Prophylactic Use of a Negative Pressure Incision Management System in Infrainguinal Vascular Surgery - A Multicentre Randomized Controlled Trial
Prophylactic Use of a Negative Pressure Incision Management System in Infrainguinal Vascular Surgery - A Multicentre Randomized Controlled Trial
Negative pressure wound therapy (NPWT) has been used in treating postoperative SSI with encouraging results and is now an accepted element in the arsenal of tools for treating these complications. The concept of applying NPWT to closed surgical wounds as a preventive measure is relatively new but draws on the inherent properties of the method which could theoretically lead to reduced seroma formation, wound dehiscence, increased capillary circulation and consequently better wound healing and fewer SSI.
Given the incidence and the consequences of SSI in infrainguinal vascular procedures any appreciable decrease in the burden of these complications could have profound benefits for patients and healthcare facilities. As to date, there are no published data from randomized controlled trials investigating the effectiveness of this prophylactic measure.
The aim of this study is to assess the effect of NPWT applied to closed surgical wounds directly after skin closure compared to standard sterile gauze dressing in reducing the incidence and severity of postoperative SSI in infrainguinal surgical wounds in patients undergoing elective, open vascular surgery.
Intervention and Surveillance:
The groin incisions in the intervention group will have NPWT dressing, applied under sterile conditions in the operating room. The NPWT will remain on the patient until postoperative day 7 or earlier if the vacuum seal is broken for any reason. If the NPWT is removed earlier than 7 days, a sterile gauze dressing will be applied to the incision.
The control group will receive a sterile gauze dressing, applied under sterile conditions in the operating room. The dressing van if needed be changed under sterile conditions at the ward on the second postoperative day. The dressing will remain on the patients until postoperative day 7. The dressing may be changed (by a research nurse or the attending surgeon), under sterile conditions if needed during the 8-day period.
After the initial 8-day period, patients in both groups will be supplied with sterile gauze dressings for an additional 6 days during which dressing changes may be carried out under sterile conditions.
All groin incisions will be examined, evaluated and categorized by a qualified research nurse or the attending surgeon, who will be blinded to the initial treatment modality, on the seventh postoperative day, 30 days postoperative and again after three months. Wound cultures will be taken (when possible) if the ASEPSIS score at any one of the three examinations is equal to, or exceeds 21 points.
Preoperative preparations will be the same for both groups. All patients will receive three doses (one pre- and two postoperative) of antibiotic prophylaxis on the day of the operation. Groin incisions will be closed with subcutaneous and intracutaneous monofilament absorbable sutures.
All patients will be asked to respond to the 36-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36) and the European Quality of life - Five dimensions (EQ-5D) questionnaires at the time of inclusion and at the one month follow up visit. The Wound QoL (Swedish) questionnaire will be presented to the patients at the one-week follow up.
Primary Endpoint:
• Postoperative SSI within 30 day, classified according to the scoring method ASEPSIS (Additional treatment,Serous discharge, Erythema, Purulent exudates, Separation of the deep tissues, Isolation of bacteria and in-patient Stay) and graded using the Samson classification (Grade I-V), confirmed by positive identification of the infectious agent.
Secondary Endpoints:
Postoperative SSI within 90 days, classified according to the scoring method ASEPSIS (Additional treatment,Serous discharge, Erythema, Purulent exudates, Separation of the deep tissues, Isolation of bacteria and in-patient Stay) and graded using the Samson classification (Grade I-V), confirmed by positive identification of the infectious agent.
Based on previous studies the incidence of postoperative groin SSI is 30-35%. Recent studies using NPWT have shown a reduction in incidence of 50% or more.
Using a sample size calculator (Sealed Envelope Ltd., Clerkenwell Workshops, London EC1R 0AT, UK) for binary outcome superiority trials with an alpha level of 0.05 for 80% power and an estimated incidence reduction from 30% to 10% using NPWT a sample size of 59 patients in each arm and a total sample size of 118 is required.
Randomization will occur once the skin incision has been closed. In cases of bilateral groin incision the right groin will be randomized and the left allocated the other arm of the trial. The surgeons, the operating room personnel and the investigators evaluating the outcome will not be blinded to the intervention.
Missing data will be treated based on the type data missing. In cases where missing data will affect the primary outcome the cases wil be deleted but accounted for in the final report.
Statistical Analysis Plan:
The data from each patient will be analysed using appropriate statistical methods for categorical and continuous and comparative analysis in respect to risk factors and outcome, both primary and secondary as previously defined. Absolute risk increase or reduction, as well as numbers needed to treat for NPWT use will be reported.
Analysis of primary outcomes will be done based on the intention to treat principle. Student's t-test and Pearson's chi-square or Fisher's exact test for continuous and categorical data, respectively. In cases where bilateral incisions are planned, the right groin will be randomized and the left will receive the alternate treatment. For subjects lost to follow up, the last recorded follow up/outcome will be recorded as their final outcome.
Analysis of secondary outcome data will be done according to normal distribution of data whrereby non-normally distributed data will be analysed using the Mann-Whitney U-test.
All tests will be 2-sided and P ≤ 0.05 will be considered statistically signinficant for all tests.
The statistical analyses will be done using SPSS version 23 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA).
All patients will be asked to respond to the 36-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36) and European Quality of life - Five dimensions (EQ-5D) and Wound QoL questionnaires at the time of inclusion and at the one month follow up visit.
The data from these questionnaires will be stratified and analysed using appropriate statistical methods.
Ethical considerations:
General regulations The study will be performed in accordance with the declaration of Helsinki as revised at the 64th WMA General Assembly in Fortaleza, Brazil, October 2013. Approval of the study protocol has been obtained from the Regional Ethics Committee.
Informed consent Prior to enrolment all patients will receive written and oral information about the study. The patients will only be included after obtaining written and informed consent.
Inclusion Criteria:
Patients older than 18 years.
The clinical criterion for study entry is elective:
a. Open infrainguinal vascular surgery for peripheral arterial disease
i. Thrombendarterectomy (TEA) ii. Bypass surgery with vein or synthetic graft
Patients on whom complete seal of NPWT can be maintained during the first 24 hours after operation.
-
Exclusion Criteria: