Randomized Controlled Trial of the Scleroderma Patient-centered Intervention Network Hand Exercise Program
Randomized Controlled Trial of the Scleroderma Patient-centered Intervention Network Hand Exercise Program
The Scleroderma Patient-centered Intervention Network (SPIN) is an organization established by researchers, health care providers, and people living with scleroderma (systemic sclerosis or SSc) from Canada, the USA, and Europe. The objectives of SPIN are (1) to assemble a large cohort of SSc patients to complete outcome assessments regularly in order to learn more about important problems faced by people living with SSc and (2) to develop and test a series of internet-based interventions to help patients manage aspects of their disease, including hand limitations.
In SSc, approximately 90% of patients experience significant hand function limitations, which impact overall disability more than any other aspect of the disease. The SPIN hand exercise program was designed by SPIN experts in rehabilitation, behavioural therapies, and e-health interventions, as well as patient representatives in SPIN. The program core consists of 4 modules that address specific aspects of hand function, and integrates tools to support key components of successful self-management programs, including goal-setting and feedback, social modeling, and mastery experiences.
The SPIN-HAND trial is a pragmatic randomized control trial (RCT) embedded in the SPIN Cohort that will evaluate the effect of SPIN's online hand exercise program, in addition to usual care, on hand function and health related quality of life (HRQL) in SSc patients with at least mild hand function limitations. SPIN will randomize 586 SPIN Cohort participants with at least mild hand function limitations and an indicated interest in using an online hand exercise program to be offered the hand exercise program or usual care only.
For individuals with SSc, skin and tendon involvement of the hands with significant functional impairment is nearly universal. Hand function limitations impact disability more than any other aspect of the disease. However, given the challenges of conducting high-quality, adequately powered clinical trials and disseminating disease management tools in a rare disease context, proven rehabilitation interventions, including those for hands, are typically not available to rare disease patients. To address this gap, the Scleroderma Patient-centered Intervention Network (SPIN) was founded to (1) assemble a large, multinational cohort of SSc patients as a framework for large-scale rehabilitation and self-management intervention trials; and (2) to develop, test, and disseminate effective disease management tools to patients with SSc.
The SPIN Cohort currently includes over 2000 English- and French-speaking patients from over 40 sites in Canada, the USA, France, and the United Kingdom. SPIN Cohort patients complete outcome measures via the internet upon enrolment and subsequently every 3 months. SPIN utilizes the cohort multiple RCT (cmRCT) design as a framework for conducting trials of interventions. SPIN Cohort patients consent to allow their data to be used for observational research, to assess intervention trial eligibility and, if eligible, be randomized. They also consent that if eligible and randomized to usual care, their data can be used to evaluate intervention effectiveness without them being notified that they have been randomized to the usual care group and not offered the intervention. Thus, in SPIN trials, trial status is masked for patients in the control arm, but not the intervention arm.
The SPIN-HAND trial will evaluate the effect on hand function and HRQL of offering SPIN's online hand exercise program, in addition to usual care, to Cohort patients who have at least mild hand function limitations. The SPIN hand exercise program was designed by SPIN experts in rehabilitation, behavioural therapies, and e-health interventions, as well as patient representatives in SPIN. The program core consists of 4 modules that address specific aspects of hand function, including (1) Thumb Flexibility and Strength (3 exercises); (2) Finger Bending (3 exercises); (3) Finger Extension (3 exercises); and (4) Wrist Flexibility and Strength (2 exercises). The program also integrates tools to support key components of successful self-management programs, including goal-setting and feedback, social modeling, and mastery experiences. 586 SPIN Cohort participants will be enrolled in SPIN-HAND. Eligible patients will be able to use the online intervention in English or French, have at least mild hand function limitations (Cochin Hand Function Scale (CHFS) ≥ 3) and have indicated high interest in using an online hand exercise intervention (≥6 on 0-10 scale).
Randomization will occur at the time of patients' regular SPIN Cohort assessments. Eligible patients, based on questionnaire responses, will be randomized automatically with a 3:2 ratio, using a feature in the SPIN Cohort platform, which provides immediate randomization and complete allocation sequence concealment. A 3:2 ratio is being used in order to increase the number of patients who receive the intervention and to support secondary analyses that examine compliers versus non-compliers.
Trial outcomes will be assessed immediately pre-randomization and at 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, and 24 months post-randomization via the SPIN Cohort for both patients randomized to be offered the intervention and patients who receive usual care only. The primary outcome analysis will compare CHFS scores between eligible patients offered the intervention and those not offered the intervention at 3 months post-randomization. Secondary outcomes will include patient-reported health status, usage logs, user satisfaction, and HRQL.
Statistical analyses will be done blind to trial arm allocation. For the primary analysis, an intent-to-treat approach that compares all patients randomized to be offered versus not offered the intervention will be used. Intervention effects will be estimated using a generalized linear model, adjusted for baseline CHFS scores, recruitment centre, sex, age, disease duration, and diffuse versus limited SSc status. Missing data effects will be investigated using multiple imputation.
Analysis of secondary outcome variables and time points will be done similarly. In addition, complier-average causal effect analysis will be used to estimate effects among patients who accept the intervention offer compared to similar patients in the usual care group. Analysis of usage log data will be conducted to understand the association of uptake and use patterns with intervention effect.
Inclusion Criteria:
SPIN Cohort inclusion criteria:
For SPIN-HAND:
Exclusion Criteria: