Motion and Viewing Analysis of Surgeons During Minimally Invasive Gynecological Interventions
Motion and Viewing Analysis of Surgeons During Minimally Invasive Gynecological Interventions
During minimally invasive surgery (MIS), surgeons manipulate sharp and stiff instruments in the vicinity of fragile tissue, blood vessels, and critical nerves, where poor depth perception can have dramatic consequences. Since typically, 2-dimensional visualization is offered, to correctly infer the 3rd dimension, surgeons rely on their anatomical knowledge and experience. During unforeseen events, correct depth information can make the difference between success and failure. This explains the steep and long learning curve for surgeons. The absence of proper depth information slows down execution and leads to an unnecessary large mental load.
A recent document from the European Association of Endoscopic Surgery showed that 3D shortens operative time and learning curves and reduces complications. 'What the best way is to visualize 3D content' remains an open question. Near-to-eye displays provide small screens in front of each eye, while stereoscopic displays use glasses to project the 3D content to the eyes. The Da Vinci surgical system uses two individual optical panels. These systems are bulky, or restrict head movement, thus users have remarks on the ergonomics. The glasses for stereoscopic displays obscure the view, reduce brightness, and alter the color. Correct color is crucial to recognize tissue types and details or parts in shaded areas. Stereoscopic 3D displays lead to headache and eye-fatigue, called visually induced motion sickness in 11-22% of surgeons after several surgeries.
Autostereoscopic Visualization (ASV) is appealing for medical applications. Besides the improvement of depth perception, it allows 'glasses-free' operation. One of the key components of such displays is eye-tracking, that locates the eyes of the user to be able to render the 3D image to that viewpoint. ASV is a single-viewer application, which can be challenging in an operating room, with multiple people present. Therefore, a rigorous investigation is needed to maximize the performance of the algorithm and ensure the quality of service needed for medical use. It is crucial to collect data from real scenarios by recording the operation, the pose, motion of surgeons and the entire staff. These recordings will deliver solid understanding of the circumstances and rate of occurrences where eye-tracking and 3D visualization fails (or could fail). Furthermore, patterns can be recognized that could help to develop a robust eye-tracking algorithm and safety features for ASV.
Aim of the study
The aim of this study is to analyze the movement and direction of vision of the surgeon's eyes during gynecological interventions. The assessment is done by making video recordings of the medical staff during the procedure. The measured data consists of:
Medical condition or intervention under investigation
Gynecological laparoscopic interventions that involve suturing or extensive dissection, including hysterectomy, sacrocolpopexy and niche repair.
Study schedule
Eligible patients and involved staff members (i.e. surgeon, first assistant, nurse handling the instruments) will be informed on the purpose and nature of the trial. When consenting in written, intra-operative recordings will be carried out.
Since no patient data or follow-up on their condition is involved in the trial, the study ends for all involved at the end of the operation.
Equipment used during the trial
Within the trial, video recording will be carried out by 4 depth cameras mounted in the operating room. The depth cameras will be mounted on top of the displays used by the operating staff. Each camera will be powered by a Raspberry Pi single board computer. The members of the operating staff will be labeled with a visual marker on the head cap to be able to track their movement. Markers will also be installed on the wall or equipment within the field of view of the cameras, where they will be visible throughout the operation. To be able to assess the change in visual circumstances during operation, a LUX meter will be used. The videos will be streamed to a laptop where they will be stored. The equipment is connected via a wireless manner, so no cables will be required.
Potential risks
No clinical risks are introduced by the study. The hardware and software are not in contact with the patient or clinical staff, they are at a safe distance from the surgical field, and there is no interference with other hardware used in the operation.
Assessment of pose
Assessment of the pose and movement of the displays and staff members will be continuously registered by the depth camera and visual markers, which will also allow identification of the roles of the personnel involved.
Video recordings
The video recordings will start only after the patient is installed and draped for surgery, hence completely covered. Recordings will stop as soon as the operation is finished, while the patient is still covered. If the surgeon decides that a part of the recording is too sensitive or would violate the rights of any person involved, the recordings will be paused for that period, or even discontinued entirely.
For the operating staff, their faces will be visible on the videos.
Selection of participants
Participants will be recruited at the Gynecology Department of the University Hospital Leuven. All visiting women undergoing one of the selected surgeries and fulfilling the inclusion criteria will be invited to participate unless the supervising clinician does not think it is appropriate. Eligibility check of the patient can be as early as when planning of the patient's surgery, or at the latest at hospital admission. She will be informed about the study and may sign the informed consent when she opts into the study.
The operating staff at the Gynecological Department will be invited to participate. The operating staff is informed about the study and may sign the informed consent or decide not to take part in the study. For each operation to be eligible for the study, voluntary informed consent is required from all staff members involved.
Sample size statistics
The study uses an adaptive sample size. First, an estimation of the order of magnitude of the sample size was made based on literature, where videography was used to assess staff behavior and motion analysis of surgeons with statistically significant results. Then, a method for adjusting the sample size based on accumulating data will be used.
Anticipation of sample size based on literature review
Azevedo-Coste et al. made an assessment of the movements of clinical staff using an optical motion tracking system, while the movement of the doors was monitored with a wireless network of inertial sensors. Markers were placed on the staff members' surgical cap based on their roles. The authors determined 30 recordings of orthopedic and cardiac surgeries to obtain statistically significant results. Zheng et al. conducted video recordings of laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication to examine team cooperation among surgeons. Overall, 28 operations were required.
In conclusion, we anticipate that around 20-30 recordings may be needed, i.e. 60 to 90 recordings for the three operation types.
Adjustment of sample size based on accumulating data
In order to enable early stopping, we propose to perform interim analysis and perform, based on accumulating data, the measurement of saturation based on the method described by Guest et al. For each type of intervention, the recorded data will be first evaluated after 5 recordings, which will be considered as a base of collected information. Then, the dataset will be reevaluated after each new recording. If the new information from all recorded metrics falls below a ≤5% threshold, the new dataset will be considered to be similar, thus providing no new information. The recorded dataset will be processed to extract the following metrics from the data:
If 5 consecutive recordings of the investigated intervention show similarity, then saturation is reached for that intervention, and the recordings will come to an endpoint.
We also will stop further inclusion and recordings when 50 surgeries of each type are studied.
Summary of sample size
An adaptive sample size will be used. Following 5 recordings of each type of operation, the first calculation is made, and a first interim analysis is done after one additional patient (minimum number: 3*6 = 18). The maximum is 3*50 = 150 recordings.
Statistical analysis
When saturation is reached, each type of operation will be analyzed statistically for the metrics described above. More precisely, for each type of operation the mean and standard deviation will be calculated for (if applicable, units are given between brackets):
Collected data
All recorded data are labeled with a study number; one study includes all recordings from all the cameras, hence includes visual information on patient and staff. The recorded data contains color and depth video files. The coding of the recorded data is different for staff members and patients.
Though data on each operation could be processed anonymously, we assume that the data of participants are de facto pseudonymized: the data are "time- and date-stamped", so identification of the patient or participating staff is theoretically possible via that identifier. Moreover, on the recordings the faces of the staff are visible.
The principal investigator however will not keep a list of study numbers and corresponding patient medical record numbers.
Recognition of patients As to visual recognition of the patient on the video-material, recording is only made while the patient is draped, thus patients will not be recognizable on the footages. The research team is obliged to protect the data from disclosure outside the research according to the terms of the research protocol and the informed consent document. No patient records will be stored for this study.
Recognition of staff members The data of participating staff members cannot be anonymized. The faces of the personnel will be visible, thus individuals will be recognizable on the footages. Furthermore, the visual markers will carry information on their roles. The research team is obliged to protect the data from disclosure outside the research according to the terms of the research protocol and the informed consent document.
Data management and handling
Clinical information will not be released without the written permission of the participant, except as necessary for monitoring, auditing, or inspection by the relevant authorities.
The recording system used to collect the data has limited access measures by usernames and passwords. Data will be collected electronically and the saved data will be hosted at UZ Leuven, in the domain allocated to the PI. This is a password-protected domain and access will be only possible to the personnel involved in the study (PI, sub-investigator, administrator). Published results will not contain any personal data that could allow the identification of individual participants.
Ethics and regulatory approvals
The trial will be conducted in compliance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki (2013), the principles of GCP and in accordance with all applicable regulatory requirements. This protocol and related documents will be submitted for review to Ethics Committee of the University Hospital Leuven.
The study is conducted only on the basis of prior informed consent by the subjects to participate in the study. The investigator shall obtain a signed informed consent form (ICF) for all patients prior to their enrolment and participation in the study in compliance with all applicable laws, regulations and the approval of the Ethics Committee. The investigator shall retain such ICFs in accordance with the requirements of all applicable regulatory agencies and laws.
The Investigators shall treat all information and data relating to the study disclosed to them on this study as confidential and shall not disclose such information to any third parties or use such information for any purpose other than the performance of the study. The collection, processing and disclosure of personal data, such as patient health and medical information are subject to compliance with applicable personal data protection and the processing of personal data (The General Data Protection Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR)).
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: