The purpose of this study is to evaluate a new counseling tool for patients deciding whether or not to undergo prostate cancer screening. This screening decision aid is a computer program that provides individual patients estimates of their risks of prostate cancer diagnosis, prostate cancer related death, or death from any cause. The researchers are evaluating whether or not patients find this screening decision aid helpful. As part of this study, participants will be asked for their response on questionnaires.

If patients find the screening decision aid helpful, the researchers will make it available at other clinic locations.

To conduct a feasibility study on implementing the computer-based screening decision aid for prostate cancer screening in a primary care setting during a 60-minute interview. To aid in informed decision making, the screening decision aid will include a graphical representation of predicted probabilities of prostate cancer diagnosis, prostate cancer-specific mortality, death from competing causes based on a man's unique demographic information. The study team will provide standardized counseling followed by individualized counseling with the screening decision aid. It will assess the quality of the decision making process (patient feels knowledgeable, informed of the risks/benefits, feels clear about their values, is involved in the decision), and quality of the decision.

Inclusion Criteria:

• Life expectancy > 10 years
• Ability to read English

Exclusion Criteria:

• Personal history of prostate cancer
• Personal history of prostate biopsy or prostate surgery
• Prior prostate specific antigen screening in the past year leading up to their scheduled clinic visit
• Cognitive impairment