Evaluation of Training Curriculum and Service of Improving Access to Community Therapies
Evaluation of Training Curriculum and Service of Improving Access to Community Therapies
The current study aims to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of a training curriculum designed for teaching low-intensity psychological interventions to bachelor's degree holders, specifically focusing on principles of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and its intervention effectiveness. This evaluation is divided into two integral parts.
In the first part, the curriculum, which encompasses a 120-hour intensive teaching block followed by a nine-month placement, will be evaluated. To assess the trainees' competencies in applying the principles of ACT, a series of role-play examinations will be administered at various time points, including pre-training, pre-placement, mid-placement, and end-of-placement. Focus groups will be conducted.
The second part of the evaluation is to examine the outcomes of low-intensity psychological interventions, delivered by the trainees, targeting adult individuals screened with mild to severe symptoms of depression and anxiety. To achieve this, a series of questionnaires will be administered at several stages: pre-intervention, during each session, and at a three-month follow-up. Outcome measures will include the assessment of depressive and anxiety symptom severity, quality of life, functional impairment, therapeutic alliance, and the level of experiential avoidance. Individual exit interviews and focus groups will be conducted.
The aim of the study:
Hypotheses:
It is hypothesised that the competency level of the training participants will increase after the intensive training block and the placement. It is also hypothesised that after receiving the low-intensity psychological intervention based on the ACT principle, the depression and anxiety scores, functioning impairment, and experiential avoidance level will reduce, and quality of life and therapeutic relationship will improve.
'Training Participants': Participants from the Psychological Wellbeing Practitioners (PWPs) Programme will be invited to participate in the research. The PWPs are bachelors. Degree holders will undergo 120 hours of intensive training block, followed by a 9-month placement to practise the learnt skills. Given therapist competency will be part of the program, this research will request the participants to consent to the use of the data collected in the program.
'Service Participants': Individuals with depression or anxiety symptoms will be sampled in this study. Participants will be recruited from the placement organisations and promotions on social media, web pages, and at mental health centres. The sample size is estimated to be 300 individuals for initial screening for LIACT-guided self-help services.
Research design:
For training evaluation, given the current training programme already consists of a therapist competency assessment to ensure the quality of the training participants. Recorded role-play videos will be rated the ACT therapist competency by trained psychologists at pre-training, post-training block, mid-placement and post-placement. A consent form will be sent to the training participant to authorise the use of data for analysis.
Repeated measures design will be adopted for this study. Individual guided self-help LIACT service, eligible participants will receive 6-8 sessions of guided self-help LIACT over three to four months. Clinical outcomes (depression and anxiety levels) will be measured at every session, it will take around 5 minutes to complete these two routine outcome measures. Other primary and secondary outcome measures, including functioning impairment, quality of life, psychological flexibility, experiential avoidance, absenteeism, and therapeutic alliance will be at 3 time points, namely pre-treatment, post-treatment (at the end of the last session) and 3-month follow-up. Participants will take around 30 minutes to complete the full package of assessments. These outcome variables will be additionally measured after each session to avoid missing data if participants drop out. The recovery rate and reliable improvement rate will also be used as indicators to evaluate the efficacy of LIACT. Focus groups will be conducted on participants who drop out and complete the programme to understand their experience and journey.
Curriculum The LIACT training curriculum is designed by registered clinical psychologists with consultation from local ACT experts from the Association of Contextual and Behavioural Science (Hong Kong Chapter). There are 5 modules in the intensive training block including introduction, professional and ethics issues, application of ACT low-intensity intervention, troubleshooting and preparation for clinical placement. The LIACT protocol is also piloted and revised by clinical psychologists to ensure its adaptability to local situations. After 120- hour intensive training, the training participants will attend a role play exam to ensure their competency to proceed with the 9-month placement. During the 9-month placement, each PWP is expected to see at least 15 direct service beneficiaries to provide LIACT. During this supervision will be provided regularly to ensure the quality of service delivery and risk management. There will be a mid-placement review and final placement review, and the training participants will submit audio recordings for supervisors to rate for their competence.
A focus group will be conducted for the training participants to understand their learning experience.
Treatment Guided self-help LIACT will be provided to eligible participants. For individual guided self-help LIACT service, an intake assessment will be conducted to assess the presenting problem of the participants at pre-treatment to ensure the suitability to receive LIACT service. Participants will be given the LIACT self-help workbook collaboratively with a PWP. Between each session, clients will read through the workbook and complete the exercises suggested in the workbook. In subsequent sessions, PWP will guide clients to overcome the difficulties in performing the LIACT exercises.
Therapists PWPs will be responsible for providing LIACT to the participants. PWPs have completed a 120-hour intensive training and pass the role play examination prior to placement provision. The training was provided by experienced clinical psychologists and counsellors. Moreover, PWPs are under regular supervision by clinical psychologists, experienced counsellors, or social workers with extensive ACT training.
Inclusion Criteria:
18-65 years old adults with any of the following problem(s):
Exclusion Criteria:
Adults with the following features/ presentations are not eligible for the PWP programme and should automatically lead to an onward referral:
Individuals with any of the following diagnoses or situations are also excluded:
jacky.chow@mind.org.hk+852 9145 2584
candice.powell@mind.org.hk+852 3643 0869
Hong Kong, China
ivychan.hm@aka.org.hk+852 2552 0994
cmcheng@bokss.org.hk+852 3413 1500
emily.chu@cedarcom.hk+852 2616 0119
hannah.reidy@mind.org.hk+852 2824 0822
shroff@centralminds.hk+852 2813 6108
apple.sung@fuhong.org+852 2214 2500
pauline.liu@hku.hk+852 3917 1419
timothy.or@hkuspace-plk.hku.hk+852 3923 7121
vickitang@hkphab.org.hk+852 2551 4226
kunst.kaman@gmail.com+852 6771 3626
erictsui@ln.edu.hk+852 2616 8274
jacky.chow@mind.org.hk+852 9145 2584
candice.powell@mind.org.hk+852 3643 0869
erica.lam@jardines.com+852 2579 2104
erica.chen@pathfinders.org.hk+852 5621 8239
erin@runhk.org+852 9096 5502
virginie@runhk.org+852 6110 3391
soco.kikileung@gmail.com+852 2729 2209
elda.chan@sjccs.hk+852 2525 7207
sandy.ma@hkfyg.org.hk+852 3755 7216
jerrywong@mhahk.org.hk+852 2834 9618
amandine@wyng.hk+852 9773 0828
kys@ylth.org.hk+852 6097 8461