Lemborexant for Insomnia in a Patient With Dementia: An N-of-1 Trial
Lemborexant for Insomnia in a Patient With Dementia: An N-of-1 Trial
Insomnia is a highly common, chronic disorder that is distressful for the patient but also for caregivers and can give rise to a heavy burden on the healthcare team. Sleeping aids like benzodiazepines and other sedatives (e.g., zolpidem, zopiclone) have been widely used to help treat insomnia. However, sleeping aids are also known to cause adverse drug reactions such as drowsiness and dizziness, that increases the risk of falls, driving impairment, visual impairment, cognitive impairment, and upon discontinuation may cause paradoxical rebound insomnia, delirium, and nightmares all of which exacerbate the initial insomnia. All of the negative aspects of sleeping aid use are exaggerated for older, frail adults.
Some patients experience an early (young-age) onset dementia with a substantial component of insomnia. Due to the many risks associated with traditional sleeping aids they are often inappropriate in adults living with cognitive impairment and/or frailty. Lemborexant comes from a new class of medications for insomnia. Lemborexant is a dual orexin receptor antagonist that blocks the binding of wake-promoting neuropeptides orexin A and orexin B to their receptors orexin 1 receptor (OX1R) and orexin 2 receptor (OX2R), which is thought to suppress wake drive. Unlike other traditional sleeping aids, lemborexant has not shown to be significantly associated with driving impairment, rebound insomnia, or dependence/withdrawal symptoms. Also, in clinical trials it only rarely causes the types of adverse events associated with benzodiazepines and other traditional sedatives and is less often associated with discontinuations due to adverse events.
While lemborexant is available on the Canadian market it is unclear how this medication will be tolerated by patients living with an early onset dementia. Understanding the effectiveness and tolerability of lemborexant will be helpful in an N of 1 trial to understand the details of effect and effectiveness in individual patients.
Background & Rationale Insomnia is a highly common, chronic disorder that is distressful for the patient but also for caregivers and can give rise to a heavy burden on the healthcare team. Sleeping aids like benzodiazepines and other sedatives (e.g., zolpidem, zopiclone) have been widely used to help treat insomnia. However, sleeping aids are also known to cause adverse drug reactions such as drowsiness and dizziness, that increases the risk of falls, driving impairment, visual impairment, cognitive impairment, and upon discontinuation may cause paradoxical rebound insomnia, delirium, and nightmares all of which exacerbate the initial insomnia. All of the negative aspects of sleeping aid use are exaggerated for older, frail adults.
Some patients experience an early (young-age) onset dementia with a substantial component of insomnia. Due to the many risks associated with traditional sleeping aids they are often inappropriate in adults living with cognitive impairment and/or frailty. Lemborexant comes from a new class of medications for insomnia. Lemborexant is a dual orexin receptor antagonist that blocks the binding of wake-promoting neuropeptides orexin A and orexin B to their receptors orexin 1 receptor (OX1R) and orexin 2 receptor (OX2R), which is thought to suppress wake drive. Unlike other traditional sleeping aids, lemborexant has not shown to be significantly associated with driving impairment, rebound insomnia, or dependence/withdrawal symptoms. Also, in clinical trials it only rarely causes the types of adverse events associated with benzodiazepines and other traditional sedatives and is less often associated with discontinuations due to adverse events.
While lemborexant is available on the Canadian market it is unclear how this medication will be tolerated by patients living with an early onset dementia. Understanding the effectiveness, tolerability, and safety of lemborexant will be helpful in an N of 1 trial to understand the details of effect and effectiveness in individual patients living with dementia and insomnia.
Hypothesis The investigators hypothesize that lemborexant will be effective and safe in the treatment of insomnia in adults living with both early-onset dementia and concomitant sleep difficulty.
Objective The objective of this study is to evaluate lemborexant for efficacy and safety as a sedative medication for insomnia in adults living with both early-onset dementia and insomnia.
Methods This is an investigator led N of 1 trial for adults with early onset dementia and insomnia. While this trial is designed for a particular patient case the investigators anticipate that there may be opportunities in the future for this N of 1 trial to be redeployed additional times to other adults living with early onset dementia.
Study Procedures:
(1) Study medication will be provided for an 8 week period. Medications will be dispensed in an ABiBABAAB sequence where each letter represents 7 days of treatment, A represents placebo, Bi represents lemborexant 5mg and B represents lemborexant 10 mg. This doubly counterbalanced design to defends against both linear secular trends and nonlinear trends. Medication will be provided in 7 day packs (plastic or cardboard dosette) marked to correspond to the assigned treatment week and assigned as follows.
Week 1 = placebo Week 2 = lemborexant 5mg Week 3 = lemborexant 10 mg Week 4 = placebo Week 5 = lemborexant 10 mg Week 6 = placebo Week 7 = placebo Week 8 = lemborexant 10 mg Medications will be placed inside an opaque capsule to minimize the difference in appearance for the active and inactive treatments. Dispensing details of the 3 treatments will be provided with each of the 8 week long medication supplies. Please note that there will be no washout time between treatment periods (For practical purposes, washout periods may not be necessary when treatment effects (e.g., therapeutic half-lives) are short relative to the length of the treatment periods. Since treatment half-lives are often not well characterized and vary among individuals, the safest course may be to choose treatment lengths long enough to accommodate patients with longer than average treatment half-lives and to take frequent (e.g., daily) outcome measurements.
(2) The patient will also be provided with a Study reporting tool (Appendix 1) where they can record details of drug response and any other noticed events/effects.
4. The participant/caregiver will receive weekly follow up phone calls by the researcher to report the efficacy and harms that the participant experienced in the last 7 days for the 8-week duration and ensure that the treatment is being tolerated. These details will be recorded for consideration and assessment when determining patient response.
5. Efficacy outcome that will be measured in the Study Reporting tool will include: i) total sleep time, ii) sleep onset latency (SOL), iii) wake time after sleep onset (WASO), iv) sleep efficiency, v) number of awakenings to be measured nightly based on patient and caregiver estimate, vi) quality of sleep (see Appendix 2), vii) quality of life of both the patient and the caregiver.
Risk outcome that will be measured will include:
i) presence & severity of adverse drug reactions (ADRs) (somnolence, headache, sleep paralysis, etc.), ii) patient's willingness to drop-out due to ADRs. Furthermore, provision of follow-up care will be ensured by the co-investigator.
Statistical Analysis N of 1 trials are completed with a signal analysis which analyzes the differences in effect between the periods of treatment and the periods of comparator. In this study the treatment will be lemborexant and the comparator will be placebo. Investigators will assess each of the efficacy measures and risk outcomes and then compare across periods of active treatment and comparator.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
shanna.trenaman@dal.ca19024310559