A Feasibility Study Assessing the Acceptability, Adherence, and Safety of Photobiomodulation (PBM) Therapy and Objective Assessment Measures in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME)
A Feasibility Study Assessing the Acceptability, Adherence, and Safety of Photobiomodulation (PBM) Therapy and Objective Assessment Measures in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME)
There is no cure or approved treatments for ME. Several causes have been implicated in ME, including poor mitochondrial function. Mitochondria are the powerhouse of cells, producing energy. Therefore, loss of mitochondrial function and reduced energy production could be an explanation for the debilitating chronic fatigue that defines ME.
The primary site of red light absorption in cells is the mitochondria. Mitochondrial red light absorption can boost energy production. Light therapy is already FDA approved for the treatment of acne, muscle and joint pain, arthritis, blood circulation issues and hair loss. This is the first study to trial the use of red light therapy in ME and results will help us understand if the use of red light therapy is accepted by ME patients.
In past clinical trials the monitoring of symptom reduction/increase in ME patients was mainly done using symptom questionnaires. These questionnaires have not been specifically developed for ME symptoms and therefore the reliability of results is poor. This study will be assessing the use of a new symptom questionnaire developed specifically for ME and will also be trialling the use of other tools to measure symptom reduction/increase.
In addition, this study will also trial the use of Mantal, an online remote research management portal. This is to improve accessibility of ME patients to research participation.
Each ME participants involvement in the study should take approximately 7 weeks. Involvement is split into four phases: 1) baseline, 2) intervention, 3) follow-up and 4) feedback.
Baseline assessments:
Intervention:
- Participants are posted the red lamp to use in their own homes during weeks three and four. Participants use the red lamp for two minutes, daily, each morning for a total of 14 days.
Follow-up:
Feedback:
- Participants are asked to complete an online questionnaire during week seven.
The prevailing theory regarding mechanism of action of PBM is that by activating cytochrome c oxidase (CCO) it boosts mitochondrial ATP production, which, in turn, enhances the metabolic activity of the cell. This occurs simultaneously with the regulation of the reduction/oxidation (redox) state of the intracellular microenvironment favouring expression of genes associated with tissue regeneration and repair. Immune modulation and dampening or attenuation of pro-inflammatory responses ensures a coordinated regenerative effort. An alternate mechanism of action, independent of the absorption of red and near infrared light by CCO, proposes that by reducing the viscosity of interfacial water layers in the predominantly hydrophilic intramitochondrial space PBM increases the speed of rotation and activity of the mitochondrial rotary motor (ATP synthase) that results in increased ATP production. Irrespective of the exact biochemical mechanism of action, crucially, these processes take place in the absence of inciting tissue injury, photothermal effects, or photoacoustic effects.
While the underlying causes of ME/CFS are not know a consistent finding from metabolism-based studies is mitochondrial dysfunction and compromised energy metabolism characterised by high levels of oxidative stress and limited ATP production. Loss of mitochondrial function and compromised ATP production is therefore a plausible explanation for the debilitating chronic fatigue that defines ME/CFS. Based upon prior human studies demonstrating restored ATP production and function investigators hypothesise that PBM and 670nm red light exposure will, by increasing mitochondrial function in ME/CFS patients, improve their physical capacity and cognitive function.
The device that will be used to evaluate red light therapy in ME/CFS patients is an LED lamp that emits a spectrum of light in the red spectrum of visible light, peaking at 670 nm. This lamp was purchased from Planet Lighting Ltd, London, UK; LBT-PAR38-40. This lamp has the following specifications: 1) 40W output, 2) 60o beam angle, 3) 220-240V 50Hz input, 4) E27 base, 5) has a UK Conformity Assessed (UKCA) marking, 6) has CE certification, 7) is Restriction of Hazardous Substances Directive (RoHS) compliant, 8) has a 3 years warranty. It is important to note that this is not a medical device and will be marketed by Planet Lighting as an aid to general health wellbeing lamp for the general population. The Planet Lighting website advertising this product is currently being developed. The director from Planet Lighting has confirmed this in a letter.
Participants will be identified through the UK charity Invest in ME Research. Potential participants are those who have subscribed to the charity. The charity will email subscribers the study flyer and the participant invitation letter. The study flyer and participant invitation letter will include a link to the study specific website on Mantal. The homepage of the study website will contain a summary of the study and a link to the full participant information sheet which ME patients can either download and print or read online.
At the end of the full participant information sheet participants will be instructed on how to provide their informed consent if they wish to participate. Participants will be asked to click on the "register now" button on the homepage of the study website. When participants click on the register now button they will be taken through a series of statements for their consent. If participants consent to all of the statements they will then be taken to a sign up page where participants are able to register for the study with their first and last name and email address. They will be asked to provide a password for their account.
After participants have provided informed consent and created an account on the study website participants will be asked to complete a screening questionnaire on the study website. Participants who fulfil the eligibility criteria will receive a notification to inform them that they are eligible and have been enrolled onto the study. The notification also prompts participants to log in to Mantal to complete baseline study procedures. Participants who do not fulfil the eligibility criteria will be notified on the screen that they are unable to participate in the study at this time and will receive a QIB withdrawal letter via email.
Once participants are enrolled onto the study, participants will be asked to complete the "About You" questionnaire, which will collect information on the participants demographics and ME diagnosis.
Then participants will move onto baseline measures. The first baseline measure participants are asked to complete is the FUNCAP27 questionnaire, which assesses functional capacity. Participants will complete the FUNCAP27 questionnaire online through Mantal. Once participants have completed this questionnaire, they will then complete the battery of six online cognitive function assessments from NeurOn (https://neuropsychology.online) in the following order: 1) reaction time, 2a) word encoding, 2b) word retrieval, 3) trails A, 4) trails B, 5) digit span backwards and 6) fragmented letters. Participants will complete cognitive assessments online through Mantal. Participants can choose to either complete the FUNCAP27 questionnaire and the cognitive function assessments on the same day or on separate days. Participants are asked to try to complete as many of the cognitive function assessments as they feel able to. Before and after each cognitive function assessment participants are asked to rate their level of cognitive fatigue (from 1 to 10, 1 being the worst and 10 being the best) and asked if they feel well enough to complete the next cognitive function assessment. If participants answer no, then the battery of cognitive function assessments will be terminated for that participant. Participants will receive daily text or email reminders to complete the FUNCAP27 and NeurOn assessments. After participants have completed or terminated the cognitive function assessments they will be asked to provide their address for the research team to mail the GENEActiv wrist worn accelerometer monitor and instructions to participants. Participants will be asked to complete an equipment disclaimer form online prior to wearing the accelerometer. Participants will be asked to wear these monitors immediately upon receipt for a total of seven days. Participants will receive daily automatic text reminders sent out by Mantal to wear the monitor. Participants are asked to enter the date they start wearing the monitor onto the study portal. Once participants have confirmed they are wearing the monitor, participants will be able to complete the morning and evening entries of the consensus sleep diary version E (CSD-E) for the seven days they are wearing the monitor. Participants will receive daily text reminders (automatically sent out by Mantal) to complete the CSD-E morning and evening entries. Seven days from the date they start wearing the monitor participants will receive a text reminder (automatically sent out by Mantal) to take off the monitors and to post them back to the research team using the prepaid envelope. Participants who are housebound are asked to contact the research team to arrange a courier to collect the GENEActiv accelerometer from participants homes. Participants will receive a text reminder daily until the research team has received the monitor. The PI will download the raw data from the devices internal memory and perform a quality control (QC) check that the monitor has worked and recorded activity for 7 days. If the monitor has not worked participants will be requested to repeat the wear of the monitor and completing the CSD-E.
Once the activity monitor data has passed the QC the red lamp (Planet Lighting Ltd, London, UK) will be posted to participants with instructions for use. Participants will complete an online donated equipment disclaimer form before using the lamps. Participants will be asked to use this lamp for 2 minutes, daily (between 9:00 and 11:00), for a total of 2 weeks. Participants will receive daily text reminders at 8:30 to use the lamp. Participants will be asked to log on to mantal each day and record whether they have managed to use the lamp that day. After using the lamp for 2 weeks participants will be asked to return the lamp back to the research team using the prepaid postage labels. Participants who are housebound are asked to contact the research team to arrange a home collection via courier.
Once participants have finished the intervention, they are asked to complete the FUNCAP27 questionnaire, NeurOn assessments, wear the GENEActiv monitor and the complete the CSD-E. This will be undertaken following the same protocol as the baseline measures. Once the research team has received the monitors in the post participants will be asked to complete a feedback questionnaire via Mantal.
The end of the study will be when the last participant has completed the feedback questionnaire.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: