Prolonging the Duration on Site of Short Peripheral Venous Catheters Used to Administer Intravenous Antibiotics in Cystic Fibrosis Adults. Randomized Controlled Trial on the Effect of Different Concentrations of Antibiotic in Normal Saline
Prolonging the Duration on Site of Short Peripheral Venous Catheters Used to Administer Intravenous Antibiotics in Cystic Fibrosis Adults. Randomized Controlled Trial on the Effect of Different Concentrations of Antibiotic in Normal Saline
Patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) need to frequently undergo courses of IV antibiotic therapy. To avoid a high number of venipunctures peripheral venous catheters (SPVC) or cannulas are used. Because of the irritant action of the drugs used, SPVC's often do not last for the whole antibiotic course (usually of two weeks) and the patient has to be punctured again for the insertion of a new IV line. With the passing of time the veins are more difficult to be found. An alternative to the use of a cannulas is the surgical insertion of a central venous catheter. This intervention may have contraindications or, specially in adolescents, cause unacceptable alterations of the body image.
The aim of this study is to find a way to prolong the duration of the SPVC used by CF patients during antibiotic courses avoiding the irritation of the vein or a phlebitis.
Design of the study: randomized controlled trial. The study will see a collaboration of nurses, physicians and technicians of the Tuscan CF Centre.
The patients that will participate at the study will be randomly assigned to one of the two groups: one group will receive the antibiotics prescribed according to the maximal dilution suggested by the pharmaceutical company, the other will receive a much higher dilution (i.e. a higher volume of Normal Saline), but the time of administration will be the same.
The assessment will regard: the level of inflammation of the vein (with a special visual scale) and the duration of the SPVC.
The hypothesis that is to be proved is that diluting the antibiotic in a higher volume of Normal Saline it is possible to delay or prevent the irritation of the vein and the onset of a phlebitis.
In case that the hypothesis will be confirmed by this study an easy, secure, low cost and immediately available system will be available to reduce the number of venipunctures necessary to complete a course of IV antibiotics.
Background
Cystic Fibrosis (CF) is a common genetic disease which affects, among other organs, the respiratory tree. The major cause of mortality and morbidity in CF are pulmonary infections caused by a limited number of bacteria, in particular gram negative bacteria such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) and Burkholderia cepacia complex (BCC) which cause frequent clinically acute pulmonary infections.
Current figures show that 57.3% of patient have their lungs infected by PA and 2.9% of them have their lungs infected by BCC (1). To fight pulmonary exacerbations, patients frequently have to undergo antibiotic treatments, which often cannot be given orally or by aerosol but have to be administered intravenously (IV). Some CF Centers have also adopted a treatment protocol for patients chronically infected by respiratory pathogens in which a prophylactic IV course of antibiotic is routinely given every 3 months even in the absence of clinical symptoms of pulmonary exacerbations (2) An IV course of antibiotic treatment should be continued for at least 10 days but usually it lasts 2 weeks (3). Completing it would therefore require doing numerous venipunctures to a patient. In the USA, during 2004 some 45% of patients aged 18 to 30 required at least 1 IV antibiotic course, about 25% 2 IKV course and 15% 3 courses or more (1). This IV treatment regime brings a relevant burden of pain, anxiety and a worsening of quality of life (4). In order to reduce the number of venipunctures needed for an antibiotic course, several intravenous indwelling devices have been used to administer antibiotic infusion.
Some of these venous catheters are inserted in a central vessel. Among them, port caths and Groshong or Broviac type Central catheters, Midline catheters are those most commonly used (5-9). They are intended to last from several weeks to years. Their insertion requires a surgical intervention. Such an invasive intervention may not be sometimes indicated due to the patient's clinical condition. Moreover, the presence of a permanent device may influence the patients' body image and autonomy, with negative consequences in the psychological condition of the patient, especially in adolescence (10). Also, systemic infections may occur (11), the permanent management of the device may result complicated (12-15) and it may influence the patient's day-to-day life. Recently, a high incidence of thrombosis related to the insertion of this kind of catheters has been described (16) The most commonly used type of IV device to administer antibiotics in CF is the short peripheral venous catheter (SPVC) or cannula (17, 18) which has been considered for long now the simplest, most easy-to-use and economic way for administering IV therapy in CF. The use of this device allows patients not to be punctured at every administration and to eventually perform the antibiotic course at home avoiding hospitalisation and therefore maintaining a relatively normal daily life. Moreover, compared to the previously described permanent devices, this one is less invasive, it does not require a surgical intervention to be inserted, and it is intended to be maintained only for the duration of the treatment.
In order to facilitate CF people's autonomy and to reduce the conditioning of their quality of life, The home administration of IV antibiotic has become increasingly common (17-21). In 2004, 20.1% of US CF patients received home IV treatment (1). Patients themselves and their relatives are often trained by CF Centers' Nurses on how to manage the administration of the antibiotic treatment on their own.
Typical responsibilities of the CF Center's Nursing Staff is to position the SPVC, to manage the venous access and the drug infusions, to evaluate the site of the cannula insertion and the drug administration, and to educate patients on possible complications (21-23).
During the course, patency of the venous access between one antibiotic administration and the following is achieved by flushing the catheter at the end of each infusion either with normal saline or with heparin solution.
With the passing of time, SPVC insertion might become increasingly difficult due to the repeated venous trauma, which may lead to the formation of thrombi and the progressive occlusion of the vein; (17).
Due to the particular respiratory pathogens (PA, BCC) affecting CF patients' lungs the doses of antibiotics are much higher than those administered to non-CF patients with pneumonia. Even though it sensibly lowers the risk of infectious problems, the IV administration of such high doses of antibiotics, may irritate the veins' tunica intima and cause a phlebitis which may occlude the vein and therefore interrupt the vein's patency. Indeed, it is well established that the infusion of antibiotics and other irritant substances frequently cause iatrogenic phlebitis (24-28). Other factors have been discussed as risk factors for the onset of phlebitis and to a short duration of the SPVC (29); among others, the movement of the patient, his/her age, the type of SPVC, the type of dressing used, the site of insertion (30) the blood count, (25).
The onset of phlebitis oblige healthcare providers to the repositioning of the venous catheter in another site and to cause to the patient further suffering, pain and anxiety. Although scarcely investigated, the problem of reducing the amount of venipunctures and pain in CF patients is clinically important. A recent study by our research group has examined the recalls of adult CF patients about the invasive procedures received in childhood (31). The study has evidenced that repeated venipunctures imply an additional worsening of their quality of life and may influence the CF child future compliance to treatments.
So far only a few studies have investigated an effective way to prolong the duration of SPVCs used without causing a phlebitis, but they are substantially inconclusive (32,33) On the basis of the existing studies, it can be hypothesised that the volume of fluid in which the antibiotic is diluted, and consequently its concentration, may affect the veins' tunica intima irritation.
Specific Aims and Rationale
This study aims at investigating whether a different concentration of the prescribed dose of antibiotic in the infusate during intravenous administrations influences the inflammation of the vessels and the consequent duration of SPVCs in patients with CF undergoing antibiotic courses.
For each antibiotic to be administered IV, the producer, besides the type of infusate, provides also a suggested maximum concentration or a concentration range.
Theoretically it is possible to reduce the vessel's irritation by keeping the quantity of drug and the time of infusion constant, but diluting the prescribed amount of antibiotic in a larger volume of infusate, in a given interval of time. This would lead to a smaller number of drug molecules acting as irritants on the tunica intima.
Therefore, the aim of the study is to verify the hypothesis that a greater volume of infusate for constant amounts of drug dose and time, reduces the irritation of the vessel's tunica intima caused by the antibiotic and allows a longer patency of the vein and a longer use of the SPVC.
We will compare the outcomes of two different concentrations of antibiotic in Normal Saline, which is the mostly used infusate for IV administration of antibiotics. The type of the prescribed antibiotic and the time of infusion will stay the same. The CF center specialist physician will continue to prescribe drugs as usual, according to intern protocols and to patients' clinical conditions.
The eventual purpose of the study is to reduce patients' distress and discomfort when they are obliged to undergo antibiotic treatments which need invasive procedures. Indeed, if the tested hypothesis would be confirmed, simply increasing the volume of normal saline in which the antibiotic is diluted would lead to less vein irritation, lower incidence of phlebitis and a longer permanence of the SPVC used for an IV antibiotic course. This would imply a reduction of the number of venepunctures needed to complete an IV antibiotic course and a reduction of patient discomfort and pain.
Also, if the tested hypothesis would be confirmed, the solution proposed would be immediately applicable to the clinical practice, since it would not require any authorization process. Also, it would be of little expense and completely safe, unless any contraindications exists to the infusion of a higher volume of Normal Saline Besides this, CF Centers' Health Care Providers might have a simple, safe and relatively low-cost method to prolong the duration on site of a IV antibiotic course and to reduce the number of venepunctures given to the patient.
Preliminary results
Recently this same group of researchers has carried out an observational study, partially retrospective and partially prospective (34-36). We studied 87 SPVCs inserted to 36 patients in 56 IV antibiotic treatment cycles in a period of 6 months (mean duration 8.3 days). It has been evidenced that the gauge of the SPVC and the number of daily administrations are significantly correlated to the duration on site of the cannula. In particular, SPVCs with a larger gauge (G22) had longer mean duration than smaller (G24) SPVCs (9.6 days vs. 7.2 days, p=0.03) SPVCs used for antibiotic courses in which the antibiotic daily dose was divided into 3 administrations had a longer mean duration (10.3 days) than those used in courses in which the daily dose was divided into 2 administrations (6.5 days, p=0.001).
According to this study, other factors such as patients' age, the brand of the cannula, the health care professional who inserted the cannula, the site of insertion (dominating or non dominating arm), and the concurrent administration of oral anti-inflammatory drugs do not seem to influence the duration of the SPVC on site. The results of the study lead the researchers to hypothesise that the concentration of the antibiotic infusion i.e. its dilution might have an impact on the local inflammation of the vessel. Indeed, since each single administration was administered in the same infusion volume of 100 ml, the patients who had received the daily antibiotic dose divided in 3 administrations had received the same daily antibiotic dose diluted in a higher volume of fluids both daily and at each administration.
The study group is composed by Nurses, Physician and a Technician with a long experience in CF research. The group has carried out also other studies aimed at finding ways o that cures received by patients have as least impact as possible on their quality of life. In particular the study group's interest has focused on the issue of pain in CF patients (31, 37, 38).
Experimental Plan
Study design: Randomized controlled non-blinded clinical trial. The study will confront the effect of two different antibiotic concentrations administered IV on the inflammation of vein and on the duration in situ of the inserted SPVC.
The assignment of patients to one group or the other will be done by randomization. Randomization will be launched by a researcher blind in regards to patients. Data analysis will be done by a researcher blind in regards to patients.
The study will not influence the usual course of therapeutic treatment chosen by the specialized physician of the CF center. The only experimental variable will be the concentration of the dose of antibiotic prescribed by the physician in the infusate, or the volume of fluids needed to infuse the antibiotic.
In the aim of reducing the number of possible confounding variables, age range of the patients, SPVC gauge and brand, type of dressing, scales used for the evaluation of irritation and infiltration, type of antibiotics used, time of infusion, number of attempts for SPVC insertion will be standardized.
Authorization by the Ethic Committee of the Meyer Children Hospital has been obtained.
Subjects included to the study will sign an informed consent and the consent to treat their personal data. They will receive written information on the study.
Data will be analyzed and presented in aggregated form and by no means it will be possible to retrace the subjects to whom the data refer.
Subjects, Materials and Methods
This is a multidisciplinary study with participation of Nurse researchers, and Physician researchers They will participate in the study according to their own field of professional competences and legal responsibilities as described in the laws in force in Italy. In particular, Physicians will make diagnoses and order prescriptions and nurses will administer therapy, choose and use the most appropriate IV devices according to the clinical condition of the patient, notice and assess sign and symptoms with the use of validated scales, educate and instruct the patients on the therapy. Patients recruitment to the study will be done by the Physician and the Nurse together by assessing the fulfilment of inclusion criteria and by informing the patient.
The Nurses participating in the study will all be in possess of the qualification to practise the profession and of the graduate degree in Nursing or equivalent and will be instructed by the principal investigator in regards to the use of the assessment scales used in the study, the participants' inclusion criteria and the research protocol.
Inclusion criteria
To be included in the study subjects need to fulfil the following requirements:
The two experimental groups will have the following treatment:
Group A: Ceftazidime will be infused diluted in Normal Saline at the maximum suggested concentration of 40mg per ml of infusate. Time of infusion: 30 minutes.
Group B: Ceftazidime will be infused diluted in Normal Saline at the concentration of 10mg per ml of infusate. Time of infusion: 30 minutes.
For both group Tobramycin will be infused diluted in Normal Saline at the concentration of 1mg per ml of infusate (i.e., one half of the maximum suggested concentration of 1mg per ml of infusate). Time of infusion: 40 minutes.
Measured outcomes will be:
For each of the two groups calculation will be done on:
The proportion of subjects who will score 0 or 1 on the "Phlebitis Scale" for each single day of observation (1st day, 2nd day… up to the 14th) The mean duration of the first SPVC inserted for the treatment course
Statistical Analysis
Differences between proportions will be analysed with the Chi-square test. Differences between means of in situ durations of SPVCs will be analysed using the Student t-test.
Statistical significance level is established at 95%.
The removal of the first SPVC inserted for the antibiotic course concludes the participation of the subject to the study. The SPVC will be removed in the following cases:
The same subject can be readmitted to the study if 30 days have passed from the end of the previous course.
The subject is a drop-out if
The data on the level of inflammation of the vein taken up to the moment of drop out will be included in the analysis according to the intention to treat. The duration of the SPVC will not be taken into account.
Determining the sample numerosity
The CF Center of Tuscany takes care of 191 patients. 78 patients (41%) are adults and potentially recruitable for the study. All patients of the Tuscan Regional CF Center are seen in the Outpatients clinic regularly to evaluate clinical status and microbiology of respiratory tract secretions. According to the data found with the preliminary study done by this same group of research (34), the antibiotic courses that match the inclusion criteria for this study in one year will be about 50 in the Tuscan CF Centre of Florence.
To determine the numerosity of the sample for the t-test on the differences between means of SPVC durations, we fixed a power of the trial of 0.8. In the absence of reference measures, we hypothesise a minimum expected difference between the SPVC duration in the two experimental groups equal to that found in the preliminary study carried out by this research group (34) between patients who were given IV antibiotics 2 times a day and those who received them 3 times a day, that is, 3.8 days. Also, we hypothesize a standard deviation within each group equal to that found in the two groups of the preliminary study, that is, 5. On the basis of these expected values, the numerosity of the two experimental groups was determined in 30 for each group. Such number will be increased of a number of subjects equal to the number of drop-outs.
Randomization
A simple randomization method will be utilized. One of the participants of the research group will do the randomization and will have no other role in the study. He will be blind concerning patients and will not know neither their identity nor their clinical status. Every time that a patient will be recruited into the study by the researchers, the Physician and the Nurse that have done the recruitment will contact the researcher responsible for the randomization to communicate that a new patient has been included without giving any information on the patient. The person responsible for randomization will flip a 50 cent Euro coin into the air and will communicate the result. The recto of the coin (the one indicating the coin value) means inclusion into the Group A. The verso of the coin (the one with the national insign) means inclusion into the Group B. The person responsible for randomization will be reachable by telephone on a dedicated mobile phone during all the CF Center opening time.
The study will end when both groups will have reached the numerosity established a priori, plus the number of drop-outs.
Sequence or Timetable of the Project
January 2007: education of the Nurses and of the Physicians that work at the clinical aspects of the study (recruitment, cannulation, knowing of the research protocol and preparation of the expected concentrations; assessment of cannulation site and use of the scales, education of the patient); February 2007: beginning of the recruitment of patients and start of the study June 2007: first check of the recruited patients and of the quality of collected data October 2007: second check of recruited patients and of the quality of collected data Retraining of all persons who collaborate at the study by the Principal investigator.
February 2008: third check of the recruited patients and of the quality of collected data June 2008: fourth check of recruited patients and of the quality of collected data Retraining of all persons who collaborate at the study by the Principal investigator.
October 2008: fifth check of recruited patients and of the quality of collected data February 2009: 6th check of the recruited patients and of the quality of collected data Retraining of all persons who collaborate at the study by the Principal investigator.
June 2009: 7th check of recruited patients and of the quality of collected data November 2009: end of data collection. Insertion of paper data into a Microsoft Access 2000 database.
December 2009. Statistical analysis. Writing of final report. Paper sent for evaluation to a peer-reviewed scientific journal
Clinical protocols
Recruitment of patients In occasion of a patient's visit to the CF Center Outpatient Clinic, the Physician decides, on the basis of the clinical conditions of patient, of laboratory tests, of results of sputum culture and other instrumental and imaging diagnostic tests, whether he or she needs an antibiotic treatment, of what type and by which way of administration.
If the physician decides to prescribe an antibiotic, the inclusion criteria are verified. If all the criteria are satisfied, the subject is eligible for the inclusion in the study.
The patient will be invited to participate to the study and will be given the necessary information. After answering to all his/her questions, if the patient accepts the inclusion, the Physician and the Nurse will collect his/her written informed consent.
Subsequently the Nurse will call the researcher in charge of randomisation and will ask him the group to which the patient is assigned.
Subsequently, the Nurse will collect the initial data of the patient in the recruitment form. Then he will insert the SPVC.
Way of administration of treatment To administer the treatment only Gauge 22 SPVCs Intima BD will be used. Before the insertion of SPVC the use of a local anaesthetic cream will be proposed to the patient, if not clinically contraindicated.
Before insertion, the insertion site will be disinfected with Amukine 5% solution. Skin hair will not be removed.
After the insertion the SPVC will be fixed to the skin with a sterile transparent dressing.
The dressing will not be changed or taken away during the experimentation in order to avoid displacement of the cannula. The SPVC will be closed with a needleless lock cap for all assessed subjects.
Each infusion will be administered during a total of 70 minutes: 30 minutes for the ceftazidime and 40 minutes for the tobramycin. There will be no flushing between the first and the second antibiotic. At the end of each infusion, the cannula will be flushed with 1.5 ml of a heparin solution (25 U/ml in Normal Saline). During the experimentation the SPVC cannot be used for any other therapy nor for the taking of blood samples.
Preparation of the concentrations as for the research protocol:
Table 1 indicates the dilutions to be prepared for each single administration of ceftazidime, according to the prescribed dose Group A
Group B
Table 2 shows the dilution to prepare for every single administration of tobramycin, according to the prescribed dose.
Both groups
In order to facilitate the preparation of the antibiotics to infuse according to the concentrations shown by the research protocol, a pharmaceutical company will prepare Normal Saline bottles prefilled with the volumes needed for the study.
Clinical assessment
At the moment of recruitment in the study the following data will be collected:
Age and sex, FEV1 (percentage of the predicted), body mass index, PCR, microorganism in the sputum culture, number of attempts needed to insert the SPVC.
Every day, before the IV midday administration a researcher will assess:
The state of irritation of the vein in which the SPVC is inserted, using the "Phlebitis scale" of the Standard of Practice of the Intravenous Nurses Society (39), as follows Grade Clinical Criteria
The state of infiltration of the vein in which the SPVC is inserted, using the "Infiltration scale" of the Standard of Practice of the Intravenous Nurses Society (39) As follows.
The pain experienced locally by the patient using the numeric pain scale.
Adverse events, the physical activity performed and any other event related to the antibiotic course which may have occurred in the previous 24 hours, as described by the patient.
The researcher will ascertain, with questions and other checks, that in the previous 24 hours the dilution provided in the research protocol has been respected and that no violations of the protocol have occurred.
In rare cases, patients who have started the course as inpatients may continue it at their home, as described before (23). In these cases patients will be given a high resolution mobile videophone. The researcher will phone to the patient, will interview him and will assess the insertion site using the videophone. The validity of this kind of distance evaluation has been recently showed by a study performed on leg ulcers (41).
If the assessor scores the insertion site 2 or more in the "Phlebitis Scale", or 1 or more in the "Infiltration scale", or the patient reports a local pain of 3 or more in the pain numeric rating scale, the SPVC is removed and the observation of the subject in the study ends.
Quality controls
Every 4 months the Principal Investigator will verify the number of recruited patients and of the quality of collected data, analysing all the daily assessment forms. In case of drop-outs the number of patients to be recruited will be increased by an equal number of subjects.
Every 8 months the Principal Investigator will retrain all the collaborators involved in the study in particular with regard to: recruiting, vein cannulation, knowledge of the research protocol, preparation of antibiotic dilutions, use of scales, training of patient.
Safety
For this research we will not use any method or drug which deviate from the normal clinical practice; we will apply usual operational procedures for prevention of Clinical Risk approved for the Hospital by the Local Committee for Patient Safety and Clinical Risk Management, as provided by the Tuscan Regional Government Decree n. 1387/2004). Also, the Principal Investigator is a member of such Committee.
Adverse events relating to the participation to the study will be constantly monitored. A member of the study group will be always reachable by phone by patients for any problem that may occur during the study.
Data management and statistical analysis
Data will be stored in a Microsoft Access 2000 database. Statistical analysis will be performed by an independent free-lance Statistician, not belonging to the Researchers' Institution.
Inclusion Criteria: