Comparison of LigaSure Technology to the Conventional Electrocoagulation in Video-assisted Thoracoscopic Surgery (VATS) Lobectomy Followed by Systemic Lymphadenectomy: A Prospective Randomized Controlled Study
Comparison of LigaSure Technology to the Conventional Electrocoagulation in Video-assisted Thoracoscopic Surgery (VATS) Lobectomy Followed by Systemic Lymphadenectomy: A Prospective Randomized Controlled Study
Surgical treatment of lung cancer consists of two elements: anatomical lung resection (segmentectomy, lobectomy or pneumonectomy) followed by mediastinal lymph node dissection (MLND). Since over last 15 years the growing rate of resection is performed by minimal invasive approach - video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS). The study is focused on the clinical and technical aspects of MLND during VATS lobectomy. The extension of lymph nodes resection is strictly specified. The main benefit of MLND for the patient is precise histopathological staging, which allows choosing the best therapeutic option of adjuvant therapy. MLND is related with potential minor and major complications (bleeding, increased volume of chest tube drainage, prolonged chest tube duration and hospital stay, chylothorax, left recurrent laryngeal nerve injury, injury of the bronchus, injury of the esophagus). The majority of complications are caused by thermal injury resulting from the use of heat-generating monopolar electrocautery that is commonly used during lymph nodes dissection. In addition, thermal energy generation in case of monopolar electrocautery may lead to systemic inflammatory response and increased surgical injury. High-energy sealing devices like LigaSure™ allow for dissection, coagulation and cutting with the single instrument. Compared to mechanical ligation techniques (vessel loops, clips) or monopolar electrocautery, LigaSure™ technology has been shown to reduce: intraoperative blood loss (in colorectal, gynecologic and urologic surgery), surgery time (in colorectal, gynecologic and urologic surgery), length of hospital stay (in gynecologic and urologic surgery). Investigators hypothesize that application of LigaSure™ in VATS anatomical resection may lead to diminished complications rate, lower systemic inflammatory response and shorter length of stay compared to monopolar electrocautery.
Summary
Surgical treatment of lung cancer consists of two elements: anatomical lung resection (segmentectomy, lobectomy or pneumonectomy) followed by mediastinal lymph node sampling (MLNS) or mediastinal lymph node dissection (MLND). Since over last 15 years the growing rate of resection is performed by minimal invasive approach - video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS). This technique is used in at least 60% of patients with lung cancer operated on in the leading centers. The study project is focused on the clinical and technical aspects of MLNS/MLND during VATS lobectomy. Lymphadenectomy has to be performed obligatory in case of lung cancer resection. The extension of lymph nodes resection or sampling is strictly specified and should be the same independently from the surgical approach (thoracotomy or VATS). The main benefit of MLNS/MLND for the patient is precise histopathological staging, which allows choosing the best therapeutic option of adjuvant therapy. It was proved that MLND is superior to MLNS in its accuracy however the improvement of local control of the disease is not proved.
Mediastinal lymphadenectomy is related with potential minor and major complications. The risk of complications is low but in case of their occurrence hospital stay is usually significantly prolonged, quality of life decreases and additional surgery may be needed. In very small group of patients complications may lead to severe disability or death.
The most frequent complications related with MLND are:
The majority of the above mentioned complications are caused by thermal injury resulting from the use of heat-generating monopolar electrocautery that is commonly used during lymph nodes dissection. Bleeding or chylothorax are usually caused by incomplete blood or lymphatic vessels closure. Esophageal or bronchial wall injury can be caused by thermal injury followed by ischemia, necrosis and finally perforation. The diagnosis is frequently delayed. In addition, thermal energy generation in case of monopolar electrocautery may lead to systemic inflammatory response and increased surgical injury. Extent of surgical injury measured by acute phase proteins levels (c-reactive protein, alpha-1-antitrypsin, alpha-1-acid glycoprotein, haptoglobin) and interleukin levels was proved to be correlated to long-term results in patients with colorectal cancer.
Introduction of new high-energy sealing devices like LigaSure™ to clinical practice allows for dissection, coagulation and cutting with the single instrument. Compared to mechanical ligation techniques (vessel loops, clips) or monopolar electrocautery, LigaSure™ technology has been shown to significantly reduce:
There have been no randomized studies comparing the use of traditional electrocautery and LigaSure for lymphadenectomy during VATS resection due to non-small cell lung cancer.
Investigators hypothesize that application of LigaSure™ in VATS anatomical resection may lead to diminished complications rate, lower systemic inflammatory response and shorter length of stay compared to monopolar electrocautery.
Study design
Patients with early stage NSCLC who are routinely operated on by VATS will be randomized into two groups. First group called electro-VATS (Monopolar electrocautery) will be operated on with the use of traditional electrocautery and the second called liga-VATS (LigaSure) with the use of LigaSure. In the first group during the whole procedure (dissection of pulmonary ligament, mediastinal pleura and adhesions, as well as hilar dissection and lymphadenectomy) only traditional monopolar electrocautery will be used. In the liga-VASTS patients only LigaSure will be applied,no monopolar electrocautery will be used. The procedure of VATS lobectomy or segmentectomy will be performed in standardized fashion with separate stapling of hilar vessels and bronchus and lung parenchyma division. The hilar dissection and mediastinal lymphadenectomy will be performed using either monopolar electrocautery or LigaSure according to the randomization. The extent of lymphadenectomy will be the same in both groups and will include stations 2R,4R,7,8R,9R,10R,11R on the right side and stations 5,6,7,8L,9L,10L,11L on the left side. The number of removed lymph nodes will be counted. The extension of lymphadenectomy will be controlled and supervised by main investigator. Deep temperature inside the esophagus at the level approximately 2-3 cm below the carina will be measured during lymphadenectomy in order to assess the differences in the exposure of the surrounding tissues to the thermal energy generated by either LigaSure or electrocautery. The temperature measurement should in some part reflect the potential risk of thermal injury to the esophagus caused by different energy devices.
Investigators plan to enroll 200 patients, 100 patients in each group. Initial assessment will include age, gender, comorbidities (Charlson Comorbidity Index, CCI and Thoracic Revised Cardiac Risk Index, thRCRI scores) and pulmonary function tests. The following factors/parameters will be measured/compared in both groups: 24-hour, 48-hour and total volume of chest tube drainage, chest tube duration and hospital stay, rate of the prolonged air leak, rate of redo surgery due to bleeding, rate of postoperative complications related to the procedure, intraoperative blood loss and time of the surgery, local thermal effect, systemic inflammatory response after surgery.
Statistical analysis
The analyzed data will be presented as means, standard deviations, minimum and maximum values, medians, interquartile ranges (lower quartile, upper quartile) or percentage, as appropriate. Normality of the distribution will be tested with the Shapiro-Wilk's test, and the equality of variances will be checked with the Levene's test. For comparison of groups, unpaired t test or one-way ANOVA (for data which follow normal distribution and homogeneity of variances) or Welch test will be applied. In case data will not normally distributed nonparametric tests will be used - Mann-Whitney U test or the Kruskal-Wallis test with the Dunn's post-hoc test. Categorical data will be analyzed with the χ2 test or the Fisher-Freeman-Halton test. The relationship between variables will be analyzed with the Pearson's linear correlation coefficient or the Spearman's rank correlation coefficient or (and) by multivariate linear regression. All the results will be considered significant at p<0.05. Statistical analyses will be performed with statistical packages: STATISTICA 10.0 PL (StatSoft. Inc.) or StatXact 9.0 (CytelStudio) software.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria: