Impact of Motivational Feedback on Levels of Physical Activity and Quality of Life by Activity Monitoring Following Knee Arthroplasty Surgery - Randomized Controlled Trial Nested in a Prospective Cohort (KneeActivity)
Impact of Motivational Feedback on Levels of Physical Activity and Quality of Life by Activity Monitoring Following Knee Arthroplasty Surgery - Randomized Controlled Trial Nested in a Prospective Cohort (KneeActivity)
The goal of this randomized controlled trial (RCT) nested in a prospective cohort study is to investigate whether physical activity (PA) following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) or unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) can be optimized by the use of an activity tracking device including motivational feedback in comparison with activity tracking without feedback. Furthermore, the project will investigate the predictive value of PA level prior to TKA/UKA for the length of stay, return to work, and quality of life.
The main hypothese of the study are:
RCT study:
Prospective cohort:
Patients will be randomized to activity tracking and motivational feed-back by gamification for patient self-mobilization (Intervention-group) or 'care-as-usual' including activity tracking without motivational feed-back (Control-group). Patients not eligible and/or willing to participate in the RCT study, will be offered to participate in a prospective non-interventional cohort study.
Background:
Worldwide over a million patients receive a TKA or UKA each year and in Denmark more than 10,000 TKA and UKA's are performed annually, and the lifetime risk of symptomatic osteoarthritis (OA) of the knees are 45%. Despite being considered a successful intervention, 15-25% of patients following TKA are not satisfied with their output, which to some degree may be associated with reduced daily physical activity (PA). Few scientific studies have examined how daily PA is affected by TKA and how it might affect rehabilitation. It is unknown if a focus on increased PA in everyday life after return from hospital might improve rehabilitation and patient satisfaction. The current study addresses this 'gap' in science with high-level clinical evidence, to investigate if a novel technology on motivational feed-back regarding PA can be introduced to assist patients with a better rehabilitation following TKA or UKA.
Aim:
The aim of this randomized controlled trial (RCT) nested in a prospective cohort is to investigate whether PA following TKA or UKA can be optimized by the use of an activity tracking device including motivational feedback in comparison with activity tracking without feedback. Furthermore, a prospective cohort will investigate the predictive value of PA level prior to TKA/UKA for the post-surgical length of stay, return to work, and quality of life.
Trial design overview:
Design:
Randomized, blinded, two-arm, multi center trial. 150 patients scheduled for TKA or UKA will be recruited through Odense University Hospital (Svendborg and Odense) and Vejle Hospital. Patients will be randomized to 12 weeks of activity tracking and motivational feed-back by gamification for patient self-mobilization (Intervention group) or 'care-as-usual' including activity tracking without motivational feed-back (control group).
Patients that are not eligible and/or willing to participate in the RCT study will be offered to participate in a prospective non-interventional cohort study where the main outcome are self-reported disability, generel health, return to work, pain medication, overall experience with TKA or UKA.
SENS Motion:
SENS Motion (SENS Innovation ApS, Copenhagen, Denmark) is a wireless medical accelerometer for collecting objectively PA data. SENS Motion has developed a patient app with gamification/motivational feed-back to enhance PA. SENS Motion is CE marked as a medical device. SENS Motion has no right to unpublished study data and is neither financially nor personally involved in this trial. None in the study group is related to SENS Motion.
Blinding:
The primary investigator will be blinded to allocation and will not participate in randomization of patients. The statistical analysis will be performed on allocation codes only and thus the data analysts will be blinded in relation to intervention allocation. Blinding to intervention of patients, surgeon, and nurses (healthcare providers) will not be possible due to the nature of the intervention.
Randomizing and database:
Randomization is performed internet-based using REDCap Randomize, allocated 1:1. The randomization itself takes place right after the surgery. The randomization is performed as a block randomization in blocks of 2, 4 and 6. No stratifications are applied to the randomization, and the primary investigator is blinded regarding the permuted blocking strategy. A data manager, with no clinical involvement in the trial, prepares the randomization sequence. The allocation is concealed in a password-protected computer file.
Compliance:
Patients in the control group will have the app installed on their smartphones without motivational feedback, solely for transferring data from the activity tracker. To prevent data loss, weekly SMS messages will remind both intervention and control groups to open their SENS app during the week. No standard for adherence in app interventions has been established previously. The implementation aims for a 70% adherence rate, indicating that the intervention group will interact with the app and obtain motivational feedback for 5 out of 7 days weekly.
All patients will receive written information on how to attach the sensor, use the app (without a tablet), and use the tablet with motivational feedback. Moreover, all patients will receive a link to a YouTube video presenting the project and providing instructions on how to use the equipment.
Time points Assessment will be performed at baseline two weeks prior to surgery and randomization, following the intervention (14 weeks post baseline) (the primary endpoint) and a long term follow-up at 12 months post baseline.
Sample size:
Sample size is estimated using total accelerometer counts per day from a previous publication on TKA patients. Between-group difference in change score of 50.500 activity counts per day representing ≈ 1/3 standard deviation and a change of ≈17% is considered clinically relevant. To achieve a statistical power of 80% (β=0.80), using a standard deviation of 101.000 counts per day pre- and post-intervention, and allowing the detection of statistically significant differences at an α level of 0.05 (two-tailed testing), a sample size of n = 62 is estimated for each group. Allowing for dropout a recruitment of 150 patients (in total) is planned.
Main comparative analyses between groups will be performed by using an intention-to-treat analysis. Between-group mean differences and 95% confidence intervals will be estimated with a general linear model in which the patients baseline score is entered as a covariate and adjusted for potential baseline differences (age, sex, BMI). In addition to the intention-to-treat analysis, a per-protocol analysis will be also be conducted.
Ethics:
The study has been submitted to the regional Committee for Medical Research Ethics, which has assessed the project as "not subject to notification", Project-ID: S-20222000 - 171. Finally, The Danish Medicines Agency has declared no need for further permission to carry out the study.
Qualitative study:
A qualitative study using iterations where patients and healthcare professionals through interviews provided input for improvements of the current technology was initiated to tailor the technological maturation of the SENS App for the current patient group. Evaluation and patient involvement will be based on interviews of ten patients. Feed-back from the focus group will be implemented in an updated app-version. The first iteration was in augus t2021, the second was in feburary 2023, the last iteration is planed in september 2023.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: