ElectroMagnetic-guided Interstitial Catheter Navigation for Gynecological brachyTherapy: A Phase I Trial
ElectroMagnetic-guided Interstitial Catheter Navigation for Gynecological brachyTherapy: A Phase I Trial
Phase I study evaluating the feasibility of using electromagnetic navigation (EMN) for the catheter implantation procedure required of cervical brachytherapy. The addition of EMN to the current HDR brachytherapy workflow has the potential to dramatically improve implant quality and efficiency for the gynecological interstitial brachytherapy program. Implant quality has been reported to be an important predictive factor for local control and late toxicity.
Cervical cancer poses a significant local and global health problem. In 2017 over 1,500 Canadian women were predicted to develop cervical cancer, and another 400 were approximated to die from the disease. Cervical cancer rates have steadily decreased in developed nations largely due to regular gynaecological screening and public human papillomavirus vaccination programs; however, the disease accounts for up to 12% of all female cancer diagnoses in developing nations, and poses a disproportionate burden on aboriginal women across Canada. Much work needs to be done to address disparities in care and treatment for cervical cancer, both in Canada and worldwide.
FIGO stage IA - IB1 is considered localized disease and treated primarily with surgery. In contrast to early stage disease, tumours that extend greater than 4 cm and beyond the cervix are considered locally advanced. The standard of care for locally advanced cervical cancer defined as FIGO stages IB2 - IVA is external beam radiation therapy with concurrent chemotherapy followed by brachytherapy.
Brachytherapy is a crucial component of therapeutic management that has been shown to be associated with improved local control. High dose rate brachytherapy involves the treatment of local bulky disease using a remotely loaded Iridium-192 source. Brachytherapy delivery exploits rapid dose fall off, allowing for the central pelvis to receive a very high dose while sparing the bladder, rectum, sigmoid and small bowel. This dose escalation is beyond what is conventionally achievable using external radiation therapy methods. More specifically, image guided adaptive brachytherapy employing intracavitary applicators allows for dose optimization and improves target dose coverage for limited size tumours.
Intracavitary applicators have been shown to be adequate from covering symmetric small tumours less than 30 cc. However, for large or complex asymmetric tumours with/without vaginal involvement they are not sufficient to cover the target while respecting normal tissue tolerances. To compensate for these limitations, improvements in local control have been achieved using a combined interstitial and intracavitary technique for larger tumours. Combined intracavitary - interstitial applicators have been designed to target tumours that are not adequately covered by intracavitary applicators alone. The addition of the interstitial technique involves the insertion of catheters into the tumour enabling higher dose conformity and normal tissue sparing. This combined technique has been shown in large tumours with extensive parametrial involvement as well as in cases with unfavourable topography to be effective. Employing this combined technique, perineal-based interstitial image guided adaptive brachytherapy makes it possible to deliver higher doses to the high risk clinical target volume without increasing dose to the bladder, rectum or sigmoid.
The combined interstitial and intracavitary brachytherapy workflow for locally advanced cervical cancer at the Odette Cancer Centre typically consists of four treatment fractions. The workflow begins with a pre-brachytherapy assessment MRI that is taken before brachytherapy treatment to assist in preplanning of catheter depth and location. At the time of this MRI the patient will have a vaginal cylinder in place. 1-2 weeks after the MRI, the implant and treatment is performed. Prior to the implantation procedure, the patient is given light sedation and a spinal anesthetic, subsequently a vaginal cylinder (Best Medical Systems, Inc, Springfield VA) is inserted into the patient. A perineal template that contains a central opening is fit on the vaginal cylinder. The template is then advanced until it is appositional on the perineum of the patient. Plastic catheters (6F 24 cm) containing metal stylets are inserted through the template and along the grooves of the vaginal cylinder thereby penetrating the perineum and the vagina, respectively. The number, position and depth of the catheters that are used are based on the pre-brachytherapy assessment MRI. After the implantation procedure the template is sutured to the patient and the patient is transferred to an MRI suite where an image of her anatomy is acquired with the catheters and applicators in place. The patient is then sent for a CT scan that is to be used for treatment planning.
Treatment planning involves the registration of the CT and MR datasets. The MR images are used to identify the soft tissue organs at risk and the targets. The CT is used to identify the catheters implanted in the patient. Using the knowledge of where the applicator/catheters are with respect to the targets and organs at risk, a dose distribution is designed to target the cancer while sparing normal tissue. On the same day as the implantation, one treatment fraction is delivered and the patient is admitted overnight. The next day the patient may as a standard of care, depending on the clinical indication undergo one or two additional fractions, separated by at least 6 hours. A week later the same process for the first two fractions will be repeated for the remaining two fractions.
During the insertion of catheters, it has been recognized that they can converge or diverge as they pierce stiff tissues along the implantation path. Without proper image guidance, a template guided interstitial implant could result in an increase in risk of normal tissue complications. Real-time image guidance for catheter insertion is institution dependent, at the Odette Cancer Centre trans-abdominal ultrasound is used for placement of the tandem and more recently the trans-rectal ultrasound has been investigated for catheter placement. Other forms of real-time catheter guidance used at different centres include fluoroscopy, computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
The quality of interstitial brachytherapy implants has been reported to be an important predictive factor for local control and late toxicity. The quality of the implant is dependent on the geometry of the catheters, and real time image guidance for interstitial cervical brachytherapy is markedly lacking.
At the Odette Cancer Centre, a four-patient study was conducted to characterize the amount of catheter deflection and angulation during gynaecological high-dose-rate interstitial brachytherapy. Results from this study demonstrated that the mean value of the maximum catheter deflection at the level of the GTV was 9.1 mm +/- 3.2 mm (range 3.0 - 18.4 mm) and can approach as much as 2 cm at the level of the GTV. Although the catheter deflection observed in this study did not result in any significant dosimetric impact the sample size was small and the authors of the study suggested that further investigation into real-time catheter guidance may be necessary into alleviating this deviation to prevent suboptimal plan quality.
Electromagnetic tracking can minimize the uncertainties related to implant quality. The operation of an electromagnetic tracking device depends on a field generator producing a magnetic field that extends across the anatomy of interest. The tracked sensor in this system induces a distance-dependent voltage that is used to determine the spatial position of the sensor within the volume of interest. This technology is extensively used in clinical practice, examples include, surgical interventions, guidance of biopsies, and motion monitoring.
Electromagnetic navigation can be incorporated into the cervical interstitial brachytherapy workflow as a form of real-time catheter guidance. By incorporating this guidance into the current workflow it is possible that a higher degree of accuracy in catheter placement will be achieved when used in conjunction with image-guided brachytherapy. This study seeks to evaluate the efficacy of electromagnetic navigation on the perineal-based interstitial cervix image-guided brachytherapy workflow as part of a phase I clinical trial.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
ananth.ravi@sunnybrook.ca416 480 6100 ext. 1092