Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
In collaboration with Vitality/Discovery in South Africa, an RCT amongst adult enrolled in the lowest tier of Vitality's HealthyFood benefit will be conducted. We will compare the effect of various messaging, and financial incentive strategies on healthy food purchasing behaviors in this population.
The Vitality HealthyFood benefit is a three-tiered incentive program designed to encourage healthier food choices amongst members of Discovery Health's Vitality program. Once enrolled in the benefit, participating members can receive 10%, 15%, or 25% cash-back on the healthy foods they purchase at selected grocers. And, while overall enrolment in the program is high, there was been difficulty documenting change in purchasing behaviors; healthy foods have remained a consistent 25-30% of food spend, and unhealthy foods at around 15%. In the current study we would like to test whether differing types of messages and financial incentive structures may be more salient and motivating and have a greater impact on food-purchasing decisions. The proposed study will be a collaboration between Discovery Health/Vitality and researchers at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. In the proposed RCT, Vitality members currently enrolled in the lowest tier (10% level) of the HealthyFood will be randomized to various messaging and financial incentive structures. We will then compare the effectiveness of these different interventions at increasing healthy food purchases among enrolled members.
This study will be a randomized field trial of the combination of several theoretically-motivated interventions: varying weekly messaging, financial incentives, and monthly messaging.
Messaging and financial incentives
Weekly Messaging strategies There are three weekly messaging strategies we want to test. The goal of the messages is to increase the salience of the HealthyFood programme for enrolled members. The three strategies were chosen to enable us to compare the impact of no weekly message vs. a general weekly message vs. a tailored weekly message. The messages will be sent via SMS to all subjects and will be delivered on the same day of the week.
No weekly message-A subset of study subjects will receive no weekly SMS message. This is consistent with the current benefit structure.
General weekly message-A subset of study subjects will receive a weekly SMS that provides general information on the HealthyFood programme and on eating a healthier diet.
Personalized (tailored) weekly message-A subset of study subjects will receive a weekly SMS that includes details about their individual purchasing behavior over the past week. This message will highlight both the percentage and item breakdown of their purchases that were healthy vs. unhealthy.
Financial Incentive Structures
There are three different incentive structures we will test in this study. The goal of the financial incentives is to increase members' motivation to purchase healthy foods. Two of the strategies are currently part of the HealthyFood programme, the third is a new structure which introduces a economic disincentive on the purchase of unhealthy foods.
10% cash-back: This is the current cash-back level for all subjects at the start of on the study. This group is included as a comparison for the other incentive structures.
25% cash back: A subset of study subjects will experience an increase in their cash-back percentage from 10% to 25% of healthy food purchases. The purpose of this group is to assess whether the increase from a 10% level to a 25% level of cash-back is sufficiently large to influence purchasing behaviors.
10% + 15% (healthy-unhealthy): A subset of study subjects will become eligible for additional 15% cash-back above their current 10% level. This additional 15% cash-back will be based on the net monetary amount between their healthy and unhealthy purchases. With this structure, an individual will only receive additional cash-back (above the 10%) if they spend more on healthy foods than on unhealthy foods, and will be able to maximize their cash-back rewards by purchasing only healthy foods.
Monthly Messaging Strategies
Currently all Vitality members enrolled in the HealthyFood programme receive a monthly SMS message informing them of their cash-back deposit.
Bundled deposit SMS (standard)-This message will be the same message that Vitality currently sends to members enrolled in the program me.
Unbundled deposit SMS-Given the introduction of a new incentive structure which includes a penalty for unhealthy purchases, we wanted to test a message strategy which increases the salience of these potential financial losses.
By combining these different weekly messages, incentive structures, and monthly message, the study team determined the aforementioned 6 study arms of interest.
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
| Label | Type | Description | Intervention Names |
|---|---|---|---|
| Control--no weekly message | No Intervention | 10% cash back level, no weekly message, and the standard monthly message | |
| General Weekly Message | Experimental | 10% cash back, general weekly message, standard monthly message |
|
| Personalized Weekly Message | Experimental | 10 % cash back, personalized weekly message, standard monthly message |
|
| 25 percent cash back | Experimental | 25% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message |
|
| Standard monthly message | Experimental | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message |
|
| Unbundled monthly message | Experimental |
| Name | Type | Description | Arm Group Labels | Other Names |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Messaging | Other | See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study |
|
| Measure | Description | Time Frame |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly % Healthy Food Expenditure | The difference in monthly healthy food expenditures between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly amount spent on healthy foods divided by the total monthly amount spent on food, multiplied by 100. For those individuals who had no recorded expenditure in a given month, they will be assigned 0% healthy food expenditure that month; in this way, this outcome can be considered a composite score of being engaged in the healthy food program (0%=not engaged) and the level of engagement (if monthly expenditure >0). Each individual's data will be averaged across the intervention period. | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
| Measure | Description | Time Frame |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly % Unhealthy Food Expenditure | The difference in monthly unhealthy food expenditures between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly amount spent on unhealthy foods divided by the total monthly amount spent on food, multiplied by 100. The average over the full intervention months will be calculated within an individual and compared between arms. To be complementary with the primary endpoint analysis, in a month where an individual is not engaged in the program (0 total monthly expenditure) the worst-score (100) is imputed for that month. A similar MI approach will also be conducted as a sensitivity analysis. |
Not provided
Inclusion Criteria:
For this study, we will focus on the following individuals:
Exclusion Criteria:
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
| Name | Affiliation | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Alison Buttenheim, Phd | University of Pennsylvania | Principal Investigator |
Not provided
| PubMed Identifier | Type | Citation | Retractions |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31151390 | Derived | Gopalan A, Shaw PA, Lim R, Paramanund J, Patel D, Zhu J, Volpp KG, Buttenheim AM. Use of financial incentives and text message feedback to increase healthy food purchases in a grocery store cash back program: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Public Health. 2019 May 31;19(1):674. doi: 10.1186/s12889-019-6936-5. |
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
| ID | Title | Description |
|---|---|---|
| FG000 | 10% Cash, no Weekly Message, Standard Monthly SMS | 10% cash back level, no weekly message, and the standard monthly message |
| FG001 | 10% Cash, General Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10% cash back, general weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| FG002 | 10% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10 % cash back, personalized weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| FG003 | 25% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 25% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| FG004 | 10+15%NET Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| FG005 | 10+15%NET, Personal Weekly SMS, Unbundled Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, unbundled monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| Title | Milestones | Reasons Not Completed | ||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Study |
|
|
Not provided
Not provided
| ID | Title | Description |
|---|---|---|
| BG000 | 10% Cash, no Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10% cash back level, no weekly message, and the standard monthly message |
| BG001 | 10% Cash, General Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS |
| Units | Counts |
|---|---|
| Participants |
|
| Title | Description | Population Description | Parameter Type | Dispersion Type | Unit of Measure | Calculate Percentage | Denominator Units Selected | Denominators | Classes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age, Continuous | Mean |
| Type | Title | Description | Population Description | Reporting Status | Anticipated Posting Date | Parameter Type | Dispersion Type | Unit of Measure | Calculate Percentage | Time Frame | Units Analyzed | Denominator Units Selected | Arm/Group Information | Denominators | Classes | Analyses | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary | Monthly % Healthy Food Expenditure | The difference in monthly healthy food expenditures between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly amount spent on healthy foods divided by the total monthly amount spent on food, multiplied by 100. For those individuals who had no recorded expenditure in a given month, they will be assigned 0% healthy food expenditure that month; in this way, this outcome can be considered a composite score of being engaged in the healthy food program (0%=not engaged) and the level of engagement (if monthly expenditure >0). Each individual's data will be averaged across the intervention period. | Posted | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percentage of money per month | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
|
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
| ID | Title | Description | Deaths (Affected) | Deaths (At Risk) | Serious Events (Affected) | Serious Events (At Risk) | Other Events (Affected) | Other Events (At Risk) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EG000 | 10% Cash, no Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10% cash back level, no weekly message, and the standard monthly message |
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
| Title | Organization | Phone | Extension | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anjali Gopalan | Kaiser Permanente Northern California Division of Research | 510-891-3458 | Anjali.Gopalan@kp.org |
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, unbundled monthly message |
|
| Financial incentives | Other | See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
|
| Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
| Monthly % Healthy Items | The difference in monthly healthy food items purchased between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly number of healthy food items divided by the total monthly number of food items. The average over the full intervention months will be calculated within an individual and compared between arms. To be complementary with the primary endpoint analysis, in a month where an individual is not engaged in the program (0 total monthly expenditure) the worst-score (0) is imputed for that month. A similar MI approach will also be conducted as a sensitivity analysis. | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
| Monthly % Unhealthy Items | The difference in monthly unhealthy food items purchased between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly number of unhealthy food items divided by the total monthly number of food items. The average over the full intervention months will be calculated within an individual and compared between arms. To be complementary with the primary endpoint analysis, in a month where an individual is not engaged in the program (0 total monthly expenditure) the worst-score (100) is imputed for that month. A similar MI approach will also be conducted as a sensitivity analysis. | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
| Percentage Change in Monthly % Healthy Food Expenditures Between Arms | Examining the difference in healthy food expenditure trends between arms where the % health food expenditure is defined as describe for outcome 1 (above) | During the 6 month intervention period |
| Percent Change in Monthly %Unhealthy Food Expenditures Between Arms | Examining the difference in unhealthy food expenditure trends between arms where %unhealthy food expenditure is defined as described for Outcome 2 (above). | During the 6 month intervention period |
| Percent Change for Monthly % Healthy Food Items Between Arms | Examining the difference in proportion healthy food item trends between arms where % healthy food items is defined as described for Outcome 3 (above) | During the 6 month intervention period |
| Percent Change in Monthly %Unhealthy Food Items Between Arms | Examining the difference in proportion unhealthy food item trends between arms where % unhealthy food items is defined as described for Outcome 5 (above). | During the 6 month intervention period |
10% cash back, general weekly message, standard monthly message
Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study
Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study
| BG002 | 10% Cash Back, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10 % cash back, personalized weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| BG003 | 25% Cash Back, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 25% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| BG004 | 10+15%NET Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Weekly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| BG005 | 10+15%NET Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Unbundled Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, unbundled monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| BG006 | Total | Total of all reporting groups |
| years |
|
| Sex: Female, Male | Count of Participants | Participants |
|
| Household Size | Mean | Standard Deviation | people |
|
| Vitality membership length | Mean | Standard Deviation | Weeks |
|
| Region | Count of Participants | Participants |
|
| Shopping trips | Mean | Standard Deviation | trips per month |
|
| Monthly healthy spending | Mean | Standard Deviation | Rand (South African currency) per month |
|
| Monthly unhealthy spending | Mean | Standard Deviation | Rand (South African currency) per month |
|
| Monthly neutral spending | Mean | Standard Deviation | Rand (South African Currency) per month |
|
| Monthly healthy items | Mean | Standard Deviation | Items per month |
|
| Monthly unhealthy items | Mean | Standard Deviation | Items per month |
|
| Monthly neutral items | Mean | Standard Deviation | Items per month |
|
| Monthly proportion of spending on healthy foods | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percent of spending |
|
| Monthly proportion of spending on unhealthy foods | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percent of spending |
|
| Monthly proportion of food items that were healthy | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percent of items |
|
| Monthly proportion of food items that were unhealthy | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percent of items |
|
| OG001 |
| 10% Cash, General Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS |
10% cash back, general weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| OG002 | 10% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10 % cash back, personalized weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| OG003 | 25% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 25% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| OG004 | 10+15% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
| OG005 | 10+15%NET Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Unbundled Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, unbundled monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study |
|
|
| Secondary | Monthly % Unhealthy Food Expenditure | The difference in monthly unhealthy food expenditures between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly amount spent on unhealthy foods divided by the total monthly amount spent on food, multiplied by 100. The average over the full intervention months will be calculated within an individual and compared between arms. To be complementary with the primary endpoint analysis, in a month where an individual is not engaged in the program (0 total monthly expenditure) the worst-score (100) is imputed for that month. A similar MI approach will also be conducted as a sensitivity analysis. | Posted | Mean | Standard Error | Percentage of money per month | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| Secondary | Monthly % Healthy Items | The difference in monthly healthy food items purchased between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly number of healthy food items divided by the total monthly number of food items. The average over the full intervention months will be calculated within an individual and compared between arms. To be complementary with the primary endpoint analysis, in a month where an individual is not engaged in the program (0 total monthly expenditure) the worst-score (0) is imputed for that month. A similar MI approach will also be conducted as a sensitivity analysis. | Posted | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percentage of items per month | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| Secondary | Monthly % Unhealthy Items | The difference in monthly unhealthy food items purchased between arms. This measure is defined as the monthly number of unhealthy food items divided by the total monthly number of food items. The average over the full intervention months will be calculated within an individual and compared between arms. To be complementary with the primary endpoint analysis, in a month where an individual is not engaged in the program (0 total monthly expenditure) the worst-score (100) is imputed for that month. A similar MI approach will also be conducted as a sensitivity analysis. | Posted | Mean | Standard Deviation | Percentage of items per month | Monthly over 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| Secondary | Percentage Change in Monthly % Healthy Food Expenditures Between Arms | Examining the difference in healthy food expenditure trends between arms where the % health food expenditure is defined as describe for outcome 1 (above) | Posted | Mean | Standard Error | percentage change in % healthy spending | During the 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| Secondary | Percent Change in Monthly %Unhealthy Food Expenditures Between Arms | Examining the difference in unhealthy food expenditure trends between arms where %unhealthy food expenditure is defined as described for Outcome 2 (above). | Posted | Mean | Standard Error | Percent change in % unhealthy food spend | During the 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| Secondary | Percent Change for Monthly % Healthy Food Items Between Arms | Examining the difference in proportion healthy food item trends between arms where % healthy food items is defined as described for Outcome 3 (above) | Posted | Mean | Standard Error | Percent change in % healthy food items | During the 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| Secondary | Percent Change in Monthly %Unhealthy Food Items Between Arms | Examining the difference in proportion unhealthy food item trends between arms where % unhealthy food items is defined as described for Outcome 5 (above). | Posted | Mean | Standard Error | Percent change in % unhealthy food items | During the 6 month intervention period |
|
|
|
| 0 |
| 1,188 |
| 0 |
| 1,188 |
| EG001 | 10% Cash, General Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10% cash back, general weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study | 0 | 1,252 | 0 | 1,252 |
| EG002 | 10% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10 % cash back, personalized weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study | 0 | 1,220 | 0 | 1,220 |
| EG003 | 25% Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 25% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study | 0 | 1,206 | 0 | 1,206 |
| EG004 | 10+15%NET Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Standard Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, standard monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study | 0 | 1,243 | 0 | 1,243 |
| EG005 | 10+15%NET Cash, Personal Weekly SMS, Unbundled Monthly SMS | 10%+15% cash back, personal weekly message, unbundled monthly message Messaging: See detailed study description for overview of the different messaging interventions in this study Financial incentives: See detailed study description for overview of the different financial incentive-based interventions in this study | 0 | 1,205 | 0 | 1,205 |
Not provided
Not provided