A Feasibility Study of Smartphone-based Brainwave Entrainment (BWE) Technology as a Novel Treatment for Chronic Pain
A Feasibility Study of Smartphone-based Brainwave Entrainment (BWE) Technology as a Novel Treatment for Chronic Pain
Is brainwave entrainment a feasible tool for managing long-term pain in a patient population in the home-setting? Long-term pain affects 4 in 10 people in the UK and can impact on all aspects of life. Many people find that their pain is not well controlled on the treatments that are currently available, or they experience unpleasant side-effects from painkillers. There is therefore an urgent need for new safe and effective treatments for long-term pain.
One new approach to treatment is to target alpha brainwaves - rhythmic brain activity that is known to be associated with reduced pain. Alpha brainwaves can be increased by looking at flashing lights or listening to rhythmic sounds at the same rhythm as the brainwaves. This is known as "brainwave entrainment" (BWE) and can be delivered through a smartphone application.
The aim of this study is to test the suitability, acceptability and benefits of the brainwave entrainment smartphone application for people with long-term pain, and to inform the design of a future larger study.
The investigators aim to recruit 40 participants. Individuals may be eligible if they are over 18 years old and have suffered persistent pain for longer than 3 months. Participants will attend a 3-hour session in the laboratory in either Manchester or Leeds. They will undergo brainwave entrainment for different lengths of time whilst their brain activity and pain levels are recorded to determine the most effective "dose" of entrainment for that individual. They will then use the smartphone application at home 3 times a day for 4 weeks, and will complete pain, sleep, fatigue and quality of life questionnaires. At the end of the study, the investigators will conduct interviews to gain in-depth feedback. The total duration for each participant is around 7 weeks. This study is funded by a Leeds Cares Clinical Research Fellowship.
Primary Question/Objective:
The principal research objectives are two-fold:
Secondary Question/Objective:
STUDY DESIGN
Participants:
A total of 40 participants will be recruited from musculoskeletal, rheumatology and rehabilitation clinics in Leeds Teaching Hospitals National Health Service (NHS) Trust and Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust.
Study Intervention and Procedures:
This is a two-stage feasibility study incorporating electroencephalography (EEG), quantitative outcome measures and qualitative interviews.
Project duration:
Each participant's involvement is estimated to last a minimum of 7 weeks (this may be longer depending on the availability of the participant to attend laboratory sessions).
Number of centres:
This study will be conducted across two sites: University of Manchester and University of Leeds. Two NHS sites will act as Participant Identification Centres (PICs): Leeds Teaching Hospitals Trust and Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust.
Study design and procedures:
The project will be comprised of two studies: 1) a laboratory-based study followed by 2) a home-based study. All participants will be involved in both studies.
Potential participants may be approached and provided with a flyer and Participant Information Leaflet from musculoskeletal, rehabilitation and pain clinics at the two PICs, or may find out about the study from flyers placed in relevant NHS clinics or other relevant settings such as support groups. The participant will then contact the research team by phone or email on the contact details provided to discuss the study further, go through the screening process and arrange a convenient time for them to attend the laboratory if they wish to proceed.
Study 1:
Participants will attend either the University of Manchester laboratory in Salford Royal Hospital, or the University of Leeds laboratory in the School of Biological Sciences, University of Leeds, whichever is more convenient. They will be given opportunity to ask any questions before signing the consent forms. They will complete the following questionnaires:
Participants will then be introduced to the smartphone app, shown how to use it and given the opportunity to practice (30 mins). Participants will be provided with a smartphone with the BWE app pre-downloaded, a Virtual Reality (VR) headset and set of earphones to use for the duration of the study.
The estimated total laboratory time is 3 hours.
Study 2:
Participants will be asked to record NRS 3x a day and Brief Pain Index (BPI) short form (5-10 mins) 1x a day for 1 week at home to get baseline pain levels. After this period, they will be contacted by phone or email by a researcher to remind them to begin using the stimulation. They will then use the stimulation 3x a day for the specific duration that was identified as the optimum for them during the laboratory-based study (i.e. 5, 15 or 30 minutes, based on clinical pain ratings) for 4 weeks. They will record NRS for pain intensity and unpleasantness before and after each stimulation and BPI at the end of each day. This will be followed by a further week of baseline pain ratings with NRS 3x a day and BPI once a day.
Following this, the participant will attend the laboratory at a pre-arranged time to complete the following questionnaires:
They will also participate in a semi-structured interview (<45 minutes) with a researcher. The interview will be based around a topic guide, however the semi-structured approach will allow for trajectories in the conversation according to any significant or relevant topics that may arise. The topic guide will be designed to:
The interview will be audio-recorded and then transcribed verbatim with any identifiable data removed from the transcripts.
Recruitment:
Flyers advertising the study will be placed in relevant rheumatology, musculoskeletal and rehabilitation NHS clinics in Leeds and Manchester and in non-clinical settings (including support groups). Potential participants may be approached by clinicians in NHS clinics in the PICS, or they may contact the study team by telephone or email on the contact information provided on leaflets. Their eligibility for the study will be assessed by telephone. Participants will be provided with a verbal explanation and a Participant Information Leaflet (PIL) explaining the study, either in person or by email/post. They will have a minimum of 24 hours to decide whether to participate, at which point an initial meeting will be scheduled at a convenient date and time for the participant.
Written informed consent will be obtained from participants when they attend the laboratory for the initial meeting. Participants will have the opportunity to ask any further questions prior to consenting. A copy of the signed consent form will be given to the participant for their records and the original copy will be securely filed.
Randomisation:
All participants will receive the same intervention, however for study 1, the order in which the four sessions of stimulation (5, 15, 30 mins of alpha frequency and 10 mins of non-entraining stimulation) are delivered will be randomised using computer generated random numbers. A single research assistant who is not involved in delivery of the intervention will be responsible for the randomisation process. Neither the researcher delivering the intervention nor the participant will know the selected sequence at the start, however, it will not be possible for either the researcher or the participant to be completely blinded, given that the differences in duration of stimulation are likely to be quite apparent.
Statistical Analysis EEG data will be analysed using BrainVision Analyzer 2.0. Source localisation will be estimated using low resolution electromagnetic tomography (LORETA) using LORETA-KEY software. Appropriate statistical analysis will be carried out using SPSS software.
Interview findings will be explored with thematic content analysis using a Template Analysis approach. This involves the definition of a priori themes relevant to the research question. Two researchers will separately review and code an initial five transcripts based on the a priori themes, before coming together to organise the emerging themes into meaningful clusters and create an initial coding template by which to analyse the rest of the transcripts (modifying and revising the template as further themes emerge).
Sample Size:
The investigators aim to recruit a total of 40 participants who will take part in both work package 1 and 2. As a feasibility study, one of the key aims is to gain data on effect size in order to calculate sample size for a future clinical trial. Therefore, the sample size is based on previous studies as well as considering pragmatics such as funding, equipment and time available.
DATA MONITORING AND QUALITY ASSURANCE The study will be subject to the audit and monitoring regime of the Universities of Manchester and Leeds.
SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS AND ADVERSE EVENTS This study uses alpha frequency brainwave entrainment, which has no known significant side effects or risks. Therefore, the anticipated risk to participants is considered to be very low.
There are no anticipated risks to the researchers. There will be two-weekly debriefs with the whole research team to address any potential issues. There will be no lone-working for any team member.
ETHICAL and REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
Approvals:
The study will be conducted in full conformance with all relevant legal requirements and the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki, Good Clinical Practice (GCP) and the UK Policy Framework for Health and Social Care Research 2017. The study will be approved by NHS Research Ethics Committee and Health Research Authority prior to commencement.
Potential risks and burden to participants:
Due to the rhythmic flashing lights of the visual stimulation, individuals with a history of epilepsy or seizures will be excluded from the study, to mitigate the risk of triggering seizures. Those with sensitivity to flashing lights or a history of migraines or recurrent headaches will also be excluded. The brightness of the visual stimulation and the volume of auditory stimulation will be adjustable, to ensure it is comfortable. There are no known side effects from using this technology, however participants will be instructed to stop using it if they were to experience any adverse symptoms and to inform the research team.
Potential burden may arise from the inconvenience of attending the laboratory for face-to-face meetings. These have purposefully been kept to only 2 meetings to reduce this burden as much as possible. Data collection may be considered burdensome. Questionnaires at the beginning and end of the study will be completed with a researcher on hand to provide support. Although the NRS for pain takes seconds to complete, this will require participants to remember to record their pain scores three times a day. Participants will be provided with a clearly laid out booklet to assist them. Part of the feasibility aspect of this study is to assess how easy and acceptable the data collection measures are, so participants' feedback on the level of burden will be ascertained in the final interview and will guide future study design. Participants may perceive some burden from the final interview. It is not anticipated that the content will be upsetting for participants, however it is recognised that potentially sensitive topics may arise, including discussion of chronic pain and other symptoms. Participants will be informed that they do not have to answer any questions that they are uncomfortable with and they may leave the interview at any time without needing to give a reason.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
Helen.locke@manchester.ac.uk01612064266
Manoj.sivan@manchester.ac.uk01612064266
Manoj.sivan@manchester.ac.uk01612064266