The Effectiveness and Underlying Mechanisms of Parent Management Training and Mindful Parenting Program
The Effectiveness and Underlying Mechanisms of Parent Management Training and Mindful Parenting Program
Project Objective:
Parent management training (PMT), which focuses on teaching parents about effective discipline technique using a behavioral approach, has strong evidence base for promoting parent-child relationship, and reducing parental stress and children behavioural problem. Many PMTs, such as the Incredible Years and Triple P program, have been rated as well-established interventions for behavior problems in children.
In recent years, the application of mindfulness in the parenting context is emerging. Parental mindfulness was found to have positive effects on parent-child relationship quality and parenting stress. In particular, preliminary evidence of the eight-week mindfulness based intervention for parents, the Mindful Parenting (MP) program was found to reduce parental stress, and to decrease externalizing and internalizing problems in children.
The two lines of parenting intervention have different theoretical background but they yield similar positive effect in parents and children. The current study has the following objectives:
Hypotheses
In terms of treatment outcome, it is hypothesized that:
H1a) When compared to the waitlist control group, both PMT and MP programmes are similarly effective in reducing negative parenting behaviours and behavioural problems in children, promoting positive parenting behaviours, and enhancing parent-child relationship and parents' mental health.
H1b) Looking into the different aspects of parenting behaviours, however, PMT has stronger effects than the MP programme on increasing proactive parenting and the use of positive reinforcement, and reducing lax control. By contrast, the MP programme has stronger effects than the PMT on enhancing warmth and supportiveness and reducing parental hostility.
In terms of mechanisms of change, it is hypothesized that:
H2a) The PMT and MP programmes both have positive effects on parents' mental health by way of improved parenting practices, and such effect is mediated by the reduction in child behavioural problems and improvement in parent-child relationship.
H2b) The PMT and MP programmes are different in how they bring about improved parenting practices. Parenting knowledge is the mediator between the PMT programme and improved parenting practices, whereas parent's emotional competence is the mediator between MP programme and improved parenting practices.
Lastly, in terms of the effectiveness for particular target participants, it is hypothesized that:
H3) PMT is less effective for parents with low emotional competence whereas the MP programme is more effective for parents with low emotional competence.
Parental Influence on Child Development
It is not surprising that parents, who set the climate in the home environment, have large impact on the behavioural and emotional development in children. Numerous studies have shown that children of parents who are warm and responsive are more likely to experience optimal child development outcomes. On the contrary, timid, permissive and reactive parenting is found to be associated with emotional and behavioural difficulties in children.
Parent Management Training
Given the significant role that parents play, how to support parents become a matter of concern. Parent Management Trainings (PMT) have been demonstrated to be an effective form of parental support. Traditional PMTs are generally based on a behavioural approach, with a primary focus on educating parents on effective behavioural management strategies so as to induce changes in child behaviour.
Past research has proven that PMT is particularly effective for addressing emotional and behavioural difficulties in children. In a review of evidence-based treatment, PMT was found to gain the strongest empirical support and yield the largest effect size among all other treatment approaches for disruptive behaviours in children and adolescents. Programmes of this type include the Incredible Years (IY) Parent Programme, and Positive Parenting Programme (Triple P), which are both classified as 'Well-supported' programme in California Evidence-based Clearinghouse (https://www.cebc4cw.org/) and proven to be clinically effective and cost effective for training parents of children with significant behavioural problems. Outcome evaluation of PMT suggests that PMT yields the following positive results:
Mechanism of Parent Management Training
Although the effectiveness of PMT is well documented, the underlying mechanism of change for PMT is somewhat unclear. The effectiveness of PMT is likely accounted for by changes in parenting skills and behaviours, and associated with changes in parental self-efficacy, confidence, and attributions. Theoretically, it is assumed that parental behavioural change is itself a product of the knowledge of effective parenting practices acquired during PMT. For instance, knowledge of effective parenting strategies has been shown to be predictive of parenting competence, parent psychopathology, and child behavioural problems in a non-clinical sample. However, it could also be argued that while parents may understand what they "should" and what they "could" do, this knowledge may not necessarily translate into behaviour because of other factors, such as parental stress and parent's sense of competence. Overall, there is relatively little research examining the mechanism underlying the effectiveness of PMT and the role of parenting knowledge in these interventions. Further research is needed to examine the limitations and processes through which parenting knowledge may lead to the positive outcomes yielded by PMT.
Limitations of Parent Management Training
Despite the well-documented benefits of PMT programme, it was found that parents' capacity to regulate their own emotional arousal may influence the efficacy of the training. Others also argued that parents' ability in managing negative emotions plays a prominent role in parenting, but this is often not directly addressed in parent training programmes. Parent's own emotional competence, which broadly encompasses the ability to become aware of, recognize, accept, interpret, and respond constructively to one's own emotion, is central to the effective use of parenting skills because it affects the parent's capacity to respond to their child's behaviours in containing and sensitive ways, and reduces their hostile and coercive reactions. Parents with poor emotional competence, even after they have been equipped with effective parenting strategies, may have difficulty executing the strategies in the heat of the moment. Some researchers also posited that in times of high affective arousal, parents may have more difficulties in applying the newly acquired skills and therefore return to use the less skillful approach to manage their children. Moreover, anecdotal evidence of the author as a frontline service provider also confirms the above. Participants in PMT groups often reported that they were more confident in being parents upon programme completion because they had acquired effective parenting strategies. Nevertheless, some participants indicated that whether or not they could apply what they have learnt depends heavily on their ability to regulate their emotions. In other words, whether they could stay calm in times of parent-child conflict is a key factor.
Overall, there is a need to address parents' emotional processes in parental intervention and improving parental emotion regulation could be one avenue to help more parents.
Mindfulness and Parenting
Mindfulness is 'the awareness that emerges through paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally to the unfolding of experience moment by moment'. It can improve one's attention, promote tolerance to unpleasant sensations, feelings and thoughts; and can facilitate cognitive changes. It can also enhance the ability to cope with life challenges, through relaxation and facing difficulties with openness, and better management of caregiving duties. In the parenting context, high level of parental mindfulness is found to be associated with lower levels of parental stress and negative parenting behaviours (i.e. laxness, overreactivity, and verbosity) and increased adaptive parenting.
Given the numerous research which indicated that the practice of mindfulness could enhance resilience to emotional disturbances, and reduce emotional reactivity, mindfulness offers a promising direction for improving parental emotional competence.
Various researchers have proposed how mindfulness could be incorporated into the parenting context. For instance, it was suggested that parents can use mindfulness techniques to listen more openly to their children, develop emotional awareness, and better regulate their own emotions before reacting. Others also stated that in times of intense conflict, the practice of mindfulness could increase parents' parasympathetic tone so that they could be more focused and remain calm. The calmer and more mindful state of the parents could then facilitate parents to make wise choice in managing their children. Simply put, the practice of mindfulness may help transform reactive parenting to responsive parenting.
Recent research that investigates the effectiveness of mindfulnesss-based parenting programme yields positive results in general, supporting the utility of mindfulness in parenting. To date, mindfulness-based parenting programmes are reported to be effective in various populations, from parents of children with developmental delays, parents of children with special needs, to parents of early adolescents. Treatment effects include reducing negative mother-child interactions, decreasing mothers' emotional reactivity, and increasing parents' awareness of own emotions. In a local study, parents reported reduction in parental stress and depression, and improvement in emotion management after completion of a mindful parenting prorgamme. In general, teaching mindfulness practices to parents was effective in reducing child behavioural problems, enhancing parent-child relationship and enhances parents' well-being.
The Mindful Parenting (MP) Program
Literature reveals that the 'Mindful Parenting' (MP) programme, developed by Prof Susan Bögels in the Netherland, is one of the most extensively researched mindful parenting training to date. It is a new application of mindfulness which aims to improve parenting by improving the quality of parental attention, increasing awareness of parental stress, reducing parental reactivity, and decreasing the intergenerational transmission of dysfunctional parenting.
The MP programme is an eight-week mindfulness training for parents. It is an adaptation of the Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) for depression, and the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) programme. The programme retains the basic structure and mindfulness practices of the MBCT and MBSR programs, but with a focus on the parenting context. Components specific to MP programme include automatic pilot parenting, parental self-compassion, and beginners mind parenting. Parents are also invited to apply mindfulness to interactions with their children, other family members, and the everyday tasks associated with parenting.
Research of the MP programme yields encouraging results. Parents who completed the programme reported an increase in mindful parenting, a reduction in negative parenting behaviours (including control, overreactivity, overprotection, and rejection), and an increase in positive parenting behaviours (including autonomy granting behaviour. Benefits to parental psychopathology and well-being include decreased stress and decreased internalizing and externalizing problems. In addition, the programme also brings positive impact to child's psychopathology, including decreased externalizing and internalizing problems.
Mechanism of the Mindful Parenting (MP) Programme
Given the encouraging preliminary evidence of the MP programme, how exactly does Mindful Parenting (MP) training work? What are the possible underlying mechanisms? There are six mechanisms of change through which the MP programme may improve parenting. They include:
Preliminary evidence was found to support that the MP works through 1) reducing parental stress and the assumed effect on parental reactivity and 2) improving marital functioning and co-parenting. In a more recent study, it was found that the programme made improvement in the area of parental stress, parenting, and co-parenting, but not on marital functioning. Putting together the above research results, the first pathway (i.e., reducing parental stress and the reactivity under stress) appeared to be the most strongly supported mechanism of change in the MP programme.
The well documented positive impact of mindfulness-based interventions on emotion regulation also supports this mechanism of change. With lowered emotion reactivity and improved functioning in stressful and emotionally charged situations, parents will have an increased capacity to tackle the parenting difficulties more skilfully, and thus reduce the use of negative parenting practice. Overall, it is probable that MP works through enhancing parental emotional competence, by reducing parent's reactivity and improving their functioning in stressful situations.
The Current Study
As described above, while there has been extensive research on the effectiveness and development of PMT, the MP programme is relatively less explored. The two lines of approaches are entirely different. For instance, while PMT primarily focuses on parent child interaction processes, the MP programme primarily focuses on changing parent's own emotional processes. Nevertheless, research evidence shows that the two lines of intervention yield similar treatment effects. In particular, they are both effective in improving parent's mental health (e.g., parental stress), reducing child behavioural problems, and improving parent-child relationship. Questions arise. How are the two programmes similar and different from each other in terms of treatment effects? What are the similarities and differences in their mechanisms of change? For whom are PMT and the MP programme more effective, or is there a difference?
To date, there are limited studies comparing the PMT and the MP programme. The current study sets out to address the above research gaps. In short, the current study intends to 1) explore the similarities and differences of PMT and the MP programme in terms of treatment outcomes, 2) explore the mechanisms underlying the effectiveness of PMT and the MP programme, and 3) examine for whom PMT and the MP programme are more effective. The hypotheses in the current study are listed below.
In terms of treatment outcome, it is hypothesized that:
H1a. When compared to the waitlist-control group, both PMT and MP programmes are similarly effective in reducing negative parenting behaviours and behavioural problems in children, promoting positive parenting behaviours, and enhancing parent-child relationship and parents' mental health.
H1b. Looking into the different aspects of parenting behaviours, however, PMT has stronger effects than the MP programme on increasing proactive parenting and the use of positive reinforcement, and reducing lax control. By contrast, the MP programme has stronger effects than the PMT on enhancing warmth and supportiveness and reducing parental hostility.
In terms of mechanisms of change, it is hypothesized that:
H2a. The PMT and MP programmes both have positive effects on parents' mental health by way of improved parenting practices, and such effect is mediated by the reduction in child behavioural problems and improvement in parent-child relationship.
H2b. The PMT and MP programmes are different in how they bring about improved parenting practices. Parenting knowledge is the mediator between the PMT programme and improved parenting practices, whereas parent's emotional competence is the mediator between MP programme and improved parenting practices.
Lastly, in terms of the effectiveness for particular target participants, it is hypothesized that:
H3. PMT is less effective for parents with low emotional competence whereas the MP programme is more effective for parents with low emotional competence.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: