Structured Program of Exercise for Recipients of Kidney Transplantation
Structured Program of Exercise for Recipients of Kidney Transplantation
Older patients with end- stage kidney disease (ESKD) are at very high risk for functional impairment. Kidney transplantation (KT) has the potential to ameliorate the detrimental effects of ESKD on physical activity and functional status. However, KT alone may not meet the full extent of this potential, particularly for older or more impaired adults. In fact, activity declines immediately post-KT and fails to return to expected levels even 5 years post-KT. Older patients waitlisted for KT (most of whom are on dialysis) are therefore reliant on their pre-KT levels of exercise, which are also predictive of post-KT mortality.
"Prehabilitation" has been used in other surgical populations to minimize functional loss, and a structured exercise program may be beneficial in the pre- KT setting. However, few waitlisted patients are able to participate in typical exercise interventions due to barriers such as severe fatigue. Older patients have additional barriers such as further mobility impairment and requiring substantial caregiver support. Therefore for older living donor kidney transplant candidates, it is necessary to address issues such as specifics of coaching, timing, and importantly, incorporate caregiver participation.
The overall objective of this proposal is to adapt a previously developed 8- week, home- based, structured exercise program among older (≥50 years) dialysis patients awaiting living donor KT, with a focus on caregiver involvement. The investigators will trial the exercise program as compared to usual care. The investigators will then pilot the refined intervention in a total of 72 patient-caregiver dyads, 48 of whom will undergo the proposed intervention (24 with caregiver participation, 24 without). The primary outcomes for the pilot will be change in physical performance and activity from baseline to after the intervention, along with measurements of exploratory quality of life outcomes. In addition, the investigators will measure these same outcomes at 3- months post KT to evaluate for a durable effect of the intervention. An additional post-transplantation outcome of interest will be number of days hospitalized within 3 months of transplantation.
The investigators will conduct a randomized clinical trial of 72 eligible participants to test SPaRKT versus usual care. The primary outcome will be ascertained at completion of the 8-week program and at 3 months post-KT. This study will provide the successful completion rate of weekly coaching as well as estimates of the impact of SPaRKT as compared to usual care. This proposal is powered primarily for change in physical function and change in walking as determined by accelerometers.
Prior to the trial, the investigators will first conduct an "adaptation" phase where study personnel recruit 10-15 paired patient-caregiver dyads to work out any logistical issues with the intervention and work on incorporating caregiver participation. This initial adaptation phase will involve focus groups of each individual wave. In addition, participants and caregivers in the adaptation portion of the study will be asked to give weekly feedback on the intervention, delivered through semi-scripted qualitative interviews of participants and caregivers. Among the items the investigators will attempt to ascertain will be: appropriate length of discussion, preferred method (phone vs video), and preferred feedback during health coaching. The investigators will conduct a final focus group interview of all participants in the adaptation phase to provide consensus on SPaRKT prior to the randomized controlled trial.
Pre-intervention: At time of enrollment, study personnel will provide information to all patients and caregivers on: 1) potential benefits of exercise and increasing activity, 2) the association between poor physical function and adverse outcomes in ESKD and specifically in KT, 3) the typical course of changes in physical function and activity post-KT, 4) general recommendations for activity. The investigators will review patient records for dialysis prescription, laboratory results, comorbid conditions, and medications. All participants will be given a Fitbit Inspire 2 (Fitbit, Inc.) accelerometer and instructed in calibration and use. The Fitbit Inspire 2 is similar to the older model (now discontinued) Fitbit Zip, in that it can be placed on a lower extremity. The Fitbit Zip has been validated in older, community-dwelling adults, and is accurate in individuals with slower walking. Participants will be asked to record activity for a one week lead-in period immediately prior to baseline assessment.
SPaRKT (intervention): Participants and caregivers will be guided through video exercises adapted for hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis patients from the Strong for Life™ series of exercise videos to determine starting resistance band level, demonstrate proper positioning, and provide instruction on adjusting resistance. Each participant will engage in the videos a second time to enforce proper positioning. The Strong for Life™ videos were developed for sedentary older adults with physical disability. The adapted video series will consist of 11 exercises incorporating movement patterns used in daily activities. Some of these exercises use resistance bands. Study personnel will provide Thera-bands™ in 3 levels of resistance to each participant. Starting resistance and subsequent progression will be adapted from the Strong for Life™ protocol; a health coach will ask participants to increase the level of resistance when they are able to perform 12-15 repetitions of an exercise without loss of proper execution. Participants will be instructed to exercise using the these exercise videos 3 times per week for the 8-week intervention period, a dose found to be safe and effective in improving functional status among older adults post-hip fracture.
A health coach will be assigned to each participant in SPaRKT as the primary contact for counseling, feedback, and assistance. The health coach will call the participant once per week using a semi-structured script which will be refined during the adaptation phase. For Aim 1 and for the WC+CG group in Aims 2 and 3, caregivers will be included on calls. Participants will be counseled to increase their average daily steps by 10% for the next week's goal, starting from their baseline activity during the lead-in period. Participants will be instructed to adhere to participation in the exercise program, including with the Strong for Life™ video. Participants in SPaRKT will have recommendations for gradual increases of exercise per their individual health coach as guided by the protocol for 8 weeks. Afterwards, they will be asked to maintain exercise until KT.
Caregiver participation: For the Weekly Coaching + Caregiver Participation (WC+CG) arm in the intervention, caregivers will be asked to participate along with the older adult they are paired with. For the first week, personnel will request that caregivers keep track of patient activity logs and participate in weekly coaching sessions. During these sessions, a health coach will ask caregivers to plan how their patient can reach next week's activity and exercise goals. For later weeks, a health coach will encourage caregivers to 1) perform mid-week checks to ensure that patients will meet their targets, 2) take and increase number of walks with the patient in a stepwise fashion and 3) accompany the patient for exercise sessions.
Participant randomization. For the trial, participants will be randomized to SPaRKT (weekly coaching, WC: N=24, weekly coaching + caregivers, WC+CG: N=24) or usual care (N=24) with more patients in SPaRKT in order to have more experience working through the logistics of the intervention. Random assignments will be generated prior to the study using a computerized randomization scheme with assignments placed into sequentially numbered sealed envelopes. Assignment will be performed after living donor KT is scheduled and baseline assessment of outcomes has been performed.
For the WC+CG group, caregivers in the WC+CG group will be given guidelines based on feedback from the adaptation phase.
Usual Care: Patients randomized to usual care will receive recommendations for exercise based on the Surgeon General's recommendations for physical activity among adults5 as well as the American Heart Association and American College of Sports Medicine recommendations for older individuals or individuals with chronic conditions. These guidelines are applicable to this patient population. Patients will not receive coaching but will receive accelerometers to obtain data for comparison to the intervention groups at each time point (baseline, 8 weeks, and 3 months post-KT).
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
anoop.sheshadri@ucsf.edu415-221-4810 ext. 22576
gabriel.garcia@ucsf.edu
San Francisco, California 94143, United States
anoop.sheshadri@ucsf.edu415-221-4810 ext. 22576
Gabrial.Garcia@Ucsf.edu