Low EnerGy DiEt iN Adolescents With Obesity and Type 2 Diabetes: The LEGEND Study

A Multicentre Open-Label, Feasibility Study of the Use of a Short-Term Low-Energy Diet in Adolescents With Obesity and Type-2 Diabetes Mellitus

This is a multicentre, single-arm, feasibility study in adolescents with T2DM and obesity to investigate the recruitment and retention rates to a study using Low Energy Diets(LED). It will also provide estimates of weight loss needed to bring about remission to inform a larger randomised study. In addition a subgroup of participants and their parents/carers undertaking a period of LED will be interviewed to understand the participants experience of taking part. Two further groups will also be interviewed: participants and their parents/carers who have declined to take part in the LED to understand their motivations and barriers and healthcare practitioners who have participated in conducting the trial to understand their experience of the study.

LED intervention

The three-stage intervention, will be delivered by the local study dietitian and doctor. Participants will typically undergo a 12-week intensive LED intervention followed by a 12-week Food Re-introduction (FR) phase and then a Weight Maintenance (WM) phase. The aim is for participants to lose 15kg (or 15% of starting body weight if<80kg at baseline) and achieve remission defined as an HbA1C <48 mmol/mol three months apart.

The LED phase consists of a total meal replacement (TMR) diet for 12 weeks which contains 800-1000cal/day (with LED diets typically containing 800-1200kcal/day), and has been previously shown to be safe in young people. Available products include shakes, soups and bars from providers such as Cambridge 1:1, Lighter Life and Optifast. TMR products will be supplied and distributed by the study team at no cost to the participant. The experience of other investigators suggests that having prepared shakes and bars reduces the anxiety associated with meal choices and preparation. If participants are not able to adhere to only four meal replacement products a day, a low-energy meal option for up to one meal a day (instead of a TMR product and using low-calorie recipes provided as part of the study) may be suggested and discussed by the research team.

Following the initial LED phase, participants will enter the FR phase, typically over the next 12 weeks. This consists of a gradual reintroduction of food one meal at a time, in a structured stepwise progression and under the supervision of a dietitian. A recipe book of 400-500 kcal recipes has been developed for this purpose.

If the target weight is achieved before 12 weeks, the FR phase may be brought forward.

If the HbA1C has fallen to below the pre-diabetes range (less than 42 mmol/mol) on point of care testing, but the target weight has not been achieved, FR phase may still be initiated at 12 weeks. If the target weight is not achieved by 12 weeks and the HbA1C remains 48 mmol/mol or above, the LED phase could be extended to a maximum of a total of 20 weeks duration, in discussion with the participant and the parents/carers, as appropriate.

If, during FR, the participant gains 2kg or more, there is flexibility to regress a step along the FR pathway, at the discretion of the local team and in discussion with the participant and their family, mirroring the successful pragmatic approach of the DiRECT study. For instance, a participant who has introduced their first meal and gains 2kg, may go back to full LED; someone who has gained weight after moving from two to three meals a day may go back to two meals. A participant who gains 2kg or more in the WM phase, may similarly go back one step to two meals a day. Locally, our experience using the LED showed the importance of a flexible approach, with some young people finding benefit from a short break (e.g. for a family celebration) or a preference to start during school holidays.

Current standard practice is to measure weight at each clinic with height and HbA1C checked once every 3 months. In addition to these routine measurements, data on participants' weight, height, HbA1C and adherence will be collected by the local diabetes team at each face-to-face visit and entered directly into the study data collection forms by either a study healthcare professional (HCP) or research nurse, as well as recorded in the participants medical record.

During the LED and FR phases, participants will have two-weekly clinical contact with face-to-face contact at least every four weeks which will include repeat anthropometry (including weight and blood pressure). Biochemistry will be repeated.

During the maintenance phase, contacts will aim to be every four weeks with no more than six weeks between contacts.

Participants' data will be collected by the local diabetes team or research nurses at each visit and recorded in the participants medical record. Data will be entered into the study approved electronic case-report form (CRF) system by the local diabetes or research teams.

Study questionnaires will be undertaken at baseline, during LED, during FR and in the follow-up period using an approved electronic CRF system by either the participant or research nurse. Physical activity assessment, MRI scans and dual x-ray anthropometry (DXA) scans will be undertaken at baseline, during the transition between phases and at the end of the study period. Physical activity level will be assessed by using activity trackers, six-minute walking test and a physical activity questionnaire. MRI scans will measure internal adipose deposits and DXA will measure fat and lean mass, bone mineral density and bone mineral content. Blood samples will be taken and analysed in local laboratories of units participating in the study. Results of tests undertaken locally will be entered on participants' CRF by the local research team.

Additional Interviews

Semi-structured interviews will be undertaken by a chartered clinical psychologist with a subset of the young people who took part in the LED intervention to understand the adolescents experience of taking part in the study midway through the study and at the end.

Semi-structured interviews will also be undertaken by a chartered clinical psychologist with 10 young people and/or their family who opted not to take part in the LED study to help understand barriers to participation and how these can be minimised.

Qualitative interviews will also be conducted with at least 10 healthcare professionals from different sites involved in the study to garner feedback and experience as well as the HCPs impression of the experience of the study for the participants and their families.

It is suggested that the proposed number of interview participants will be sufficient to meet the research aims. However, data saturation (whereby no new information is reported) will guide the recruitment process. In each case, purposefully constructed interview guides will be formulated to enhance the rigour of the data generated. All interviews will be conducted remotely with Hilton Health Consultancy via an approved platform. All interviews will be recorded and transcribed and analysed by Hilton Health Consultancy.

This feedback will be instrumental in informing and shaping any subsequent randomised control trial.

Inclusion criteria

LED intervention

• Diagnosis of T2DM (defined as an HbA1C ≥48mmol/mol, in the absence of features of type 1 or monogenic/syndromic diabetes).

• Current HbA1C ≥48 (or ≥42 on antidiabetic medication) and ≤ 80 mmol/mol. To allow for the day-to-day variation in HbA1C and differences between point of care laboratory tests, -2 or +2 mmol/mol in the HbA1C result will be allowed in the current criteria if one of them is between or equal to 42-80mmol/mol.

• Aged 12 to 17 years old.

• BMI ≥981st centile (+2 SD) for age and sex (UK90 growth reference data).

• Informed consent:

  • Received from the young person (age 16-17) OR
  • Received from young person's parent/carer, with patient assent (age 12-15).

• Willing to engage in and commit to low energy diet, FR and weight management phases including follow-up and attending study visits.

LED Intervention Interviews

The same interview inclusion criteria for LED intervention, with the following additional requirements:

Patients:

• Informed consent:

  • Received from the young person (age 16-17) OR
  • Received from young person's parent/carer, with patient assent (age 12-15).

• Willing to take part in a qualitative interview alongside a parent/carer.

Relative/Carer:

• A relative/carer for a young person meeting the above LED participant eligibility criteria.
• Informed consent from the relative/carer to participate in the interview.
• Willing to take part in a qualitative interview alongside the young person.

Non-LED Qualitative Interview only participants

• Diagnosis of T2DM (defined as an HbA1C ≥48mmol/mol, in the absence of features of type 1 or monogenic/syndromic diabetes).

• Current HbA1C ≥48 (or ≥42 on antidiabetic medication) and ≤80 mmol/mol.

• Aged 12 to 17 years old.

• BMI ≥91st centile (+2 SD) for age and sex (UK90 growth reference data).

• Informed consent:

  • Received from the young person (age 16-17) OR
  • Received from young person's parent/carer, with patient assent (age 12-15).

• Willing to take part in a qualitative interview alongside a parent/carer only.

HCPs

• Registered HCP.
• Experience of delivering this trial to the adolescents.
• Willing to take part in a qualitative interview about undertaking motivational interviewing training and conducting/delivering the LED intervention study.

Exclusion criteria

LED intervention

• HbA1C greater than 82mmol/mol (to allow for the variation in HbA1c differences).
• Presence of diabetes-related autoantibodies, as per local centre guidelines.
• Confirmed mono-genetic cause of obesity (e.g. SIM1 mutation) or diabetes-associated syndrome such as Prader-Willi syndrome, Bardet-Biedl or Wolfram's syndrome.
• Secondary diabetes (post bone marrow transplant/chemotherapy).
• Significant psychiatric co-morbidity.
• Breastfeeding, pregnant or planning to conceive during the LED and FR phases (female participants will be advised on need for effective contraceptive methods during the 12-month study period, section 5.1.1.10).
• Any other condition which, in the opinion of the study investigator, would make it inappropriate to undertake a period of LED. (All reasons for not approaching patients will be recorded and analysed anonymously. Cases can be discussed with the core study group if there is doubt).
• Participation in another interventional trial within 6 months.
• Informed consent and/or assent not received.
• Pre-existing retinopathy.
• Dietary avoidance (including, but not limited to, due to allergies, intolerances, religious reasons and lifestyle choices) to any ingredients in the meal replacement products, including lactose.
• Previous scoliosis repair.

Non-LED Qualitative Interview only participants

• HbA1C greater than 80mmol/mol.
• Presence of diabetes-related autoantibodies, as per local centre guidelines.
• Confirmed mono-genetic cause of obesity (e.g. SIM1 mutation) or diabetes-associated syndrome such as Prader-Willi syndrome, Bardet-Biedl or Wolfram's syndrome.
• Secondary diabetes (post bone marrow transplant/chemotherapy).
• Significant psychiatric co-morbidity.
• Breastfeeding, pregnant or planning to conceive during the LED and FR phases (female participants will be advised on need for effective contraceptive methods during the 12-month study period, section 5.1.1.10).
• Any other condition which, in the opinion of the study investigator, would either make it inappropriate to undertake a period of LED. (All reasons for not approaching patients will be recorded and analysed anonymously. Cases can be discussed with the core study group if there is doubt).
• Participation in another interventional trial within 6 months.
• Informed consent and/or assent not received.
• Pre-existing retinopathy.
• Dietary avoidance (including, but not limited to, due to allergies, intolerances, religious reasons and lifestyle choices) to any ingredients in the meal replacement products, including lactose.
• Previous scoliosis repair.

HCPs

• None.