Sustained Wellbeing Benefits of Red Meat Consumption in a Modern Flexitarian Diet: A Study Protocol for a 10 Week Randomised Clinical Trial
Sustained Wellbeing Benefits of Red Meat Consumption in a Modern Flexitarian Diet: A Study Protocol for a 10 Week Randomised Clinical Trial
Introduction The trend of flexitarian eating patterns is on the rise, with young adults amongst the biggest adopters claiming health and environmental reasons to reduce red meat intake. Nutrient dense meat and animal products are often the lynchpin of these diets, even when consumed only occasionally and in moderate amounts. Red meat provides forms and concentrations of essential proteins, lipids, and micronutrients that are scarce in exclusively vegetarian regimens. The aim of this investigation is to consider the effects of moderate consumption of lean red meat as part of an otherwise vegetarian balanced diet and its impact on biomarkers of sustained health and wellbeing.
Methods and analyses A cohort of healthy, young (20-34 years) male and female participants will take part in two-arm parallel, randomised-controlled trial for a duration of 12 weeks, with a 3-month post follow-up. The trial will commence with a two-week assessment period followed by allocation to the intervention arms. The intervention will include the consumption of red meat or meat-alternatives three times per week for 10 weeks. Blood samples of the participants will be measured for changes in erythrocyte fatty acid distribution, circulating amino acids, neurotransmitters, markers of mineral status and inflammatory markers. Questionnaires to assess wellbeing and mental health will be undertaken every two weeks. Body composition, physical function test, blood measurements will be assessed at allocation (t0), week five into the intervention (t5) and post intervention (t10).
Discussion To our knowledge this is the first randomised controlled trial (RCT) investigating the overarching health consequences of consuming NZ pasture fed red meat or no meat, as part of a healthy diet.
Ethics and dissemination The trial was approved by the New Zealand Ministry of Health's Health and Disability Ethics Committees (20/STH/157).
Study Design and Setting The study is a parallel RCT comprising a 2-week pre-intervention assessment, a 10-week intervention period and a 22-week post follow up. Participants will all eat a balanced plant-based basal diet and be randomised to also consume either red meat ('Flexitarian' arm) or a meat substitute ('Vegetarian' arm). The meat will be pasture-raised beef and lamb butchered and packaged to our specifications in New Zealand, while the meat substitute will be commercially available plant-based products.
Recognising that there are many interpretations of the terms vegetarian and flexitarian, in this study we define vegetarian as ovo-lacto vegetarian and flexitarian as 'a vegetarian diet with moderate amounts of red meat'. Both arms can consume eggs and dairy products, but no chicken, pork or fish, and no red meat other than that supplied by the researchers.
The study is designed around pairs of young adult consumers who share meals and are therefore likely to engage over the values and challenges of developing a healthy lifestyle. Each couple/household unit (see Recruitment) will receive a weekly delivery of a vegetarian meal kit containing complete ingredients for cooking 3-4 evening meals. Depending on their allocation, the couple will also receive an allotment of frozen red meat or meat-analogue to use for preparing 3 additional evening meals. To facilitate cooking and keep the behaviours of the arms aligned, we will provide recipe cards, shopping guidance and video instructions. All other meals during the week are self-catered and must adhere to study guidelines.
The quantity of meat will be sufficient to provide 350-500 g cooked weight per person per week. This conforms to the latest international recommendations for maximum intake 7 and the reported typical frequencies of red meat consumption. The meat alternative will be similar in quantity, form and function. It is vegetarian-friendly and serves to balance the total protein and fat intake of the arms.
Changes in objective and self-assessed subjective health variables over time and between arms will be investigated. These include physical function, body composition, metabolic health biomarkers and psychological wellbeing.
Inclusion criteria:
Exclusion criteria: