistics and program monitoring data. Key informant interview data will contribute to the development of the implementation model, which will also be informed by programmatic co-design workshops. The second phase (implementation) will include a quasi-experimental effectiveness study comparing HPV vaccine administration to girls and boys aged 9-13 years in the intervention and comparison areas, as well as implementation research activities to assess uptake, reach, implementation, activity-based costing and readiness for integration and scale-up. In addition, phase 2 will include analyses of acceptability, feasibility, and satisfaction, using data from key informant interviews; and quantitative exit interviews, focus group discussions, and qualitative in-depth interviews with girls, boys, and caregivers and health professionals. A mixed methodology, integrating quantitative and qualitative research methods, will be used.
During the formative phase (phase 1), primary data collection will consist of around forty key informant interviews (KIIs), 20 per implementation region; in addition, a secondary analysis of existing routine data will be carried out. During the implementation phase (phase 2), approximately 40 key informant interviews with key stakeholders and a further 40 in-depth interviews with health workers, girls and boys aged 9-13 affected by the programme and their caregivers (e.g. parents and/or guardians) will be conducted. Exit interviews will be conducted with approximately 400 VYA/caregiver dyads after receiving HPV vaccination services in intervention areas. In addition, anonymized routine monitoring data, including aggregated service delivery data collected from the programme monitoring systems as well as from the Cameroon Ministry of Health's DHIS2 platform (an open source health information management system) and other existing data sources, will be extracted and analyzed in both comparison and intervention sites to assess the effectiveness of the intervention. Costing data will also be collected. No primary data collection proposed in this study will be conducted in comparison health facilities or their catchment areas; routine data from comparison facilities will be extracted from DHIS2 and other routine program monitoring systems only for the purposes of the effectiveness component. Primary quantitative data (e.g. exit interviews) will be collected electronically using structured questionnaires, administered via the Open Data Kit on study devices. Qualitative interviews will be recorded using digital audio recorders.
Descriptive analysis, using frequencies, percentages, cross-tabulations, graphs and multivariate and time series analysis, will be carried out to analyze and present the quantitative data. Qualitative data will be systematically transcribed and analyzed using thematic analysis, in which the data will be structured and analyzed using a hybrid deductive-inductive approach, in which the qualitative data is parsed into codes based on the semi-structured interview guide (deductive) as well as emergent codes (inductive). The study protocol will be reviewed and approved by the Cameroon National Ethics Committee and the Population Services International Research Ethics Board (REB). The content of the consent will be explained verbally and written informed consent/assent will be obtained from all study participants; written parental/guardian consent will also be obtained for all minor participants.
Expected outcomes The expected outcome of this study is to provide evidence of the effectiveness, acceptability and scalability of integrating HPV vaccination into existing SRHR supply- and demand-side programming in order to increase HPV vaccination coverage among girls and boys aged 9-13 years in the North and Far North regions of Cameroon. Qualitative results will provide insight into the acceptability of this approach among caregivers, adolescents and health providers, while assessments of scalability and readiness for integration will provide crucial information on feasibility and cost-effectiveness.
The main results of the study will include data on HPV vaccination and other VYA services among girls and boys aged 9-13 in the intervention and comparison areas. The results of the study will be disseminated at a national workshop and scientific conferences, and the findings THwill be submitted for publication in peer-reviewed journals.
Currently, only phase 1 of this study protocol has been approved. A later review and approval of phase 2 activities will be obtained prior to the commencement of phase 2.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
crothschild@psi.org206-909-6982