Changes in Adaptive Immune Responses and Effector Cell Responses Upon Nasal Allergen Exposure - a Pilot Study
Changes in Adaptive Immune Responses and Effector Cell Responses Upon Nasal Allergen Exposure - a Pilot Study
IgE-associated allergy is a hypersensitivity disease affecting more than 25% of the population in industrialised countries. The recognition of allergen by immunoglobulin E (IgE) plays a central role in the cause of allergic diseases. Both seasonal and nasal provocation studies have demonstrated the rise in specific IgE after allergen exposure. Additionally changes in other clinical and immunological parameters (e.g. nasal blockage, mast cell and basophil sensitivity, various cytokines or T cell profiles) in response to allergen exposure have been described. However the time sensitive interplay of these various factors such as the relationship between rise in IgE levels and change in basophils sensitivity or cytokine profiles is not yet fully understood. Clarifying how these various factors interact and contribute to immunological responses to allergen, is crucial for the development of new therapeutic approaches.
The investigators aim to address these questions through a study following 36 Birch allergic patients after provocation with allergen or placebo over a peroid of 6 weeks to 1 year.
Rational of the Study
Previous studies on the dynamics of the in vivo clinical and immunological responses to nasal allergen have focused on particular parameters but have not addressed the kinetics of the interplay between the different factors (i.e. allergen-specific IgE levels, local IgE and mediator production, basophil sensitivity, cutaneous sensitivity). The investigators therefore propose a randomized double-blind placebo controlled study where The investigators challenge patients intranasally with allergen extract and then closely monitor both clinical and immunological immune responses over a period of 4 months. After this a further 4 visits will take place before and after the birch season.
The investigators will look at immediate and late phase immune responses to birch pollen extract nasal challenge outside the pollen season. Study participants will initially undergo 3 consecutive days of nasal allergen challenge and then be closely followed up for a period of 1 year. To assess clinical response to allergen exposure, The investigators will make use of the skin prick test (SPT), total nasal symptom score (TNSS), nasal endoscopy and Peak Inspiratory Nasal Flow Meter (PNIF). To assess immunological responses samples including blood, nasal mucosal sampling and nasal secretions will be taken.
Study Design
In this single-center, randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind study a total of 36 (6 for a pre study) patients will be recruited into this study on a voluntary basis and will be randomised to receive a nasal challenge with either birch pollen extract or placebo. Randomisation will be stratified according to Bet v 1 specific IgE levels to allow for equal distribution in both groups. 30 Study participants will receive nasal provocation outside of the birch pollen season with either birch pollen extract or placebo on three consecutive days and will thereafter be followed up at a regular basis for up to four months.
Initially, prior to the study in 30 patients, 6 birch pollen allergic subjects will undergo a short protocol in order to ensure that
The allergen concentration used for nasal provocation is sufficient to elicit a rise of IgE antibodies
That the titrations of the skin prick test is adequate
That the timing of taking nasal secretions for determination of mediators is adequate.
Should the results from these 6 patients reveal that either nasal allergen concentration, skin test titrations or timing of nasal secretions is not adequate, an amendment will be submitted to the ethical committee.
The shortened protocol will include 5 visits:
Screening Visit
Procedure
Visit N0
Requirements regarding timing: Visit N0 is scheduled between 2 weeks and 4 days before visit N1. This is only for patients that were screened more than 3 weeks before visit N1
Procedure:
Visit N1
Procedure:
Visit N2
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N2 is scheduled the day after visit N1
Procedure:
Visit N3
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N3 is scheduled the day after visit N2
Procedure:
Visit N4
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N4 is scheduled the day after visit N3
Procedure:
• Blood, PNIF, nasal sampling (lavage, mucosal curette sampling and nasal secretion sampling) and TNSS score at 20-24hrs after administration of birch pollen extract.
Visit N5
Visit N5 is scheduled 14 ±4 days after visit N4:
Procedure:
Visit N6
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N6 is scheduled 14 ±4 days after visit N5
Procedure:
Visit N7
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N7 is scheduled 14 ±4 days after visit N6
Procedure:
Visit N8
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N8 is scheduled 14 ±4 days after visit N7
Procedure:
Visit N9
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N9 is scheduled 14 ±4 days after visit N8
Procedure:
Visit N10
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N9 is scheduled 14 ±4 days after visit N9
Procedure:
Visit N11 - Final Visit of Nasal Provocation Component
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit N11 is scheduled 28 ±4 days after visit N10
Procedure:
Visit S1 (Extension - Approved by MUW Ethics Committee on the 11th of Febuary 2019)
Requirements regarding timing: Visit S1 is scheduled 4 weeks before the predicted start of the birch season (+/- 7 days)
Procedure:
Visit S2
Requirements regarding timing: Visit S2 is scheduled 4 weeks after the end of the birch season (+/- 7 days)
Procedure:
Visit S3
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit S3 is scheduled 4 weeks after visit S2 - (+/- 7 days)
Procedure:
Visit S4 and End of Study
Requirements regarding timing:
Visit S4 is scheduled 1 year after the start of the whole study (1 year after visit N0) +/- 7 days
Procedure:
Descriptions of Study procedures
Medical history of patients, demographic data, concomitant medication Patients will be asked for their medical history including demographic data and concomitant medication, their allergic symptoms including intensity and duration and their allergic medication history.
History of allergy and TNSS score
Patients will be asked for occurrence of sneezing, rhinorrhoea, nasal pruritus, nasal congestion and sleep quality and to grade each symptom at each visit and keep a record at home. They will use the following symptom score method: 0 = absent; 1 = mild - present but easily tolerated; 2 = moderate - present, symptom is bothersome but not interfering with daily life activities; 3 = severe - symptom is difficult to tolerate and is interfering with daily life activities (24). In addition to this there will be a visual analogue scale of total disease burden on the form.
Anterior rhinoscopy
Anterior rhinoscopy will be performed once during the screening visit to exclude anatomical variances (e.g. septal deviation) or pathological changes (e.g. nasal polyps). It will be performed by using a speculum with the patient seated with the head slightly back.
Peak Inspiratory Nasal Flow Meter (PNIF)
The portability and ease of the PNIF provides a unique opportunity to obtain objective measurements while the patients are at home. It has also recently been validated as a study tool during nasal allergen challenge.
Procedure:
At visit 1 patients will be trained how to use the PNIF device (In-check, Inspiratory flow meter) and will receive one to take home with them until N5. The PNIF uses a variable diameter tube calibrated directly in litres per minute along with a low inertia indicator ring. The position of the ring after an inspiratory manoeuvre indicates the maximum flow achieved. The device works when a patient inhales through the mouth or nose, this causes air to be drawn through the meter and a cursor moves along the scale to indicate the speed of inhalation. The flow rate achieved can be noted by checking the position of the cursor against the calibrated scale.
PNIF in study conduct:
The PNIF will be given to study participants to take home so they can keep a daily or weekly dairy (depending on the phase of the study) of their nasal airflow. They will also be asked to bring them to all study visits so observed PNIF measurements can be taken.
Skin prick test
4.5.1 Procedure: Allergens are inserted into the dermis of the forearm by gently pricking the skin through a drop (20ul) of an allergen-containing solution with a sterile lancet with at least 2 cm between each individual application point. 0.9% sodium chloride solution will be used as negative and histamine as positive control. In previously sensitized individuals, itchy swelling and a reddening of the skin (wheal and flare reaction) will occur within 15 minutes upon challenge with the respective allergen. After 20 minutes, allergen solutions will be wiped off and margins of the wheals will be traced with a ball point pen. Transparent tape will be bonded on the skin in order to transfer the outline of the wheal to the tape for the records. The surface of the wheals will be calculated by digital planimetry. For inclusion, wheals of at least 3 mm in diameter will be regarded as positive reactions.
Test solutions:
Commercially available birch pollen extract and a panel of tree and grass pollen, weed and perennial allergens (Allergopharma, Vienna, Austria) will be used at the screening visit and will be stored according to the manufacturer's instructions. As controls, sterile 0.9% NaCl solution (negative control) and histamine (positive control, Allergopharma, Vienna, Austria) will be used. They will be stored according to the manufacturer's instructions.
SPT in study conduct:
Screening Visit:
A standard skin prick test with commercial birch pollen extract and a panel of tree and grass pollen, weed and perennial allergens (all Allergopharma, Vienna, Austria) as used in routine diagnostic in the allergy clinic of the ENT department will be performed to assess the patient's sensitization profile at the screening visit.
Screening and Visits N0, N5 - N11, S1-S4 A titrated skin prick test to birch extract will be performed with increasing dilutions (dilutions will be increased by a factor of 3 up to 1:60 000 (=11 dilution steps) to determine the lowest concentration that elicits a skin response. Skin tests to all dilutions will be done in quadruplicates. Commercial positive control solution (histamine) and negative control will be done in duplicates.
Safety precautions As a safety precaution, patients will be monitored for 30 minutes after testing. All investigations will be done in the Outpatient Clinic of the ENT-Department, where full emergency equipment is available.
Blood sampling and measuring of immunological parameters
Blood samples will be taken at the screening visit and at all study visits by puncture of the antecubital vein before skin testing. A maximum of 60ml per visit will be taken either heparinized (e.g. for basophil sensitivity assays) or for the preparation of serum (e.g. for assessment of total and allergen specific immunoglobulin levels or RBL assay). Serum vials will be processed and serum will be stored at -20°C. Allergen-specific IgE of blood samples of the screening visit will be measured by CAP-FEIA to assess the allergen-specific RAST-class of the patients. Measurement of total, free, and allergen-specific serum IgE, IgG, IgA and IgM will be performed either by CAP-FEIA, by microarray measurement or ELISA. The measurement will be performed at the end of the study in all collected serum samples to minimize interassay variation. Measurement of basophil responses to allergen, fMLP and anti-IgE will be performed at each visit. Briefly, basophils will be exposed to various concentrations of anti-IgE, fMLP or recombinant allergens for 15 minutes and then examined for expression of CD 63 and CD203c by means of flow cytometry. Alternatively, histamine release will be determined by commercially available histamine release kits.
Pregnancy testing
In female patients, pregnancy will be excluded with a standard urine pregnancy test. The test will be performed before the first skin prick test at the screening visit and afterwards once a month.
Nasal specimen collection
Nasal specimen collection will be performed at all visits. For every visit specimens will be collected using nasosorption FXi/PU (containing a synthetic absorptive matrix (SAM)), or a 10 cm-long plastic curette (Both devices from Hunt Developments, UK)
Nasosorption using FXi/PU (Hunt Developments, UK):
Under visualization, the device will be inserted into the nasal cavity and be placed along the lateral wall against the inferior turbinate. The index finger of the patient will be used to press onto the external aspects of the alar and lateral nasal cartilages to hold the device in place. After 1 minute, the devices will be removed and the fluid will be extracted by centrifugation. Supernatant will be frozen at -70°C until further analysis for the presence of allergen-specific and total Ig levels, mediator and cytokine levels.
Mucosal mRNA sampling A 10cm nasal curette will be used. Under direct visualisation the curette will be brought to lie against the mid-inferior portion of the inferior turbinate. The curette will be pressed against the mucosal surface moved outwards 2-3 times. This motion will be repeated 2-3 times to ensure good sample collection. This curette and technique have been shown to cause no significant discomfort to patients and thus it has the advantage of no requirement for local anaesthetic. After collection Cells will be lysed in Qiagen RLT buffer and stored at -70C for later mRNA analysis.
4.9 Intranasal challenge
Birch pollen extract (Allergopharma, Vienna, Austria) will be freshly diluted in sterile 0.9% sodium chloride solution and will be administered using a metered pump. The allergen will be administered using a metered pump delivering 15 μl per puff to both nostrils at visit N1, N2, N3. If the patient is suffering from nasal or eye symptoms after the challenge, azelastine nasal spray or desloratadin 5mg will be supplied.
Randomization Procedure
At visit N1 of the main study, patients will be randomized to one of the two groups (Birch pollen extract or Placebo). Study subjects will be randomized (ratio 2:1 for provocation versus control) using the online randomization programme "randomizer" (www.meduniwien.ac.at/randomizer), which is maintained at the Institute for Medical Informatics, Statistics and Documentation at Medical University of Graz, Graz, Austria. The 2:1 ratio is chosen because the variance of Ig measurements and derived quantities is expected to be larger in the provocation group due to expected larger overall Ig levels, also see the sample size consderations later in this document.
The randomization will be carried out by a person who is not involved in the study and has no contact with the patients to ensure that the study will be double blinded.
Investigational products and study medication
Birch Pollen Extract:
Birch pollen extract (Allergopharma, Vienna, Austria) will be used for intranasal challenge. Birch pollen extract will arrive lyophilised and will be dissolved in sterile 0.9% sodium chloride. The content of Bet v 1 in the extract will be determined by immunoblotting using antibody probes specific for Bet v 1. Finally the extract will be diluted so that the final concentration of Bet v 1 will be 50 μg/ml as this concentration has previously been shown to elicit changes in specific IgE levels upon nasal challenge.
Control solutions:
Control solutions will comprise sodium chloride 0.9% as negative control for skin prick test and as placebo for intranasal challenge. Histamine (Allergopharma, Vienna, Austria) will be used as a positive control for the skin prick test. They will be stored according to the manufacturer's instructions.
Concomitant medication
General:
All additional medication being taken by the subjects on entry to the study or at any time during the study are regarded as concomitant medication and will be documented in the Source Data File. Concomitant medications should be kept to a minimum during the study, but if considered necessary may be given if not interfering with the study protocol.
Rescue medication:
Although anaphylactic events are very unlikely in this study they always have to be considered possible. Therefore a complete emergency kit will be available immediately in case of anaphylactic reactions at SPT or nasal challenge. Furthermore if the patient is suffering from nasal and eye symptoms after the intranasal challenge azelastine nasal spray and/or desloratadin 5mg will be provided to ameliorate the symptoms.
Prohibited concomitant medication:
Subjects must remain off medications interfering with study procedures for the duration of the study. The following concomitant treatments are not permitted during this study:
Adverse events
An adverse event is any event during a clinical study, including intercurrent illness or accident, which impairs the well-being of the subject; it may also take the form of an abnormal laboratory value. The term adverse event does not imply a causal relationship with the study treatment.
All subjects experiencing adverse events - whether considered associated with the use of the study treatment or not - will be monitored until symptoms subside and any abnormal laboratory value has returned to baseline, or until there is a satisfactory explanation for the changes observed, or until death, in which case a full pathology report from a qualified pathologist will be provided. All findings must be reported on an "adverse event" page in the case record form.
All adverse events will be reported on and documented as described below. Adverse events are divided into the categories "serious" and "non-serious". This determines the procedure which must be used to report/document the adverse event.
Definition of serious and non-serious adverse events
A serious adverse event is:
Adverse events which do not fall into these categories are defined as non-serious.
Assessment of severity of AE
Regardless of the classification of an adverse event as serious or non-serious (see above), its severity must be assessed as mild, moderate or severe, according to medical criteria alone:
Mild = does not interfere with routine activities, acceptable Moderate = interferes with routine activities Severe = impossible to perform routine activities, considered as unacceptable by the physician, requires treatment, requires discontinuation of study, or has residual effect.
It should be noted that a severe adverse event need not be serious in nature. Regardless of severity, all serious adverse events must be reported on as below.
Reporting/documentation of adverse events
Adverse events are collected by spontaneous reporting.
Reporting/documentation of serious adverse events
All serious adverse events which occur during this study whether considered to be associated with the study medication or not, must be documented on an "Adverse event" page in the case record form.
A follow-up report including all new information obtained on the serious event must be prepared and will be collected.
The investigator will submit on request copies of all these reports to the ethics committee. Where necessary, investigators will inform the authorities.
Reporting/documentation of non-serious adverse events
These are to be documented on an "Adverse event" page in the case record form.
Statistical analysis
As this is a pilot study, the performed analysis are considered as explorative and hypothesis generating.
Patient characteristics and outcome variables will be described by calculating maximum, minimum, median, mean and standard deviation for metric variables and absolute and relative frequencies for categorical variables.
To analyse time-trajectories of IgE levels and other outcome variables, descriptive statistics as well as 95% confidence intervals for the mean will be calculated for each time-point and each treatment group separately. To account for heterogeneous baseline levels between patients, the observed outcomes for each patient will be standardized by the respective baseline values for these analyses. Further, mean differences between groups and according 95% confidence intervals will be calculated for each time-point. For graphical illustration, the individual trajectories of each patient will be plotted.
The data observed in the skin prick test consists of a series of allergen doses and the resulting area measurements. Based on preliminary data from eight patients in previous study, an exponential model of the type Area = A*(1-exp(-λ Dose) was found to appropriately describe the dose-response relationship observed in the skin prick test. The model will be fit for of each time point in each group using a non-linear least squares algorithm. From these models, the response rate λ, the plateau area A and the 50% effective dose will be reported together with 95% confidence intervals.
If there are missing values, all analysis will be done on an available case basis.
Sample size considerations:
Given the exploratory nature of the study, the sample size considerations are based on the precision of parameter estimates. The primary objective is the analysis of IgE levels across time. Date from a previous study show a relative increase of anti-Bet v 1 IgE four weeks after nasal provocation with Bet v 1 by a mean factor of 1.4 and a standard deviation of approximately 0.5 between patients. With a control antigen, the mean factor was 1.04 with a standard deviation of approximately 0.25. The maximal statistical precision for a comparison of mean values between the two groups is achieved if the allocation ratio is proportional to the ratio of standard deviations, which is 2:1 based on the previous data. Under the above assumptions on effect sizes and standard deviations, a total sample size of 30 (20:10) will provide 95% confidence intervals with a half-width of approximately 0.2 in either group. The expected half-width of a 95% confidence interval for the mean difference between groups is 0.28. (A corresponding two-sample t-test would have a power of 80% to detect a mean difference of 0.4 at a 5% significance level). For the analysis of the skin prick test, the preliminary data suggest that with a sample size of 20, the half-width of 95% confidence intervals for the 50% effective dose will be approximately 0.25 times the 50% effective dose, which is considered as sufficient precision for this pilot study. Please see appendix for graphical representation
Ethical and legal aspects
The study will be carried out in keeping with local legal requirements and GCP. It will be performed in accordance with the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki (1964), including current revisions.
Informed consent of subject
Before being admitted to the study, the subject must have consented to participate after the nature, scope and possible consequences of the clinical study have been explained in a form understandable to him/her. The subject must give consent in writing. The signature of the investigator will confirm the subject's consent. The patient may withdraw the consent, even without giving comments, at any time and without negative consequences for his future medical care.
Acknowledgement/approval of the study
Before the start of the study, the study protocol will be submitted to the Ethics committee of the medical university Vienna and the general hospital of Vienna (Borschkegasse 8b/E 06, 1090 Vienna, Austria).
Insurance
All subjects participating in this study will be insured at the Zürich Insurance company (Zürich-Versicherungs-Aktiengesellschaft, Schwarzenbergplatz 15, 1010 Vienna, Tel. +43 50 1255 1255; insurance number: 07229622-2).
Confidentiality
All subjects' names will be kept secret in the investigators files. Subjects will be identified throughout documentation and evaluation by the number allotted to them during the study. The subjects will be told that all study findings will be stored and handled in strictest confidence.
Documentation and use of study findings
Documentation of study findings
All results collected during the study will be collected in a source data file and will later be transferred to the case report forms (CRFs). All entries on the case record forms will be made legibly in black or blue ink. If corrections are made to entries in the case record form, the words or figures will be ringed and a single stroke drawn through them. The correct value will be entered beside the old entry and date and the correction will be initialled. Incorrect entries must not be covered with correcting fluid or obliterated or made illegible in any way. The completed CRFs will be signed by the investigator. CRFs will be completed immediately after the final examination. The medical records upon which the CRF is based will be kept for at least 15 years.
Use of the study findings
The findings of this study will be published by the investigators in a scientific journal and presented in scientific meetings. The manuscript will be circulated to all co-investigators before submission.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: