Clinical Efficacy of Platelet Gel From Cord Blood for the Treatment of Diabetic Foot Ulcers
Clinical Efficacy of Platelet Gel From Cord Blood for the Treatment of Diabetic Foot Ulcers
A novel method (PCT n. WO 2010/007502 A2, 2010) has been developed to obtain platelet gel from umbilical cord blood (CBPG). The main advantages so far identified in CBPG as compared to platelet gel derived from adult platelets relate to the lack of microbiological contamination in the former and to a different profile of growth factors concentrations, such as a higher content of VEGF and lower content of TGF in CBPG. Recent developments have led to a procedure in which CBPG can be prepared, stored in a cryopreservation bag and applied to the skin ulcer without breaking the sterility chain. In spite of promising results on allogeneic CBPG, a randomized clinical trial of sufficient statistical power to detect significant advantages (clinical and economical) will be performed in patients affected by diabetic foot ulcers and randomly treated with CBPG versus standard local medications (SLM).This study is a multicenter (8 centers) controlled randomized clinical trial. Outcomes: (1) primary objective is to evaluate the number of closed skin ulcers within 4 weeks of treatment with CBPG vs standard local medications; (2) secondary objectives are percent skin ulcer closure area, number and type of adverse events and cost of treatment. Sample size calculation: 95 + 5 (dropout) test and 95 + 5 (dropout) control patients ensure 80% power to detect as statistically significant (p<0.05) >60% healing in test vs 40% healing in control.Each clinical centre has been invited to enrol 15 treated and 15 control patients, according to local availability in 12 months. CB units are routinely collected after mother's informed consent before and after placenta delivery in accredited public cord blood banks belonging to the Italian Cord Blood Network (ITCBN) coordinated by the Centro Nazionale Sangue (CNS). After storage and transportation at monitored room temperature, the units will be processed for the preparation of CBPG within 48 hours of collection. CBPG will be prepared according to standard procedures with a defined final platelet concentration (0.8-1.2 x 109/L). The CBPC units will be finally cryopreserved in a -80°C freezer in view of the clinical use of the CBPG, which will require thawing at 37°C in a waterbath and activation with Calcium gluconate. For SLM, each clinical center will use their validated standard procedures.
Background information and study rationale: Evidence no. 1 (platelet gel). The gel obtained upon platelet activation of platelet rich plasma with thrombin or with pharmaceutical extracts of cobra venom is a blood component that has been used for clinical purposes for a number of years. The rationale supporting this therapy relates to the high content of growth factors in platelet alpha granules that can be delivered topically by a natural biocompatible carrier (i.e. the platelets) upon platelet activation. So far, platelet gel has been mainly used to repair recalcitrant skin ulcers in diabetic and non-diabetic patients in an autologous blood donation setting. Unfortunately, most candidates to this therapy are elderly patients, frequently affected by a number of pathologic conditions and comorbidities which make them mostly unfit or unsuitable for the process of autologous blood collection. In practice, most patients who could mostly benefit from this therapy are de facto deprived of a potentially effective treatment because of this limitation.
Evidence no. 2 (blood transfusion safety). Current systems for blood donor screening by viral nucleic acid testing have dramatically reduced the risk of transmission of infectious conditions through the transfusion of blood and blood components. Accordingly, limitations to the use of allogeneic blood and blood components that were mandatory some decades ago do not find current justification. This opens the perspective of an increased use of allogeneic blood components - including platelet gel - with potential advantages for large numbers of patients in whom they are mostly indicated.
Evidence no. 3 (platelet gel from cord blood). A research group led by the investigator proposing the present project has recently developed a novel method (PCT no. WO 2010/007502 A2, 21 January 2010) to obtain platelet gel from the newborn's blood remaining in the placenta after delivery, aka umbilical cord blood or placental blood. The main advantages so far identified in platelet gel derived from cord blood platelets as compared to platelet gel derived from adult platelets relate to the lack of microbiological contamination in the former and to a different profile of growth factors concentrations, the main difference consisting in a higher content of VEGF and lower content of TGF in cord blood platelet gel. Recent modifications performed have led to a procedure in which platelet gel from cord blood can be prepared and stored in a small plastic bag rather than in tubes or dishes, which can be easily cryopreserved, stored, transported to sites of clinical use and applied to the skin ulcer without breaking the sterility chain. This paves the way for a broader use of allogeneic cord blood platelet gel inside and outside hospitals.
Evidence no. 4 (knowledge gaps). In spite of interesting and promising results on allogeneic cord blood platelet gel, three elements are missing before the latter may be used extensively in patients who may need it: (1) a more complete biochemical characterization; (2) a regional or national program to collect and prepare the necessary doses of cord blood platelet gel; (3) a randomized clinical trial of sufficient statistical power to detect significant advantages (both clinical and economical) in patients treated with cord blood platelet gel versus controls treated with skin ulcer advanced medications. In this regard, small scale investigations suggest that the effective use of platelet gel may reduce recalcitrant skin ulcer medication costs to one tenth of costs currently reimbursed to hospitals for ineffective advanced medication (from about 190.000 euro to about 19.000 euro to treat 11 elderly patients).
Evidence no. 5 (cord blood banking and transplant). Cord blood - which was once disposed as a hospital waste - is currently a precious source of hemopoietic stem cells to be used for bone marrow replacement in patients affected by severe blood diseases. The last 25 years of clinical experience with this stem cell source has shown that high cell dose and better HLA match are the most important factors impacting on patient survival. For this reason, cord blood banks preferentially cryopreserve cord blood units with very large volumes, as volume correlates with cell content, and discard about three quarters of units collected. It is expected that the discard rate will increase in the future, also because the worldwide inventory of about 600.000 cord blood units in 128 cord blood banks already includes units with volumes that are currently considered sub-optimal for hemopoietic transplant. It is therefore expected that 70-80% of cord blood units donated for allogeneic hemopoietic transplant may be unsuitable for this use and ultimately discarded. These units can be used for the preparation of platelet gel if a suitable program of recovery from delivery suites, transportation to a production site and processing into platelet gel is developed.
Study design: This study is a multicenter controlled randomized clinical trial (Allogeneic cord blood platelet gel (CBPG) vs Standard local medications (SLM)). Each clinical centre has been invited to enroll 15 treated and 15 control patients, according to local availability in the 12 month study interval.
Sample size calculation : 95 + 5 (dropout) test and 95 + 5 (dropout) control patients ensure 80% power to detect as statistically significant (p<0.05) >60% healing in test vs 40% healing in controls (Pocock, 1983).
Principles of Statistical analysis: Descriptive statistics: summary tables by treatment group (except for baseline characteristics which will be provided by sequence and overall) according to the type of variable summarised; quantitative criteria: standard quantitative statistics (N, mean, SD, median, min-max); qualitative criteria: frequency distribution [number of non-missing observations (N) and percentages (%)].
CBPG preparation and quality control: CB units are routinely collected after mother's informed consent in plastic bags containing 21-29 mL of citrate-phosphate-dextrose (CPD) anticoagulant by trained midwives, before and after placenta delivery in natural deliveries and in cesarean sections respectively, according to locally validated standard operation procedures, in accredited public cord blood banks belonging to the Italian Cord Blood Network coordinated by the Centro Nazionale Sangue. After storage and transportation at monitored room temperature, the units will be processed for the preparation of CBPG within 48 hours of collection. Based on a previous standardization exercise, the participating banks will be allowed to use locally available bags of convenient size and nominal volume that they consider appropriate for this protocol. In the above standardization exercise, it was decided to define the main characteristics of the final CBPC as follows: target mean volume 10 ml, range 5-15; target mean platelet concentration 1 x 109/L, range 0.8 - 1.2 x 109/L. The latter concentration was selected in agreement with the platelet concentration defined by the Italian Society of Transfusion Medicine for platelet gel obtained from adult blood. CBPG will be prepared according to procedures defined during pilot studies at each bank, which included an initial centrifugation of CB at 200-210 g x 10-15 minutes, followed by the transfer of the platelet rich plasma (PRP) into a secondary bag, centrifugation of the PRP at 1800-2600 g x 15 minutes and removal of the supernatant platelet poor plasma (PPP) in excess of the final target volume of the CBPC. The latter was defined by an automated algorithm performed by an Excel spreadsheet used for data collection, which takes into account the platelet concentration in the PRP and the minimum (0.8 x 109/L) and maximum (1.2 x 109/L) values of the platelet concentration aimed at in the final CBPC. The platelet concentrations in the PRP divided by 0.8 and by 1.2 x 109/L provide the upper and lower bounds of the CBPC volume respectively. The final volume was set by determining the net weight of the CBPC on an electronic scale. The CBPC units will be finally cryopreserved in a -80 °C mechanical freezer in view of the clinical use of the CBPG, which will require thawing at 37° C in a waterbath and activation with Calcium gluconate. For the standard local medications, each clinical center will use their validated standard local medications. Details and specifications of the local standard medication procedures will be collected from each participating centre.
Treatments: Test treatments: CBPG is a gel formed by fibrin trapping platelet fragments from about 10 billion platelets in 10 mL of neonatal plasma anticoagulated with CPD. It is stored in a commercial PVC bag for blood component preparation and storage.
In the '80s, David Knighton developed a technique for in vitro stimulation of platelets, with thrombin solutions that allowed to collect a supernatant abundant of growth factors. This product, derived from patient platelets was locally applied as gel to encourage the ulcer repair.
The rationale in the use of such product is in the presence of several tissue growth factors: P.D.G.F. (Platelet Derived Growth Factor); E.G.F. (Epidermal Growth Factor); T.G.F. (Transforming Growth Factor); V.E.G.F. (Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor); I.G.F. 1 e 2 (Insulin Growth Factor 1 and 2); F.G.F. (Fibroblast Growth Factor). Applying in situ the iper-concentrated and activated platelets as platelet gel, tissue regeneration processes are started and accelerated. In this setting, platelets are similar to cellular laboratory-tanks that process, store and then release (if activated) several growth factors able to stimulate mesenchymal stem cell regeneration as fibroblasts, osteoblasts and endothelial cells. This platelet ability to take part in tissue repair mechanisms has been the theoretical essential requirement to use the platelet gel in several circumstances, all associated with the requirement of tissue repair activation.
Repeated PG applications have been shown to be useful prior to wound surgery since they can reduce lesion size, improve anatomic and morphological conditions of wound bed and margins and trigger neo-angiogenesis at the margins and within the necrotic area.
Usual source of platelet fractions is adult human blood, but this source involves relevant drawbacks and problems. Peripheral blood from a human cannot be used without potential risks due to alloreactivity, resulting in several clinical complications. On the other hand, the availability of autologous blood is generally low, since it can be dangerous to withdraw a sufficient amount from a patient who cannot tolerate such a withdrawal. Moreover, allogeneic blood from adult donors can involve risks of infections.
Platelet fractions derived from human placental blood can avoid the above drawbacks and also contain high concentrations of platelet factors.
Dosage and Administration: For the medication of patients enrolled in the treatment arm, one CBPG unit (mean volume 10 ml, range 5-15; mean platelet concentration 1 x 109/L (0.8 - 1.2 x 109/L) will be administered every 3-4 days. CBPG units, cryopreserved and stored in a small plastic bag in a -80°C freezer, will be thawed at 37°C in a waterbath and activated with Calcium gluconate and immediately transported to sites of clinical use and applied to the skin ulcer without breaking the sterility chain.
Efficacy assessment: Efficacy will be evaluated with the CBPG-DFU Clinical Research Form.
Safety assessments: Information will be collected on all adverse events and on events associated with CBPG that will occur during treatment. Care and management efforts provided at each treatment visit will include cleansing and assessing the wound and obtaining vital signs and an interim wound history, including information regarding adverse events, concomitant medications, nutrition and weight-bearing status.
Inclusion Criteria
Exclusion criteria