Inhaled Methoxyflurane for Pain Management in Nasal Bone Fracture Reduction : A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial
Inhaled Methoxyflurane for Pain Management in Nasal Bone Fracture Reduction : A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial
This is a randomised, double-blind, placebo controlled study to evaluate the efficacy of Methoxyflurane (Penthrox®) for the treatment of acute pain during closed nasal fracture reduction.
The study aims to provide evidence under blinded controlled conditions that Penthrox is safe and effective in patients aged 18 to 65 years during closed nasal fracture reduction.
The main objective of this study is to establish if the addition of Methoxyflurane to local anesthesia has the ability to significantly reduce the pain during closed nasal fracture reduction compared to local anesthesia with placebo.
The secondary outcomes consist of assessing if inclusion of Methoxyflurane will have a positive impact on the time needed to achieve the reduction, the need for backup analgesia, the rate of reduction failure, pain level during infiltration of local anesthesia and the clinician's appreciation of the procedure.
As an hypothesis, the investigators expect that the addition of Methoxyflurane to the standard local anesthesia will significantly reduce the pain compared to local anesthesia with placebo during closed nasal fracture reduction. The investigators also think that Methoxyflurane might reduce the duration of the reduction, limit the need for backup analgesia, reduce the rate of reduction failure, reduce the pain level due to infiltration of local anesthesia and facilitate the procedure for the clinician.
To reach these objectives, the investigators propose a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study on a sample of patients randomized in two different groups:
The placebo in this study is a 0,9% saline solution that will come in an identical Penthrox inhaler. The inhaler will be prepared by a pharmacy technician experienced in double-blind research right before its use. The characteristic smell of the Methoxyflurane solution will be reproduced by pouring a few drops of Methoxyflurane just above the tip of the inhaler. N95 masks will be worn by the clinician and research nurse throughout the procedure to lower the risk of group identification.
PROCEDURE Patient referred to the investigators outpatient clinic for nasal fracture 7 to 10 days from the trauma date will be evaluated by one of the investigator and the need for intervention will be established.
Eligible patients will be randomised in a 1:1 ratio to have 17 patients per treatment arm (an interim analysis will be done after 10 patients per treatment arm). Eligible patients will receive either methoxyflurane or placebo from the PENTHROX® inhaler in a 1:1 ratio.
Before the procedure, the patient will assess his current level of pain on the visual analog scale (baseline pain). The patient will then self-administer 6 to 10 successive inhalations of Penthrox or placebo (assisted by the research nurse). The clinician will then wait 5 minutes before proceeding with local anesthesia as follow :
The patient will use the inhaler one more after local anesthesia and the investigator will wait 5 minutes prior to proceeding with the closed reduction to ensure an adequate efficacy of the topical lidocaine-oxymetazoline anesthesia.
The cotton balls will then be removed and the clinician will proceed with the closed reduction.
The research nurse then documents the time at which the reduction begins. A scalpel handle is placed against the external nose to measure the distance from the medial canthus to the nostril rim. The scalpel handle is inserted between the depressed nasal bone and the the nasal septum, parallel to the nasal dorsum. The depressed bone is pulled laterally and guided into a neutral position with the scalpel handle while direct pressure is applied medially on the contralateral nasal bone (the laterally deviated side) in order to push it back into its neutral position. If needed, centrally depressed fragments require an anterior lifting motion with the elevator. These steps are repeated until the patient and the clinician are satisfied with the aesthetic result or if the patient asks the clinician to stop the procedure. End time of the procedure will also be noted.
The patient can ask for additional Methoxyflurane inhalations at anytime during the procedure. The patient is provided with 3 mL bottle of Methoxyflurane (or placebo) and cannot ask for another one. If during the procedure the patient asks for additional analgesia, his nose will be packed with cotton balls soaked in lidocaine-oxymetazoline for 5 minutes. However, if despite additional analgesia the procedure is interrupted because it is too painful for the patient, it will be considered as a reduction failure due to pain (whether the procedure is carried out under systemic analgesia, sedation or is abandoned). In the event of failure to achieve adequate fracture reduction, sedation and/or general anesthesia will be offered to the patient to complete the reduction.
After the procedure, pain levels (during infiltration of local anesthesia, mean and peak pain during the reduction) will be reported on the visual analog scale.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
Pierre-Hugues.Fortier@USherbrooke.ca8193461110 ext. 24927