Clinical Study of Laser Analgesia in Cavity Preparations
Clinical Study of Laser Analgesia in Cavity Preparations
Not much has been done in research to explain the clinical benefit of laser cavity preparation without the use of injection anesthetic. The Author of this study sought to show the science behind the "no shot, no pain" in restorative dentistry using an Er,Cr:YSGG laser Patients with two similar size lesions of class I or class V cavities selected as subjects. In the same appointment, both cavities are prepared by the Er,Cr:YSGG. One lesion was prepared with one high power laser setting to ablate the enamel, dentin, and caries. The other lesion was prepared with a low power setting to start and is aimed at applying low level laser therapy (LLLT) before using the high power setting to ablate enamel, dentin, and caries. A visual analog scale (VAS) was used for the patient to analyze how comfortable each laser technique was. An Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used.
The principal objective of this study is to prove the phenomenon of laser analgesia. Traditionally before a cavity preparation is performed, the doctor will use local anesthetic (Needle Injection) before using rotary instrument to do a cavity preparation. The study involves using the Er,Cr=YSGG Laser to perform cavity preparation without giving any injection anesthesia. VAS (Visual Analog Scale) will be used to have patients rate the laser cavity preparation procedure to show there is laser analgesia. On each patient subject that has two similar size cavities of the same classification, either Class I or Class V, on similar teeth. Two different laser protocols will be used. One includes Low Level Laser Therapy (LLLT) to condition the pulp producing analgesia before using higher power to perform the cavity prep. The other protocol will skip the LLLT setting and prepare the cavity with the higher power to perform the cavity prep. The design of the study is to find out if there is laser analgesia and if LLLT makes a difference in providing better analgesia. The VAS forms from each procedure will be used to show there is laser analgesia and potentially cavity preparations can be performed by using the laser without the need to give injection anesthesia first. 48 patients will be included in this study.
Treatment. Preconditioning and cavity preparation are done using the Er:Cr:YSGG laser, Waterlase MD (mfg: Biolase Technology Inc, Irvine CA), and the gold hand piece with an MG6 fiber tip, trunk fiber, contra-angle hand piece. Preconditioning. Preconditioning is preformed using laser desensitization. One tooth will be randomly selected, and preconditioning will be performed using LLLT on the tooth with minimal tooth ablation. The LLLT settings that will be used for preconditioning are 0.25 Watts, 50 Hz, 0% water, 0% air, H mode. Following this a fiber-optic tip will be aimed perpendicular to the surface of the cervical portion of the tooth, ensuring that a 2mm distance will be maintained between the end of the fiber optic tip and the surface. The fiber-tip will be used to generate a 2mm line. The cavity on the second tooth will be prepared for without laser preconditioning. Lesion Preparation - small preparations. Small preparations are to be performed as follows. The Waterlase MD is set to 4.5W, 15 Hz, 65% air, and 60% water and the cavity is prepared according to the preferred technique. If patients indicate sensitivity, the procedure will be halted, patients fill out the VAS form and anesthetic will be offered. For patients who refuse anesthetic, the procedure will be continued at the same settings. Lesion Preparation - small to medium preparations. Small to medium preparations will be performed as follows. The Waterlase MD will be set to 2W, 15 Hz, 65% air, and 60% water and the cavity will be prepared according to the preferred technique. If patients indicate sensitivity, the procedure will be halted, patients fill out the VAS form and anesthetic will be offered. For patients who refuse anesthetic, the procedure will be continued at the same settings.
Restoration. Overall VAS Score. Up to 3 intra-operative VAS measurements are recorded. If a patient feels even the slightest amount of pain during the procedure, they will be instructed to raise their hand and the treatment will be paused. The patient is then asked to fill in the VAS form before the procedure will be continued. After conclusion of the cavity preparation, patients will be asked to mark one last VAS rating indicating the overall pain of the procedure. Patients that do not raise their hand throughout the entirety of the procedure will be given an overall VAS rating of zero. Data for each patient will be recorded and analyzed in this way.
The VAS scale will be presented to the patients using a standard explanation (zero, indicating no pain at all, to 100, representing the 'worst pain patient had ever felt'). Patients will be asked to place a vertical line on the VAS scale to indicate his/her discomfort status. They are encouraged to stop the treatment if they encounter any pain. The number of hand raises, as defined by the protocol, will be recorded and analyzed (small and medium/large preparations are analyzed separately), represent the number of times during the procedure the patient felt sufficient discomfort to stop the procedure. VAS data will be assessed by the following assumptions: The 'lower' the average score, the 'better' the mode of treatment. Once the patient marks their vertical line on the scale, a precise measurement, in millimeters, was taken from the "zero" line of the VAS scale to where the patient marked their line.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: