Developing New Treatments for Tourette Syndrome: Therapeutic Trials With Modulators of Glutamatergic Neurotransmission
Developing New Treatments for Tourette Syndrome: Therapeutic Trials With Modulators of Glutamatergic Neurotransmission
A joint NIH -Tourette Syndrome Association Conference has emphasized the critical need for the testing and development of new pharmacotherapy for tic suppression in Tourette syndrome (TS). This submission is a safety, tolerability and efficacy pilot study using two medications that modulate glutamate neurotransmission, riluzole, a glutamate antagonist, and D-serine, a glutamate agonist. Glutamate is the primary excitatory neurotransmitter in the central nervous system, an essential component of pathways implicated in TS and an extensive modulator of dopamine, the major neurotransmitter associated with tics.
This is a single site, short-term, proof of concept study of riluzole and D-serine for the treatment of tics. Each medication will be evaluated and compared to placebo as part of a double-blind, randomized, parallel, flexible dose, three-arm, 8-week, treatment protocol (D-serine, riluzole, or placebo). A total of sixty patients (age 8-17 years) with TS and moderate to moderately-severe tics will receive study medication according to a 2:1 (dopamine modulating drug: placebo), randomized schedule, i.e., riluzole (n=24), D-serine (n=24), placebo (n=12). The primary outcome measure is tic suppression as determined by changes in the Total Tic Subscore of the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS). Secondary tic outcome measures include changes in the YGTSS Total Score and two Global Impression Scales. Further, since both riluzole and D-serine have been proposed as treatments for obsessive-compulsive behaviors, a TS co-morbidity, these symptoms will be followed. Safety measures include serial physical examinations, vital signs, laboratory studies (comprehensive metabolic panel, complete blood count, plasma amino acids, and urine analyses), documentation of side effects and adverse events, and measurement of changes in ADHD, depression and anxiety.
This pilot investigation will provide important proof-of-concept data on glutamate therapies for TS and, in turn, evidence for large-scale, multi-center clinical trials.
Study Design Overview: The goal of this study is to perform a short-term, proof of concept study to examine the safety, tolerability and efficacy of riluzole and D-serine in the treatment of tics. Each medication will be evaluated and compared to placebo as part of a randomized, double-blind, flexible dose, parallel, eight-week protocol, containing six weeks of active treatment (D-serine, riluzole, or placebo). A total of sixty patients (age 8-17 years) with Tourette syndrome or chronic motor tics (Tourette Syndrome Study Group criteria) having moderate to moderately-severe tics will participate; riluzole (n=24), D-serine (n=24), placebo (n=12).
This study contains six weeks of active treatment with D-serine, riluzole or placebo. The decision to implement a 6-week treatment protocol was based on the following: a) the ability to gradual increase doses of medication on a weekly basis over the first five weeks to dosages beneficial in other conditions; b) a treatment duration similar to that used in other glutamate modulatory treatment studies; and c) a time period necessary to identify a treatment effect in milder non-neuroleptic tic-suppressing medications such as clonidine. We emphasize that this is a short term, proof of concept study for riluzole and D-serine in the treatment of tics. Specific questions such as long term durability of beneficial effects, potential long-term side-effects, and comparisons to non-drug interventions are important, but not a focus of this pilot study.
The study will begin with a screening evaluation to ensure that each subject satisfies all eligibility criteria and to allow subjects to become familiar with our assessment procedures. Randomization of medications contained in look-alike capsules will occur at the baseline visit and is performed by a member of the Research Pharmacy staff. Patients will be evaluated at baseline, have direct formal scheduled evaluations at the end of treatment week's 2, 4, and 6 (+ 2 days), have telephone evaluations at the end of treatment week's 1, 3, and 5 (+ 2 days), and a final visit at 8 weeks. The primary outcome measure is effective tic suppression as determined by the difference in the Total Tic subscale (TTS) scores of the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS) at baseline and 6 weeks. Secondary outcome measures will include the change from baseline and 6 week scores for the YGTSS total score, the Clinical Global Impression -Improvement (CGI-I), and Patient Global Impression of Improvement (PGI-I). Secondary outcome for obsessive-compulsive behaviors will be measured by changes in the Children's Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale (CY-BOCS). Safety measures will include the use of an expanded Pittsburgh Side Effect Scale modified to include side effects of riluzole and D-serine, incidence of adverse events, measurement of vital signs (BP, pulse) and body weight, physical examination, laboratory studies (comprehensive metabolic panel (CMP), complete blood count (CBC), plasma amino acids, and urine analysis), the DuPaul ADHD Rating Scale, Child Depression Inventory-short version (CDI-S), and Multi-Dimensional Anxiety Scale for Children (MASC). A Drug Safety Monitoring Board containing three clinician-scientists with experience in pharmacological trials will meet quarterly to review this study.
1. Study Population:
a) Recruitment: Subjects with TS/CMT (ages 8-17 years) will be recruited from the Tourette Syndrome Clinic at the Johns Hopkins Hospital and child psychiatry practice.
Patients with TS/CMT will be candidates for this study if: 1) they are tic-suppressing drug naive; 2) are not currently on treatment for TS (off medications for at least three weeks); or 3) if, in the judgment of the Investigators (Dr Singer and Grados), they are not adequately managed using current therapy (prescribed for greater than one month) and are willing to maintain a constant dose throughout the protocol. We believe that limiting the study to include only "drug-free" subjects would have a negative impact on recruitment. Many individuals with moderately severe to severe tics (TTS > 22) are receiving medications and in our opinion requiring prolonged tapers and extended drug free intervals are not in the best interest of the patient.
4. Procedures: i) Screening visit ( - 3 to -1 weeks): Determination of diagnostic eligibility criteria: medical history, complete physical examination (weight, heart rate, blood pressure, respiratory rate); familiarization with assessment procedures, rating scales for: tics, the Yale Global Tic Severity Scale (YGTSS), Clinical Global Impression-Severity Scale (CGI-S), obsessive-compulsive problems, Children's Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (CY-BOCS); attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, DuPaul ADHD Rating Scale, depression, Child Depression Inventory- Short Version (CDI-S); and anxiety, the Multidimensional Anxiety Scale for Children (MASC). Informed consent and child assent will be obtained. Urine (urine analysis) and blood (comprehensive metabolic panel, complete blood count, and plasma amino acids) will be obtained. Females who have begun to menstruate will be screened with a blood pregnancy test. Parents will be told the results of these tests. If the patient is uncomfortable with our telling the results of the pregnancy test to her parent(s), then they may decide not to take part in this study.
ii) Baseline Visit (Day 0): Determination of diagnostic eligibility criteria and the results of blood and urine analysis studies will be reviewed. Evaluation will include weight, heart rate, blood pressure, and respiratory rate, physical examination, rating scales for tics, obsessive-compulsive problems, ADHD, depression, and anxiety. As part of the baseline visit, the PI and Study Coordinator will meet with the parent to explain the procedures for dose titration, review in detail the outcome measures, and review approaches to administering medication (e.g., providing the pill with water or other beverage, observing the child swallow the medication without biting or chewing). Following confirmation of study eligibility, Dr Singer will forward a request for medication to the Johns Hopkins Research Pharmacy.
iii) Randomization (Day 0): A computer generated unequal randomized scheme will be used by a research pharmacist in the Johns Hopkins Research Pharmacy to assign patients to riluzole, D-serine, or placebo. The pharmacist making the treatment assignment will be proved with all essential data including patient name and study number, age, weight, and a list of concurrent medications. Subjects already on medications will be equally distributed among treatment groups. Twenty-four subjects each will be randomized to riluzole and D-serine and twelve to placebo. Medications, packaged in look-alike capsules, will be distributed by The Johns Hopkins Research Pharmacy. All medication codes will be retained by the research pharmacist until the completion of the study. All study medication will be double-blind: the Investigators, Study Coordinator and patient/parent will not be aware of the treatment assignment.
iv) Treatment groups (weeks 1 through 6): All treatments will be packaged in look-alike capsules. Patients will receive a 16 day supply of medication at the Baseline visit, and at the 2 and 4 week visits. Medications will be administered for the first week on a qday basis (morning) and thereafter on a twice a day schedule (morning and bedtime).
Each subject will be contacted at the end of weeks 1, 3, and 5 by telephone and evaluated in person end the end of weeks 2, 4, 6, and 8.
The maximum number of capsules per day in each treatment group is five. In order to achieve this fixed number, if necessary, Research Pharmacy will provide an additional vial of capsules containing the appropriate medication (see drug descriptions).
Riluzole (Rilutek):
Selection of dosage: For reference, in adults with ALS, riluzole was safe and effective in dosages of 100 and 200 mg twice daily. In a treatment study of infants with spinal muscular atrophy the maximum dosage was 10 mg higher than a 107 mg/m2 dose, e.g., for a 5 kg child whose surface area was 0.33 m2 , the dose was 35 mg/day. No child had any change in laboratory studies or had adverse effects.
Selection and timing of doses for subjects: The starting dose of riluzole will be 50 mg for one week; administered as one capsule (50) every morning. Dosage schedules will be flexible. If needed for tic suppression, the dose will be increased weekly by 50 mg and given in BID doses. The maximum dose will be 200 mg/day (administered as 2 capsules BID). In any individual subject, dose escalation may proceed more slowly, or the dose may be reduced if necessary. At the 4 week visit, if an additional dosage increase is prescribed by Dr Singer, the pharmacy will provide an additional vial of 14 capsules labeled as study drug, but containing placebo (P) capsules. No changes in dosage will be made during the final week of treatment.
D-serine:
Selection of dosage: In man, D-serine is synthesized from L-serine via one enzymatic step catalyzed by the enzyme serine racemase. Levels of D-serine are controlled by the activity of serine racemase, the later having the highest expression in the forebrain. D-serine is currently being used in IND# 71,369 (D Javitt, PI). This approved serine will purchased by the Research Pharmacy at Johns Hopkins and encapsulated into capsules containing 250 and 500 mg of D-serine. The established treatment dose in the aforementioned IND is 30 mg/kg/day. In adults with schizophrenia and OCD, D-serine was safe and effective in dosages of 2 grams per day [Javitt Personal Communication].
Selection and timing of doses for subjects: The dosage schedule will be flexible with a maximum dose for each subject being 30 mg/kg/day. The following Table provides examples of subjects of different weights receiving increases of dosages. In any individual subject, dose escalation may proceed more slowly, or the dose may be reduced if necessary. At the 4 week visit, if an additional dosage increase is prescribed by Dr Singer, the pharmacy will provide an additional vial of capsules labeled as study drug, but containing either 250 (A) or 500 (B) mg tablets of D-serine or placebo (P); capsule content to be determined by patient's weight (see below). No changes in dosage will be made during the final week of treatment.
Placebo:
Placebo tablets will be formulated in look-alike capsules. At the 4 week visit, if an additional dosage increase is prescribed by Dr Singer, the pharmacy will provide an additional vial of 14 capsules labeled as study drug, but containing additional placebo (P) capsules.
Compliance: To assess medication compliance, subjects and parents will be asked at each evaluation point (telephone and visit) about their compliance. Subjects will be required to return their medication vials at each visit and Dr Singer will verify whether the number of tablets returned by the subject corresponds to the prescribed intake. Compliance is defined as taking >80% to <120% of the prescribed doses.
vi) Concomitant medication: At each patient visit (baseline, 2, 4, and 6 weeks) the patient/parent will be asked to provide the names of any prescribed medications, over-the counter or herbal preparations used since the last visit.
vii) Medication taper: At the completion of the 6 week treatment phase, medication will be tapered over a ten day period; reduction of one capsule every other day. The half life of riluzole is 12 hours.
viii) Post-intervention (end of week 8) follow-up and management By the end of week 8, the subject will be completely off the study medication. Since study medications cannot be continued following completion of the protocol, this visit will, in part, be devoted to establishing ongoing care and treatment. All subjects will be offered ongoing care, treatment, and follow up with Dr Singer at Johns Hopkins. If the subject already has a treating physician, Dr Singer will be available to provide consultative services. Neither the Investigators nor subjects will receive information about the experimental drug assignment until the entire study has been completed.
ix) Evaluations: This is an 8-week study (6 weeks treatment, 2 week taper). Telephone evaluations will be performed by Dr Singer at the end of week's 1,3, and 5. At each telephone contact, clinical response, possible side effects, drug compliance, and medication adjustment will be discussed. Each subject will have direct evaluations by Dr Singer at baseline and the end of week's 2, 4, 6.and 8. These evaluations will include a pill count (except baseline) to assure compliance and safety measures including physical examination, vital signs (BP, heart rate), weight, blood and urine studies, and assessment of side effects using the Pittsburgh side effects scale. Dr Grados, a blinded outcome evaluator, will administer and score the outcome measures at each of the subject's visits (baseline, end of weeks 2, 4, 6).
x) Early stopping rules: Subjects may be withdrawn from the study at any time at the discretion of the subject, primary care physician, or Dr Singer.
The Research Coordinator, with assistance of the Statistician, will prepare data for the quarterly review by the SMB from data stored on a secure computer. The SMB will act independently to review the data. If there is any safety concern related to one or more of these groups, then the Board may choose to identify the actual treatment groups by access to the randomization codes maintained by the pharmacy. Significant adverse events will be reported to the IRB, SMB and FDA within 24 hours.
Inclusion Criteria:
Exclusion Criteria:
Subjects with co-morbid ADHD, obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), and conduct disorder will not be excluded as long as these diagnoses are not the subject's primary problem